Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Curved Edge Skew Questions

Posts

Curved Edge Skew Questions

#1

Curved Edge Skew Questions

Tom Minehan

>I am by no means a proficient skew user but through practice I have become proficient enough to use a skew on "real" projects. I recently purchased a skew with a curved edge (Alan Lacer) and just finished a practice session with it and now have a couple of questions.

1) What is the advantage of the curved edge? Does it help some cuts

that are difficult or not possible with a straight edge?

2) I find it easier to roll beads with the long point down (true with either edge). The instructions I find seem to prefer to use the short point down. Is there some sort of "gotcha" using the long point that I haven't encountered yet or is it a matter of user preference?

Re: Curved Edge Skew Questions

#2

Re: Curved Edge Skew Questions

john lucas

>First of all I don't see any advantage to the curved edge but that's just me. I turn beads with either the long point or short point but prefer the short point. At least up until the last little bit on a steep sided bead. In that case I find the long point saver. It's like cutting a really deep V. I'm more comfortable cutting the top part of the bead and shallow beads with the short point.

Re: Curved Edge Skew Questions

#3

Re: Curved Edge Skew Questions

John K Jordan

>Tom,

Some people say the curved edge is more forgiving, one reason being it puts the toe (long point) further from the wood. However, I've never once run the toe into the wood accidentally unless I fell asleep at the lathe. The curved skew I have does seem a bit more stable (but cuts less cleanly) but I think it's because I have it ground at a larger angle. One thing - I find the curved skew certainly more difficult to sharpen correctly!

It does seem that rolling large beads and end cuts with a round skew is a little easier, perhaps since it moves the dangerous part of the edge a little further away from the turning wood. However, I use my skews more often for v-grooves and planing cuts and I prefer a straight grind for both of those. Some like a curved skew for v-grooves claiming it is a bit easier to see the point, but I don't find that a problem.

Darlow claims rolling a bead with the short point results in a smoother cut than the toe since there is more edge to support the cut. I do find it less grabby but I'm still not comfortable turning beads for keeps with either point of the skew. Frank Penta turns beads (at least fairly small beads) with a 1/4" round skew with the long point down - it's fun to watch. He says the real secret is in how you hold your hand at the beginning of the cut, very similar to what Darlow mentions. I'm not completely comfortable with this yet, but I've had more success with this than with a larger skew point down or up, so I'm thinking it has more to do with the very short cutting edge than the direction of the long point.

I'm very interested to hear what others say about this.

BTW, I had a wild idea the other day and modified an old skew for bead rolling and it seemed to work perfectly. The best part, with this modification I COULD NOT MAKE IT CATCH even when I tried! I want to experiment further before I describe the details.

JKJ

Re: Curved Edge Skew Questions

#4

Re: Curved Edge Skew Questions

Russ Fairfield

>I see it as being easier for me to make several cuts with the curved edge - pummels without tear-out on the corners, coves, and planing cuts on the end of the piece. A cove is almost impossible with a straight edge, but becomes quite easy with the curved edge.

Re: Curved Edge Skew Questions

#5

Re: Curved Edge Skew Questions

john lucas

>I almost never dissagree with Russ (how can you) but I don't have any trouble cutting coves with the skew and mine are all straight. I also use the toe of the skew to finish the bottom of goblets and square up the ends of tenons and square sided pommels. I don't have any problems. I tried the same things with the curved skew and found no difference. I love to play with skews and have a convex bevel skew also which has been toughted as being the greatest thing since slice bread. I do find it harder to use than a flat or concave bevel.

I frequently hear the idea that a curved edge skew will keep the tip further from the wood to reduce catches. This is silly. When you are cutting with the skew you should have the cut on the lower 1/3 or at least half. If you get above this you risk a catch because the skew is not flat on the tool rest and the higher you go the more leverage the wood produces on the skew and eventually pulls it into the wood with disastrous results. Although the very top of the curved edge skew is futher away from the wood than a straight edge you will have reached the disastrous area sooner than this. If you are cutting on the lower 1/3 where you should be the two skews are cutting at virtually the same angle and the area slightly above this is also virtually the same. It's only when you get above the 1/2 way point that they differ and then it's too late.

You can cut with the upper 1/3 but you better know what your doing. I have done vary narrow coves using just the first 1/4" of the toe end of a 1" skew with the toe up. This would normally be a total disaster but if you know how to keep it on the bevel and control the size of cut you can get away with it.

Now I'm not saying a curved skew is bad. In fact the only thing I don't like about a curved skew is that I find them harder to sharpen than a straight edge. It's like many tools, if you get used to it this is the one you like. Many people buy a curved tool and all of the sudden they are turning with the skew and couldn't before. I suspect this is because they put out more effort to use the skew and practice with it and consquently learned to use it. As Nick Cook says, there are a certain number of catches built into every skew and you have to use them up. In other word Practice, practice, practice.

