indeed...
GaryG in MD
>Keith,
Thanks for your thoughts. You're right that it can be done that way. Indeed, that's exactly what I did when I cut off the damaged area. I do know how to make this cut and do it successfully with my more acutely-nose-angled gouges (which get a safe start with the proper approach angle and thumb pressure at the point of initial attack).
I typically chose not to make this cut on a thin rim edge though, because it can kick back if you're not doing it exactly correctly, as pointed out by Galen, but mainly because it involves cutting into end grain and it can tear out when it comes out the other side of the rim. Stuart Batty is very opinionated about not cutting into end grain when it's not necessary, and I like to try to follow his examples. In this case (on a rim where I have only a narrow lip to true up), I believe a shear scrape is the desired cut because it is cutting only into side grain all the way around. I went right back and did that successfully -- I just had to re-normalize my technique back to the correct angles.
I have also seen many turners, like Jamie Donaldson and Al Stirt (just to name two random examples that cross my mind), avoid the cut you describe (because it goes directly into end grain) by using a shearing cut, somewhat similar to the shear scrape, with the flute nearly facing the wood, but cutting with the lower side of the nose and moving from the center toward the rim, either in one long, smooth cut, or in a series of shorter steps to quickly (and roughly) remove material. [Some may do this and then clean up with your cut because it's easier to make a long flat like that.] Again, this cut is solely into side grain, so technically it cuts cleaner, with better shavings and less pressure and less dust. End grain is not our friend.
In the end, it's a matter of personal preference and the kind of wood -- different woods obviously react very differently in terms of tear out.
We need all these various techniques in our bag of tricks. Thankfully, these days we have a wide variety of well-designed tools to chose from and good instruction on how to use them.
BTW, I like your CAD artwork. ...Gary