Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

How do I fix a gouge from a gouge?

Posts

How do I fix a gouge from a gouge?

#1

How do I fix a gouge from a gouge?

Ray Carson - Lawrenceville, NJ

>I'm working on a bowl for a Christmas gift and have a small gouge from a gouge on the inside. I tried turning it out but was fearful of blowing threw the side. I decided to try and sand it out during the sanding process but it's not coming out. It's about the size of a 1/2 dime and it's in the end grain of the turning near where the heart wood would have been. The wood surrounding it is real feathery. The sides are already about 1/4 to 3/16 in thickness and with more sanding I think it's going to get real thin at that spot. I was planning on finishing the bowl with poly or spray lacquer. I wasn't planning on this to be used as a salad bowl or anything. Maybe just a mantel dust collector. :-) (I hope not) I thought about filling it, but with what?

Help !

Ray

Re: How do I fix a gouge from a gouge?

#2

Re: How do I fix a gouge from a gouge?

john lucas

>when they get that thin I use one hand on the outside of the bowl and then turn or shear scrape on the inside to get rid of tear out or in your case a gouge. If you sand it out it will be very uneven. If I'm really nervous about losing the bowl I will use a curved cabinet scraper with the lathe off to level the area. Sanding leaves lumps from the hard and soft grain. A cabinet scraper won't.

Re: How do I fix a gouge from a gouge?

#3

Re: How do I fix a gouge from a gouge?

E. Tabachek

>In addition to what John said try "wetting" the wood with dilluted sanding sealer (Robert Rosand's trick) or dilluted shellac. I shear scrape with the sealer wet or you could let it dry and the wood will be "firmed up" before you apply the tool. Any kind of catch goes deep.

ET

Re: How do I fix a gouge from a gouge?

#4

Re: How do I fix a gouge from a gouge?

Bill Grumbine - Kutztown PA

>Ray, regardless of whether you turn the gouge out or sand it out, you are going to reduce the thickness of the bowl at that point. So why not leave it alone? It is on the inside, and it is a display piece, so no one is really going to care except you and other turners, right?

I would either fill it or leave it be. Filling can be as easy as some sanding dust from the same or similar wood coupled with the finish you are going to use on the piece. Oil finishes like Watco or tung oil are not as hard as film finishes like shellac or polyurethane, but either type should give you good results if you go with filling the hole. In either case, the fix should be just about invisible when the piece is being handled, and is guaranteed to be invisible from normal viewing positions while sitting on the shelf!

Re: How do I fix a gouge from a gouge?

#5

Re: How do I fix a gouge from a gouge?

Dick Coers

>How about an inlay? If you would go in and change the shape of the gouge into something like a maple leaf with a dremel, then inlay some inlace, you would have a piece of art!

I've seen pictures of really old utility wood bowls that had butterfly keys inlaid to stop a crack. Maybe something like that would be nice. For sure it would add to the amount of time to finish it, but maybe a chance for a skill building project. Heck, maybe just woodburn some decoration around it? Just thinking out loud.

Re: How do I fix a gouge from a gouge?

#6

Re: How do I fix a gouge from a gouge?

John K Jordan

>Perhaps gouge it in several other places inside and call it art? [g] Distressed wood is all the rage.

I suspect you cannot sand it out gracefully since sanding will remove the softer wood first and likely result in a horribly uneven surface. Cut or scrape or leave it depending on the depth.

I have good success with a small curved scraper I cut from a curved cabinet scraper. I find this leaves a much smoother surface than sanding and unlike using a gouge or handled scraper while turning, can be applied only where needed. (I use it primarily with the lathe turned off) I usually apply sanding sealer, wax, or oil to end or problem grain first, depending on the intended final finish.

JKJ


img

Re: How do I fix a gouge from a gouge?

#7

I like your ideas Dick.

Ray Carson - Lawrenceville, NJ

>

Re: How do I fix a gouge from a gouge?

#8

Invisible on a shelf.....maybe. :-)

Ray Carson - Lawrenceville, NJ

>In the back of my mind, I'll know it's there. That's the perfectionist in me. I'm going to try and reduce it's appearance a little more but not much. I'm afraid I'll blow out the side if I push the issue. Also, this is from a log I hauled back from Vermont so I really can't turn another. I could also get a hunk of this wood and turn it, but I don't know what kind of wood I'm turning. Plus it wouldn't have the same meaning if you know what I mean. (see - Wood ID / Confirmation? *PIC* Posted By:Ray Carson - Lawrenceville, NJ fishnwood@comcast.net Date:Thursday, 2 October 2008, at 3:49 p.m.)

I agree, sitting on a shelf, hanging on a wall, nobody will really notice it. It's hopefully going to be more of a display piece than someting that will see daily use.

I will post this project soon and you guys and girls can critique my butcher job. :-)

Thanks Bill.

Ray