Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Bowl edge cut

Posts

Bowl edge cut

#1

Keith Tompkins

Bowl edge cut

keith tompkins

>Another way to deal with truing up the top surface of a bowl, as posted by Gary G. Instead of shear scraping, a cut can be made with either a bowl or spindle gouge, with the flute facing away from the surface being cut, bevel rubbing. Start the cut at the outer rim, and cut inward, letting the tool cut at a steady rate, don't force the cut. To begin the cut without skating backwards, cut right on the centerline, then just touch the bowl's surface to create a groove for the bevel to follow, then proceed with the cut. With a sharp gouge, the cut will be extrermely clean. I make this cut before I begin to remove material from the bowl's interior.


img

Re: Bowl edge cut

#2

Re: Bowl edge cut

Randy G

>Can you show a top view of this cut? I think I understand but want to make sure I understand where the tool angle is from the bowl

Re: Bowl edge cut

#3

Right On...

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>

Re: Bowl edge cut

#4

Keith Tompkins

Re: Bowl edge cut

keith tompkins

>This should do it....Handle is level, bevel rubbing, cut right on center from rim to interior. Flute is facing away from cut. I believe this is an essential cut in wood turning.


img

Re: Bowl edge cut

#5

Re: Bowl edge cut

Randy G

>Thank you sir... If I understand this right, I do believe I have done this before... thanks for the 2nd pic

Re: Bowl edge cut

#6

Right you are!

Jorge Castaneda ~ Downeast Maine

>

Re: Bowl edge cut

#7

Re: Bowl edge cut

GalenV

>Keith:

Turned my first tops this last weekend and used this very same cut with a spindle gouge on end grained blank and turned out great.

Our club had also provided a cross grain blank with maple dowel to make tops. Trying this same cut all I got was nice catch and spiral cut up the blank. Just could not make cut into end grain.

This is the same as you show for a bowl with cross grain blank. Spindle gouge was just sharpened before turning. What is the secret to good cut on cross grain as you show? Was I forcing the cut to fast or spindle gouge not turned true flute out? Seemed like other newer turners had trouble with same cut so is it just more experience?

I can turn a rim of a bowl but not with the cut you show till I can understand what I need to do.

Thanks

Galen

Re: Bowl edge cut

#8

Keith Tompkins

Re: Bowl edge cut

keith tompkins

>Hi Galen, There are a couple of reasons you are experiencing the problems on cross-grain pieces. First, the flute must be presented at 90 degrees to the turning. If not, the gouge will act like a threading tool; lean it one way, it spirals towards you. Lean it the other way, it tends to spiral away from you. Second, the tool must be presented so the cut aims straight towards the center. Too high on the turning, the tool will be hard to control, and tend to spiral towards you. Third, be sure to just "kiss" the turning with the tip of the tool....be patient, and a groove will form. Gradually deepen the groove, then the bevel will have enough support to cut without skittering off. It's easier to cut this way with a long, steep bevel; I have at least a 45 degree angle on all my gouges. A blunt angle is much more difficult to start a cut like this with. Last, support the handle against your side. This gives far more control than by simply trying to control the tool with your arms. Just like learning to use a skew, this cut takes time and patience to learn. I suggest putting a bowl blank on the lathe, and practice this cut every day until you can do it without fear of a catch. This is a fundamental turning cut, and is worth investing the time it takes to master it.

Re: Bowl edge cut

#9

Re: Bowl edge cut

HeatherA in AK

>This thread has been very informative. I wish that we could have a gallery with tool cutting photos in it. It has taken me quite a while and reading many books and watching Richard Raffan and Bill Grumbine videos to get to where I can picture in my head the tool position when someone says "shear cut" or "shear scrape. I was going to suggest this to Bill, have a poster with the 3 main cutting positions on it and when to use them, I would put it over the lathe. Folks here could post their favorite cutting/scraping positions and when they use them.

Heather

Re: Bowl edge cut

#10

Thanks Keith

GalenV

>Keith:

Thanks for your directions I saved for my file I keep by the lathe.

It just got me I could do the cut across the end grain to make a top and no catches but doing the same on cross grain I blew it every time. Think I got shock. Spindle gouge angle is 40 degree. Thinking about it I probably entered slight above center if anything and maybe just below tip. Grip was high on the handle so movement was not magnified and handle braced only down the inside of my forearm and not to my side.

Does turning speed effect, other than faster catch :)?

As "punishment" :) I have been back to practice turning beads and coves with that spindle gouge. Will attempt cross grain again Friday!

Thanks for your help.

Galen

Re: Bowl edge cut

#11

Re: Agree 100%

GalenV

>I agree 100% on having one place to put all good information for new turners such as myself.

Keith, with the help of John Jordan. on October 7th posted a good picture of turning beads and coves using the spindle gouge, when I ask for help. It was given in a size I could print off well for reference.

I find this web site is a great wealth of experiance and as long as everyone will put up with me I hope I can continue to ask for help.

