Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

We are NEW here *LINK*

Posts

We are NEW here *LINK*

#1

We are NEW here *LINK*

Keith & Diane Gracely

>Hi my name is Diane Gracely. My husband Keith and I just began woodturning this year and we would like some feedback from all of you on our work and our web site. And I would like to say I was thrilled to find this web site! We are from the Leesport, PA. area. Here is our web site- www.kewlboxes.com


Kewl Boxes

Re: We are NEW here *LINK*

#2

Re: We are NEW here

Bill Grumbine - Kutztown PA

>Hi Diane

Welcome to the site, and we are practically neighbors! I live just up the road from you, not really in Kutztown, but that is my mailing address. If you want to meet up with some other turners face to face, you should check out the Lehigh Valley Woodturners club which meets at the Woodcraft store in Allentown.

Also, if you are coming up this way, the shop door is always open.

Bill

Re: We are NEW here *LINK*

#3

Re: We are NEW here

Bill Grumbine - Kutztown PA

>Hello again Diane

I see you already know who I am, since you have apparently lifted some of my words off my own website.

From your site:

Wood is an imperfect medium. It has flaws and faults that sometimes make it unusable. But just as God uses imperfect men and women to accomplish His will, we use imperfect wood to show the beauty in nature. Decaying wood, wood with cracks, knots, and other defects is still beautiful, sometimes more beautiful than wood that has no such problems. We strive to bring out the beauty in each and every piece be it imperfect wood or perfect wood.

From my site:

Wood is an imperfect medium. It has flaws and faults that sometimes make it unusable. But just as God uses imperfect men and women to accomplish His will, I use imperfect wood to show the beauty in nature. Decaying wood, wood with cracks, knots, and other defects is still beautiful, sometimes more beautiful than wood that has no such problems. I strive to bring out that beauty in each and every piece that comes into my hands.

Notice anything similar???? Of course, it fits a lot better on mine since since I am the one who wrote those words, and they are part of my "artist's statement". I don't mind people copying my work. I encourage that. I do have trouble with people who copy my words (plagiarism I believe it is called) or my DVDs.

Have a nice day, and I will look forward to the revision on your website.

Bill

Re: We are NEW here *LINK*

#4

Re: We are NEW here

Kevin G.

>People never cease to amaze me Bill? It doesn't say much about one's character or ability when they have to "borrow" another turner's written statement, especially something as personal and heartfelt as an Artist's Statement. Sheesh! :-(

Re: We are NEW here *LINK*

#5

Re: We are NEW here

wilbur

>That was a truly lame move on the part of the Gracely's.

Re: We are NEW here *LINK*

#6

Re: We are NEW here

Jerry McCaffrey

>Well Bill, I notice that the Gracely's site showed it copyrighted in 2008 so those words must be theirs. Your site didn't show any such notice, so who knows where those words came from on your site. It's nice to see as a realtively new turner that you've hooked up with a woodturning club like LV Woodturners. We also have some good demos at our club in NJ. We've had Steve Antonucci demo hollowing, followed up two months later by some big heavy guy demonstrating basically the same thing. Both were good, but Antonucci had a funnier delivery.

Hey, thanks for some really great demos, lessons and DVD's, never mind Five Barns where you host woodturners from all over the US.

Jerry

Re: We are NEW here *LINK*

#7

Steven Antonucci

My artist's statement: Bizarro Bill Grumbine ;-)

steve antonucci

>Wood is a perfect medium. It has no flaws and no faults that sometimes make it usable. But just as God uses perfect men and women to accomplish His will, I use perfect wood to show the ugly in nature. Undecaying wood, wood without cracks, no knots, and no other defects is still beautiful, sometimes more beautiful than wood that has such problems. I strive to bring out that ugly in each and every piece that comes into my hands.

Steve

Re: We are NEW here *LINK*

#8

Steven Antonucci

Apparently, I posted while someone was unposting!

steve antonucci

>

Re: We are NEW here *LINK*

#9

Re: Apparently, I posted while someone was unposti

Jerry McCaffrey

>It made sense when the rest of the thread was there

Re: We are NEW here *LINK*

#10

Re: Apparently, I posted while someone was unposti

John K Jordan

>I've seen several posts disappear lately. I assume these are removed due to inappropriate content. (I did a lot of that during my years of moderating an international forum.)

Was a post I read earlier today removed for being a thinly disguised advertisement?

JKJ

Re: We are NEW here *LINK*

#11

Re: Apparently, I posted while someone was unposti

Randy G

>Personal opinion was they did want advise and maybe did copy something that should be changed now. The thread was degrading, so we'll move on and enjoy turning now right? :D

Re: We are NEW here *LINK*

#12

Steven Antonucci

I read your post (before it was unposted...)

steve antonucci

>I'm funny :-)

S

Re: We are NEW here *LINK*

#13

Ellis Walentine

The thread was removed...

Ellis Walentine

>...so that Diane could address the issues of "borrowing" content from another website. I figured it was inadvertent or unknowing, so I stopped the thread before a lot of other people decided to pile on.

I echo Bill's sentiments that a lot of folks find it hard to say what they mean to say without communicating something entirely different. I think Diane and her husband fell down that rabbit hole with their initial post and the subsequent disparagement of our country, which she tried to qualify with a smiley. Sometimes smileys don't work. I would prefer to inform her of the perceptions that her words evoke, and hope that she agrees.

None of us always says the words that exactly express our meaning. The real test is in the heart. I don't think Diane meant to convey the meaning that her statement implied, as she herself has attested.

Ellis

Re: We are NEW here *LINK*

#14

Re: The thread was removed...

John K Jordan

>I understand, thanks.

We all make mistakes and learn from them.

JKJ