>Generally speaking, is it easier to thread an end grain box or a side grain box?
I am playing around with hand threading, and I'm getting some pretty boogered up threads in an end grain experiment. I know the theory, and I think I'm doing it pretty well, but the results are that my threads aren't very sharp and show a lot of chipout.
I have a piece of dry cherry if that helps. I've lubed the cut with mineral oil, and it helps a bit, but still not the results I am looking for.
In my limited experience I don't know about "easier" but cutting into the side grain of an end grain box is more CONSISTENT all the way around as opposed to cutting with the grain, through end grain, with the grain, etc around the side grain box (face turned). Also, the end grain box is much more likely to stay round which may be more important for a threaded box than a lidded box.
I think biggest thing, assuming your cutters are sharp, is the type of wood. I've had walnut chip badly while cocobolo cut cleanly. I have resorted to soaking wood fibers in thin CA or lacquer-based sander sealer which strengthens the fibers.
Also, if the starting diameter for outside threads is not too big it will leave a little flat on the top of each thread instead of a sharp point which may break off.
Have you seen the book "Making Screw Threads in Wood" by Fred Holder? It is excellent reading. Also, a good resource is a chapter on threading in "Woodturning Techniques" by Mike Darlow - he covers the history, early machines, and a variety of techniques including cutting threads by hand with a chisel. Excellent reading.
>I decided that one of the best ways to figure some of the answers to my questions out was to just try it!
My experience with cherry was likely the result of the piece that I had chosen. I picked up another piece and had much better results with the wood in "side grain" orientation. Ditto with an old piece of maple.
I then took something that I was given by Harvey Fein at a club meeting. I don't know what it is, but it looked like olive, but didn't cut like olive. I proceeded to make a lot of mistakes in sizing, and continually managed to cross thread. Either the top was good and the bottom wasn't or vice versa. In the end, I was left with parting gifts only.
I supposed that I could also make a "Bonnie Klein" rig and forget the whole thing, but what would be the fun of that? Hand chasing threads certainly requires a little skill, a lot of planning, and some attention to detail, since you can't sand out your mistakes.
It is hard to beat African Blackwood or English Boxwood for making hand chased threads. I highly recommend either of these be used when trying to make threaded boxes. It is very difficult to do good hand chasing in the softer woods, although the coarser threads will hold up better in the softer hardwoods. I've been chasing threads since the early 1990's, my first successful thread was made with an 11 tpi chaser in Cocobolo and turning my lathe by hand to get it slow enough.
If you don't have boxwood or African blackwood, to learn on get a PVC pipe fitting and practice chasing threads in PVC, it threads very easly and allows one to get the feel for speed, etc. necessary to do good hand thread chasing.
I should also mention that epoxy threads very well. Cut recesses in the bottom of the top and the top of the bottom and pour then full of epoxy. After it sets, you can make excellent threads in the epoxy.
You can turn good threads if the grain of the wood is perpendicular to the axis of rotation so that you have some end grain and some side grain. I've chased threads in pine with this grain orientation. However, as someone else mentioned this is a problem if making boxes. Temperature and moisture can affect the wood and cause it to warp so that the threads will no longer work properly. I've made several boxes with this grain orientation, but do not recommend it for someone wishing to sell their wares.
I just recently saw a demonstration by Michael Mocho in Seattle, who was threading hard maple and getting good results using a magic elixier that looked very much like liquid dish washing soap as a lubricant. I haven't tried it on hard maple yet, but did try it on some softer wood, with less than outstanding results.
I should mention, that no one always gets a good thread the first time, even Allan Batty who is pretty good at hand thread chasing.
There is nothing like practice and more practice that will improve the hand thread chasing. When I was learning, I chased threads on every piece of wood left in the chuck after some other turning had been parted off. The threads were not always good, but the practice helped me handle the chasers better.
I've included a drawing that shows how to size the tenon and recess to make them fit properly when threaded.
One final thought, Bill Jones in England who chases threads in almost everything that he makes, said, "Get a box of offcuts and make a half a gross of little boxes and you'll become a thread chaser." In other words, practice, practice, practice!!!
>Steve, I've learned that with wood that has soft grain and hard grain that are pronounced like Cherry, requires a lighter touch and very sharp chasers. I have thinned superglue with Acetone, and applied it to the bare wood, and let it set for a while to cure well. It does better for me than wax or oil. I think... but don't know scientifically... that the thinned CA will penetrate the softer wood and make it almost the same as the harder wood, so the threads cut more evenly. But it really does require a light touch which takes longer to do the threads.
I watched Anthony Harris chase threads, and patience is surely one of his virtues when chasing. :)
>Even more experimenting and I was able to thread cherry pretty cleanly! Hard maple also threaded quite nicely. The issues is simply one of consistency. Nice male thread + not so nice female thread = start over!
I have the chasers for another week before I'll see the turner who I borrowed them from again, so I can still practice. It's probably still mostly my fault, so I know that I can work it out over time. Sooner or later I'll either get it or try building a mechanical attachment for the lathe.
I should send you some to try. I cut up a bunch recently into turning squares, some box-sized and have a pile outside under cover waiting until I can pick up a chainsaw again.
Do you live anywhere near Ruth Niles or ever see her? She is supposed to stop here tomorrow on her way back north and I could send some pieces for you.
Ok, I packed up a box of bradford pear for you - I hope Ruth has room for it! I stuffed it full and filled in the empty spaces with a miscellaneous piece or two.
This wood is green and shrinking. I looked at one 2x2 where I had cut a piece of 12 gauge copper house electrical wire, the ends flush with the sides (a built in shrinkage gauge!). Someone had evidently tied the young tree to a post. It had shrunk about 3/32" in a couple of weeks. It seems to warp quite a bit as it dries so be advised. But of the pile of turning blanks I processed a few weeks ago, almost none had cracked and a bowl I roughed out shows no signs of cracking - a good sign. :)
You need really hard material with tight grain. I have threaded hard maple, and it works ok. I understand osage orange will take a thread, but I haven't tried it. Bubinga works quite well. A 20 tpi chaser will be easier to learn on, and will generally have a shallower depth thread, which might be more forgiving of wood species. Slow RPM, and you kind of get a rhythm going. Material should be oriented with grain parallel to the lathe. You can put an insert of harder material in a softer material container. I watched Mark St. Leger do threading - very informative.