Carol ask about turning finials and there is a lot of good information in it as well. By the time I try finials I hope I can find.

Again great help, thanks to all.

Galen

Re: Bowl edge cut

#12

indeed...

GaryG in MD

>Keith,

Thanks for your thoughts. You're right that it can be done that way. Indeed, that's exactly what I did when I cut off the damaged area. I do know how to make this cut and do it successfully with my more acutely-nose-angled gouges (which get a safe start with the proper approach angle and thumb pressure at the point of initial attack).

I typically chose not to make this cut on a thin rim edge though, because it can kick back if you're not doing it exactly correctly, as pointed out by Galen, but mainly because it involves cutting into end grain and it can tear out when it comes out the other side of the rim. Stuart Batty is very opinionated about not cutting into end grain when it's not necessary, and I like to try to follow his examples. In this case (on a rim where I have only a narrow lip to true up), I believe a shear scrape is the desired cut because it is cutting only into side grain all the way around. I went right back and did that successfully -- I just had to re-normalize my technique back to the correct angles.

I have also seen many turners, like Jamie Donaldson and Al Stirt (just to name two random examples that cross my mind), avoid the cut you describe (because it goes directly into end grain) by using a shearing cut, somewhat similar to the shear scrape, with the flute nearly facing the wood, but cutting with the lower side of the nose and moving from the center toward the rim, either in one long, smooth cut, or in a series of shorter steps to quickly (and roughly) remove material. [Some may do this and then clean up with your cut because it's easier to make a long flat like that.] Again, this cut is solely into side grain, so technically it cuts cleaner, with better shavings and less pressure and less dust. End grain is not our friend.

In the end, it's a matter of personal preference and the kind of wood -- different woods obviously react very differently in terms of tear out.

We need all these various techniques in our bag of tricks. Thankfully, these days we have a wide variety of well-designed tools to chose from and good instruction on how to use them.

BTW, I like your CAD artwork. ...Gary

Re: Bowl edge cut

#13

Ric Taylor

Re: Bowl edge cut

Ric Taylor

>Galen,

As I described in my previous post, I make this cut with a sharp parting tool. There is no danger of a catch with a parting tool, and it leaves a nice smooth surface. Once that cut is made, then you can switch to a spindle gouge, bowl gouge or scraper as needed.

Ric

Re: Bowl edge cut

#14

Keith Tompkins

Re: indeed...

keith tompkins

>Hi Gary, I use several cuts as well: I'll get the edge close with an Ellsworth grind bowl gouge using a "scooping" cut, then finish up as I describe. The top surface of the bowl is cut before I begin to turn the interior to final size, so a bit of blowout on the inside does't matter; it's removed in the first stage of cutting the inside. The top surface grain structure will not often follow the same direction, as flat-boarders hand-planing a surface will discover. Just as we hit end grain/ side grain/ end grain/ side grain when turning the bowl's rim, we also encounter undilating grain patterns at the surface that follow the tree's growth rings. That's where an extensive "bag of tricks" comes into play. What works sometimes won't work at other times.

Yes, the tool can skate back, but with practice, it becomes a rare occurance...the secret is as I described above, starting a groove for the bevel to ride on, etc. I equate this cut to using a skew chisel in real-life situations...yes, one slip will destroy a piece, but with practice, nothing works better. Dedicated practice equates to a high level of skill in these techniques.

As far as the turners you mention are concerned, we all have different styles. Some avoid cutting into end grain, while I've discovered from my own experience that end grain turning is nothing to be feared, and in many cases is the superior cutting method. My personal philosophy is this: I tell my students to take from my classes what works for them, and disregard the rest....that's OK. Each turner they study with will have other techniques that work for them, some that don't. The collective knowledge gained from all sources is what will eventually help each turner develop their own comfortable turning style.

Thanks, my drawing program is invaluable for preparing demo materials and handouts, plus it's been a great learning experience.

Re: Bowl edge cut

#15

yup...

GaryG in MD

>Keith,

Well said. I certainly agree. It's nice that we have many tools and alternative methods. The exact form and wood characteristics untimately dictate what we do -- or have to do. If a cut I've done many times begins to fail me on a particular piece of wood, I don't force it -- I sharpen the tool and try again. If that doesn't work, I just switch techniques or tools until I find the one that works in that particular case. That, of course, is where experience comes in. The more you do, the more you see these things happening, and the easier it is to find the correct alternatives. I learn new things every time a start a new piece -- that's one of the joys.

I'm driving myself nuts right now with a design problem. I've got a piece that I know needs another "feature", but the wood is loaded with curl, and don't want the feature to disturb the flow of the natural wood pattern. It's a kind of Catch 22 situation. It's my first colored piece, so I don't have any experience backed up to help me. I've looked at hundreds of photos I've saved up in my archive and still can't decide. Maybe I'll post it and get your opinion.

...Gary

Re: Bowl edge cut

#16

Keith Tompkins

Re: yup...

keith tompkins

>Cool....sounds like fun!