Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

what went wrong?

Posts

what went wrong?

#1

what went wrong?

GaryG in MD

>BAM! Don't you just hate that sound?

I know what I did -- I'm just not sure why it blew up.

I started with a dried piece of silver maple.

I turned the tenon round and chucked it.

I rounded the outside for a couple of inches up to the rim from the headstock side. As planned, no problems.

I had not yet flattened to top at the rim, so I moved the tool rest around to the tailstock side and started working at the rim with a bowl gouge in the shear scraps mode -- handle very low, flute toward the wood. WHAM! I ripped the whole rim off all the way around.

I don't get it. I thought the proper way to true the rim was a shear scrape. The only thing I can figure is that I got too close to the tip, and the end of the gouge became engaged rather than a wing. I guess that would do it.

So my question is -- am I correct that a shear scrape into the top of the rim is the correct way to true up the rim. I could use a flat scraper flat on the rest, but that seems scarier to me.

Comments and recommendations please. Thanks, Gary

Re: what went wrong?

#2

Re: what went wrong?

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>My guess is that you rolled the gouge a bit so that the flute was up, instead of toward the wood, creating an unsupported cutting edge which is guaranteed to dig in big time.

Wally

Re: what went wrong?

#3

I'd like to have a video playback...

GaryG in MD

>Wally, You could be right -- it was getting a little too dark, and it was that famous "last cut".

Three things: 1) Am I correct that a shear scrape is the correct" cut in that case (I can't think what else would be);

2) Is it dangerous to shear scrape too close to the tip of the gouge? and

3) the normal shear scrape with a gouge is handle low, and the cutting edge way up high. Would it be safer in a case like that to put the handle high so the cutting edge is below the level of the tool rest? Seems like that would make any potential catch a lot less disastrous.

I really don't want this to happen again! I wrecked a beautiful piece of very curly silver maple from the ground level of a big tree. The design opportunity will make it a smaller piece than it would/should have been.

Thanks for your comments, Gary

Re: what went wrong?

#4

Re: what went wrong?

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>I shear cut rather than shear scrape. My bowl gouge has an "English" grind on it with about a 40� included angle. The nose and the far side of the edge will give a very easily controlled shear cut across a surface.

Re: what went wrong?

#5

Re: what went wrong?

bowlman

>I assume you had the piece mounted in your chuck when you tried to true up the rim. True? And did you use the tail stock for additional support?

Personally, when I go to true up the rim, I make as clean a cut as possible using the bowl gouge, but not in shear scrape mode. I reserve the shear scrape mode as a final, ultra light, finishing cut just as if I were using a cabinet scraper on a piece of furniture.

Another question: As you approached the rim, which edge of the flute was used to contact the rim and were you travelling from outer rim towards center or were you starting at the inner rim and pulling outwards?

Shear scraping is a great tool skill to have but it can be very nerve wracking ... and bowl wrecking. The theory of shear scraping is that the edge is used at 45 to 60 degrees (approximately) to the travel of the wood and the edge barely kisses the wood in a "levelling cut". That 45 degrees can be increased to approach 90 degrees, but then the edge is in line with the grain and, IMHO, does not work as well as the 45-60 degree angle.

Re: what went wrong?

#6

Re: what went wrong?

john lucas

>Gary I use what I call an arcing movement to true up the outside of a bowl that is out of round. I have the handle down and flute facing in about 60 degrees or so. I want the tip and bottom of the tool to do the cutting. I start with the gouge away from the wood and pivot the handle so the tip travels in an arc into the wood. I continue the arc until it is cutting solid wood with no air. Then I move the tool forward on the tool rest a short distance do this again.

I'm leveling the bowl in stages but it goes very quick and is very safe. By anchoring the tool with your left hand and arcing the tool in you take a very controlled bite. If the wood is really rough you arc the tool slowly. If your cutting mostly wood instead of air you can arc the tool more rapidly. On softer woods I can take off 3/8 to 1/2" of wood in each arc and this arc can go an inch or more so you get rid of wood very quickly.

The gouge looks like it's closed more than it really is in this photo. I had the camera at the wrong angle. Sorry about that but I'm late for work so I had to rush the photo.


img

Re: what went wrong?

#7

Re: what went wrong?

Bill Grumbine - Kutztown PA

>Gary, it is time for what I call forensic woodturning. You should be able to piece the fragments back together enough to have the general shape of your bowl. At some point in the circumference, there should be a dig in the wood. You should be able to fit your bowl gouge into the wood so that the profile of the gouge matches up with the dig into the wood. That will tell you how you were holding the tool when the catch occurred. If you can get the whole mess back on the lathe, you can probably figure out how you were standing.

That is the first and most important step to correcting what went wrong. There is no way to fix something if you don't know what it is you are trying to fix. As you can see by the responses in the thread already, there are lots of ways people make this cut. But however you were trying it, something wasn't quite right. I tend to think along the lines of what Wally wrote, that the gouge rotated up so that the edge was at a more acute angle. This is a very common occurrence in my shop (with students that is!) so I am pretty sure that is what happened. But there is no way to know without going back and taking a look at the wood.

Good luck with it.

Re: what went wrong?

#8

Steven Antonucci

Agree with Bill and Wally

steve antonucci

>Most likely cause of a catch would be an open flute (Between 9 o'clock and 3 o'clock). When I teach the shear scraping cut, most people are fearful of touching the top wing of the gouge (thinking it will catch, but it doesn't!), so I show it that way first. Done properly, I do not believe that you can get a catch, since no edge would be exposed to the wood except for "perpendicular" to the surface.

Start your shear scrape with both wings touching, then rotate to allow for a penny-thickness between the top wing and the surface...

Steve

Re: what went wrong?

#9

Re: what went wrong?

