>I was just fiddling around last night, making shavings out of some fahrwood, (related to dunno wood, but the name tells the source)...
Not really making anything in particular, just practicing beads and coves when snickt and the drive center was all by its lonesome. The work fell down behind the lathe and the other half just dropped onto the ways. No fanfair, but it was my first 'catch' I just hope they're all that un-spectacular.
Hope away. They usually go "bang" then "clink/clank" when the tool hits the lathe. This is followed immediately by either "whap-whap-whap-whap" if part of the piece stays connected to the lathe, otherwise by some secondary sounds in stereo echoing around the room including a possible "yeow" and perhaps a "$%@" (french for 'rats').
>Oh I knew I was hoping in vain, but it was really a very gentle catch, all things considered. Very dry fahrwood, and a very thin spindle when it caught. so not a lot of mass to go too far wrong with.
>I think I've ID'd the wood as fairly punky maple, it was down to just less than 1/4" thick when the tip of the gouge dug in, it twisted and the piece just let go. No drama, just 'snickt' and it fell.
>That's the sound of a cast iron tool rest breaking off under the impact of a heavy bowl scraper getting jammed by a 16" maple bowl. I guess I had it set a tad low. One tends to learn from these mistakes, or at least the ones that we survive.
Ellis
...and don't forget "spink, whap, fdddddp, bam, bink, bink, bonk" when your spigot breaks and your vessel is launched across the shop at about 110 mph and 2000 rpm. DAMHIKT
>Ah, turning small. When making long, thin wands I've found the wood in the thin areas very important. I look for straight grain running down the blank - burled and figured is fragile where the grain goes sideways. If there are "character" flaws I try to place them in the thicker handle area. Soft, flexible wood such as buckeye and green wood is also tricky since any flexing will beg for a catch. OTOH strong, stiff wood like dry oak, hickory, dogwood, or sugar maple is hard to break even on a 14" piece turned down to 1/8" or so in places.
A Punky Piece is Pert near imPossible - it will almost snick apart when hit with bright light or if the radio is too loud!
BTW, from your picture it looks like the tip of the detail gouge may have dug in. If cutting with the tip, the slightest hint of flexing will cause a catch. When I cut coves like that I may start the cut at the outside with the tip but then ease the gouge forward as I proceed into the cut to prevent the tip from catching. This ends up cutting most of the cove with the side of the gouge, at first just a bit to the side of the tip, then further over on the wing when approaching the bottom of the cove, especially if the bottom flattens out into a cylinder or taper - a bit like planing with a skew. This was discussed in a recent thread "tools for turning finials" with at good description by Brad Vietje.