Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

A Russ Fairfield finding

Posts

A Russ Fairfield finding

#1

A Russ Fairfield finding

eliot d

>Russ Fairfield has argued that sanding (to an equivalent grit) gives a "brighter' reflective quality than buffing -- e.g Beal, Oneway, etc.. His argument , as I understand it, has to do with the difference between deeper sharp 'V'-shaped sandpaper scratches as compared with shallower 'U'-shaped buffing scratches made by rounded buffing abrasives. His claim, I believe, is that the 'V' scratches will absorb finishes better. But I have also read articles by Michael Dresser that seem to imply the opposite. He advocates sanding with the more rounded.'U'_shaped particle sandpaper in the final sanding steps precisely because the more rounded, shallower scratches produce a finer surface. So I find myself wondering about it in that I usually finish up by buffing.

Re: A Russ Fairfield finding

#2

Are you sure? *LINK*

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>I'm not sure where you read that, but Russ's statement in one buffing discussion was:

"... And that is why a buffing will give a higher gloss appearance that a sandpaper, even though the grit particles are the same size."


Re: Beal Buffing Compund Comparisons? - Russ

Re: A Russ Fairfield finding

#3

Re: A Russ Fairfield finding

Russ Fairfield

>I have been misread, misunderstood, misrepresented, or mispoken. I may disagree with Dresdner and others on a variety of finishing topics, but this isn't one of them.

The gloss from a surface is all about the ability of a surface to reflect light into our eyeballs. The more reflected light, the higher the gloss,

In my Finishing Secrets article, I said: "Aluminum Oxide will remove wood faster than Garnet because it is harder and sharper, making a deep V-grooved scratch pattern on the surface, while the softer Garnet wears faster and leaves a pattern of shallow U-shaped grooves. It makes sense to start sanding with Aluminum Oxide and finish with Garnet."

What I didn't say there, but have said many times in other places, was that the surface sanded with Garnet would appear to be smoother with a higher gloss than the one sanded with Aluminum Oxide because of the added reflectivity of the rounded bottoms in the U-shaped scratches, even though they may be the same grit size.

Add buffing to this surface, and the sharp peaks between the grooves are also rounded, giving twice as many reflective surfaces, and twice the reflected light. We see that as a higher gloss.

Re: A Russ Fairfield finding

#4

Re: A Russ Fairfield finding

Russ Fairfield

>Yes, the sharper V grooves from an Aluminum Oxide will accept more stain and give more "tooth" for a finish. It is also true that the coarser the grit, the deeper the grooves, and the more stain will be trapped in the wood. However, life is full of compromises; and you will have to accept less gloss on the surface.

Re: A Russ Fairfield finding

#5

Re: A Russ Fairfield finding

eliot d

>Well,I'm not going to argue with the author! I read what I read at http://www.morewoodturning.net, where one of the articles is on buffing. It's an excellent article( in many ways, anyway) by Lyn J. Mangiameli about buffing. One fairly long section of it describes (what is claimed to be) your different view on the benefits of buffing. It starts out, "Russ Fairfield holds an alternate view, ..."; and then goes on to say what I tried to recount here. Do you know about this article? If not, I suppose it would interest you in that Mangiameli mentions you by name Anyway, thanks for clearing it up for me. I have had your three finishing videos for about a year now , and still consider them to be the best single source on finishing lathe turned pieces anywhere.

Re: A Russ Fairfield finding

#6

Misunderstood

Dinyar Chavda

>"I have been misread, misunderstood, misrepresented, or mispoken."

You share this with others:



To be great is to be misunderstood

(attributed to Ralph Waldo Emerson)



May I in my brief bolt across the scene

Not be misunderstood in what I mean.

(Robert Frost)



But I'm just a soul whose intentions are good.

Oh, Lord, please don't let me be misunderstood.

(Usually misattributed to Eric Burden & The Animals, but, as a jazzman, you know it was originally recorded by Nina Simone)





I can't help being amused by the fact that you are haunted by Lyn in absentia!

Re: A Russ Fairfield finding

#7

Re: A Russ Fairfield finding

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>UhOh