John K Jordan

>As an aside to the question in this thread, I've started reaching for the heavy-duty Hunter tool for such cuts.

JKJ

Re: what went wrong?

#10

Re: what went wrong?

john lucas

>The Hunter tool presented in the same angle as my gouge in the photos will give the same cut. That's probably a good cut to put in my video.

Re: what went wrong?

#11

Re: I'd like to have a video playback...

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Gary, to answer your questions, 1-Yes, it's okay to carefully shear scrape around the rim...2-If your gouge is ground with a side grind, scrape near the center of the grind. If the tip contacts the wood it can dig in and create a groove...3-Around the rim it's probably safer to have the handle near level. However, it should never be above the cutting edge.

Shear scraping should always be done with a light touch.

I agree with Bill G. When you have a bowl busting disaster you should always try to determine what went wrong. Experience is a good teacher.

Wally

Re: what went wrong?

#12

I'll Add......

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>If the walls of your bowl are fairly thin then it's NOT a good idea to come back and shear scrape around the rim. The walls will be flexing a bit and the bowl has probably gone out of round a bit. There would be a good chance of a catch. For a thin walled bowl the rim should be completed before the hollowing is complete.

Wally

Re: what went wrong?

#13

Re: what went wrong?

robo hippy

>Shear cuts can be done with a scraper or a gouge, or for that matter a skew (but not for bowls). On the inside of a bowl, especially if it is over about 8 inch diameter, I will do it in stages. As the walls get thin, they move (end grain cuts differently and moves differently than flat grain) and the bowl won't stay round. Also, because it is getting thinner, it doesn't have much mass to keep it from vibrating as the tool is applied, no matter how gentle your touch is. Go down an inch or so, then finish shear cut. Continue down to the bottom of the bowl. After cleaning up the first cut, if you come back after the second cut, you will notice it is out of round. If you clean up this out of roundness, you will notice that the wall it thicker in the end grain, and thinner in the side grain. This is wood movement. I will use my hand as a steady rest on the outside of the bowl. If you apply too much pressure, you can cause the bowl rim to wobble whicn can also cause a dig in and explosion.

robo hippy

Re: what went wrong?

#14

How can I say this....

Allen Neighbors

>I don't really know how to explain how my mind sees this problem, but I'll try. When you are cutting on the inside of the rim of a bowl, if you cut above the center, the wood is travelling away from the cutting edge, and won't catch as easily. When you cut on the outside of a bowl rim, you should cut just a tiny bit below center, the wood will be moving away from the cutting edge, and won't catch as easily.

If I'm trimming a little from the rim, I place my toolrest perpendicular to the ways, and put it at a height that will allow me to cut slightly below center. Then I lower the handle, and start at the inside of the rim, so the cutting edge will be above center. Then, as I move toward the outside of the rim, I slowly raise the handle and by the time I get to the center of the rim, I'm about on center. Then I switch to the outside of the rim, and raise the handle, so I'm cutting just below center. Then as I move toward the inside, I lower the handle so when I get to the center of the rim, (where my other cut stopped) I am about on center.

If that doesn't do it, I'll use sandpaper.

And I've learned to get the rim shaped before I get the bowl to it's final thickness. Because if it's too thin, I don't go back to the rim. I think someone from WC taught me that. :o)

I hope this makes sense to you... I can understand it. :o)

Re: what went wrong?

#15

group thanks first...

GaryG in MD

>I want to sincerely thank everyone who has replied. Those were very clear, to-the-point, and thoughtful answers. I'll reply individually tonight -- right now I've got to take the lathe outside (it's a truly gorgeous day here) and try to fix the mess I made yesterday. ...Gary

Re: what went wrong?

#16

Re: I'll Add......

john lucas

>Wally that's exactly what I was thinking when I read your first thread. Anytime a bowl gets thin scraping can be a problem. The wood can flex and grab the tool and pull it in deeper. If you don't get a catch you do get a bigger gouge than what you wanted. Been there, done that.

Re: what went wrong?

#17

Ric Taylor

Re: what went wrong?

Ric Taylor

>Gary,

All of the other posts give great information on shear scraping. But when I read your post, I think I'm reading what you asked a bit differently.

When you speak of flattening the top of the rim, to me that sounds like when you are trueing up the edge of the rim, in the direction that makes the rim parallel to the table top when the finished bowl is placed on the table. You said the bowl was already round.

When I make that cut, my first preference is to use a parting tool and come straight in from the side. That removes any part of the rim edge that is not parallel with the table top. After that cut, the rim is true, and then I can go to work with the bowl gouge or scrapper.

Ric

Re: what went wrong?

#18

Re: what went wrong?

eliot d

>Hi Gary. I think Bill Gs idea is really interesting, namely to try reconstructing the damaged bowl to see what may have happened. But I bet I know. By way of background, one way to turn near the inside rim of a bowl -- and for that matter all the way in -- is to keep the gauge horizontal ( so the flute is pointing up) and cut with might be called the north west corner of the cutting edge. It's a bit dicy, but there's only a small part of the cutting edge in contact with the wood. This is a good way to turn the inside of a natural edge bowl. My guess, considering that you were trying to do a shear scrape on the inside edge with the tool handle way down, is that the long edge your gauge was in contact with the wood -- not just a small portion of the north west corner. As a result you had lot of metal in contact with the wood so that the slightest vibration, or careless tool handling, caused this long edge to dig in and really grab the wood. On the outside of the bowl, where the bowl is more or less convex, there's no problem at all, and, indeed, one usually gets a very fine surface. But not on the inside.

Re: what went wrong?

#19

spindle gouge

john lucas

>Eliot what your describing wouldn't be a lot different than using a spindle gouge with the flute pointing at 3 oclock or a little less. The top corner of the gouge is doing the cutting.