End grain tearout and lathe speed
wilbur
>All other things being equal, when making a bowl, will you get more or less end grain tearout at higher RPMs or lower RPMs?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
End grain tearout and lathe speed
wilbur
>All other things being equal, when making a bowl, will you get more or less end grain tearout at higher RPMs or lower RPMs?
Re: End grain tearout and lathe speed
Ron McKinley
>We had Jimmy Clewes for a demo a while back and he startled us all by running the lathe at max speed after he had it rounded and balanced so must be the higher RPM the smoother cut and less tear out ....Ron
Re: End grain tearout and lathe speed
Dick Hines
>I am not sure about the speed but a sharp tool helps.
Re: End grain tearout and lathe speed
Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin
>I find higher rpm's easier, but the most important factor is how sharp your tool is. A honed edge cuts better than an off-the-grinder edge. Higher rpm's dull a tool faster.
Re: End grain tearout and lathe speed
wilbur
>Right. Sharpness isn't the issue here -- assume the tool is wicked sharp.
It's feed rate of the tool
john lucas
>Speed only matters if it helps you feed the tool at the proper speed. Forcing the tool to cut is one of the major factors in tearout. Sharpness, cutting downhill on the grain and a supported edge are the other factors.
The wood wants to be cut at a certain rate. If your force the cut faster than the wood wants to be cut it will tear out. You can either slow down the speed that you push the gouge forward or you can speed up the lathe or both. I do a little bit of both. I have never felt comfortable turning at high speed (at least on larger work)so I lighten up my grip on the tool and push very gently into the cut. I started doing this after watching Stewart Batty turn a piece that looked like it had been sanded by 600 grit. It works. It takes practice. Put the pressure down on the tool rest, not on the bevel, and see how slow you can feed the tool forward. I'll bet you'll see a better cut.
Another factor of speed of cut is how smooth you can get the curve. It's very difficult to produce a perfect curve when you are moving the tool really slow. Why, because it's just hard to move your body in a fluid way. If you speed up the lathe it lets the cut flow faster so your body moves easier in a gentle arc to control the cut. Always consider safety when you talk about speed of the lathe. I'd rather sand and scraper a bowl to perfection over getting hit by a flying piece of wood. The force that wood leaves the lathe at high speed is extremely dangerous.
Good question.
Re: End grain tearout and lathe speed
Bill Grumbine - Kutztown PA
>Yeah, but where is it pointing? ;-) Higher rpm make for smoother cuts, at least to a certain point, but presentation of the gouge matters more.
Perfect answer. Add to it the following.
steve antonucci
>John's answer is 100% dead-on. I work with a lot of new turners, and I see the same things John lists almost every time.
I try to stress cutting cleanly in almost every pass, so that we're never trying to remove tearout in a final cut. Once you can do that, feel free to hog away wood.
Unlike John, speed doesn't really bother me. I usually get a better cut at higher speeds, plus it "demos" well :-) Nothing like throwing long strings of wet maple in a demo...
The thing I try to mention over and over around finishing cuts is to make sure you resharpen right before your last pass. As I get close to the final finish cut, I take a heavy pass to show the damage it can create (so folks will know that even a good turner can't do it). Next, I take a lighter pass, but I cut it very quickly- moving the tool faster than the wood wants to be cut. This leaves a miniscule spiral pattern like a record all the way down the inside of the bowl (no tear out.)
Finally, I talk about sound and pace. As you move closer to the center of the bowl, the wood is moving much slower past the cutting edge so you need to slow the feed rate of the tool down to keep the cutting rate the same. I use the sound (pitch) as my meter. If I have the same "hiss" from rim to center, I usually have a 180 G starting point for sanding...
Steve
Re: Perfect answer. Add to it the following.
davidwalser
>
...Unlike John, speed doesn't really bother me. I usually get a better cut at higher speeds, plus it "demos" well :-)...
I think that woodturners too often ignore the safety implications of increasing turning speed. (I'm NOT suggesting Steve does that. His comment just reminded me of what I've observed in others.) All things being equal, more RPMs leads to a cleaner cut and the ability to feed the tool at a faster rate. More RPMs also increase the loads and stresses placed on the object being turned. As long as the blank is sound, is in balance, and is fixed securely to the lathe, the increased loads and stresses that come with increased RPMs can be dealt with. But a small catch or an unseen defect in the wood can, with the increased speed, suddenly release the pent up energy with disastrous consequences. This is particularly true when turning a bowl or other object without tail stock support. So, to my mind, an "ideal turning speed" is a compromise between fast enough to get a clean cut and slow enough that nothing bad will happen if things suddenly come apart.
Dale Nish came up with a formula that gives a starting point for determining this "ideal" speed: Diameter (in inches) x RPM should fall with in a range of 6,000 - 9,000. So, a 3" diameter blank should be turned at a maximum of 3,000 RPM (3 x 3,000 = 9,000). A 10" bowl blank would be turned at a maximum of 900 RPM. (See page 4 of Craft Supplies USA's current catalog for an explanation of the formula.) Dale's formula is just a rule of thumb and like all such rules there are plenty of exceptions to it, but I think it's a good starting point.
Re: End grain tearout and lathe speed
robo hippy
>I never felt that speed had anything to do with the quality of the cut. It is tool sharpness and presentation of the cutting edge (or more commonly called tecnique). Speed only makes the job quicker for me, and it seems easier. There are myrtle wood bowls turners on the Oregon coast who turn at 4,000 rpm. I have a friend who had a Legacy lathe and turns at 200 rpm. The end results are the same. I can get equally good finish cuts using shear scrapers and gouges. Sharpness and tecnique.
robo hippy
Re: End grain tearout and lathe speed
Allen Neighbors
>End grain tearout, happens when the fibers release from down inside the wood, instead of at the level where you're cutting. With a given tool that is sharpened and honed, even with the right tool presentation, you might get a little tearout on softer wood. If so, try taking a lighter cut, and if that doesn't work, turn up the speed, and take a lighter cut. It just nearly always works for me.
Now. That said, I must add that I shake quite a bit, and it's hard for me to hold the tool steady enough to make a smooth cut at a slower speed. So, I up the speed, and take lighter cuts. If I could only get the speed high enough to match my shaky hands... :o) When I'm finish-turning a piece I don't hold the tool with as tight a grip as I do when I'm roughing, and that also helps my cuts become smoother.
When I first started turning in 2003, I had to start sanding at 60 grit, many times. Now, it's seldom that I can't start at 120, and sometimes I even get to start with 180 grit. Things are looking up.
Thanks
wilbur
>Thanks for the input. This gives me a number of things to try tonight.