Re: Curved Edge Skew Questions

#6

Re: Curved Edge Skew Questions

Greg Haugen

>Both have their purposes. I have to side with Russ, I like a curved skew 99% of the time. As a general rule the angle should be "approx." 70 degrees from the toe (long point) to the heel (short point). The Lacer grind has the top 1/3 straight then a radius down, still being 70 degrees. It creates a "belly" of the cutting edge that is out in front of the points. I like this grind because it is the easiest to do a "peeling" cut, a fast waste removing cut. They're also have enough heft to remove alot of material and yet do fine work with no vibration issues. Since both skews usually and at least for a starting point have the "skew" angle the same- the use of either is the same. If you use one you should be able to use the other. I do roll beads ALMOST all fo the time with the heel, short point. I only use the toe, long point, if the bead is in a tight location. Rolling a bead with the toe requires a lot more "handle" travel, more so than a "heel" rolled bead. Practice both, you will use both at some point.

A skew should be at least "diamond honed" after it's ground. "Scary sharp" is a term used to describe the sharpness of a skew.

A curved skew, my Fav. is the 5/8" Lacer, I'll pick up and turn a project from start to finish, from taking it round from square stock to the finishing details, beads, v cuts, coves, etc. A straight skew I'll pick up, make a cut and put it back down. It's not so much the cutting edge configuration as much as the size and thickness of the skew though.

IF you're in MN, WI, or IA I'd be happy to help you out with the skew.

Just my two cents......

Greg H.

Re: Curved Edge Skew Questions

#7

Steven Antonucci

I use curved, and Lacer's grind

steve antonucci

>I like the little flat section he leaves on the long point. I find it's more useful than working with the long point, and I can still cut V's with it.

As for the curved edge, I have one skew without it. I think it's like having two different tools. I agree with John Lucas that it's a matter of practice, but the curved edge is much more forgiving, since you need to make two mistakes with it to get a spiral.

If you think about it, the contact point will have relief on either side of the cut, since the edge is radiused. This means that as you move, a small amount of "oops" results in losing bevel contact, but putting the cutting edge off of the wood.

With a straight ground edge, I don't lose that contact, and start pusting the cutting edge towards one or the other end of the skew. If it's that long point, I'm in trouble...

Steve

Re: Curved Edge Skew Questions

#8

Re: Curved Edge Skew Questions

Carol - now back in Dubuque, IA

>"a certain number of catches in each skew"

Love it!

That true of every turning tool, John?

Re: Curved Edge Skew Questions

#9

Re: Curved Edge Skew Questions

Carol - now back in Dubuque, IA

>The, does that mean if I borrow an 'experienced' skew, I won't have any catches with it, because they have all been let out?

One can wish...

Think of the market for "experienced" skews!

Re: Curved Edge Skew Questions

#10

Re: I use curved, and Lacer's grind

john lucas

>Steve My take on that is the contact point is very small in comparison to the radius. So the difference in 1/8" above or below the contact point will be virtually the same on a curved or straight skew. Think of a curved skew having a radius of 5,6 or 8". Your only cutting on 1/4 or less depending on the size of the spindle. I could be wrong but I don't think the metal would be much further away from the wood on a radius skew vs a flat skew.

Re: Curved Edge Skew Questions

#11

Re: Curved Edge Skew Questions

Ed in Leaside

>I think my skews still have more than a few catches left in them. ;-)

Re: Curved Edge Skew Questions

#12

Steven Antonucci

Here's a picture from my 2 skews

steve antonucci

>I think this picture illustrates the point I was trying to get across.

First, even though the radiused skew is twice as wide as the straight skew, the contact patch is smaller. Smaller contact patch means more forgiving of mistakes, less like to catch (although I still get them if I'm not paying attention. It's a hard thing to tell from the shot, but the radius moves both the top and bottom edges away from the cut beyond the 1/8" contact patch.

Secondly, imagine moving the tools along in three dimensions.

If I go left to right, either tool is fine, since they would both maintain the same relationship to the wood (unless there is a diameter change!)

If I move slightly up or down, I begin to get towards the danger zone with the straight skew, since my cutting edge is still engaged with the wood. With the radius, I lose bevel contact and just stop cutting...

This is the only Skew I own with a straight edge, and I don't use it all that much because I simply can't cut with it. The other three I own are all radiused, and two have the flat ground sections like the one you see here for a "peeling cut" as described by Lacer (who showed it to me at Totally Turning).

No doubt, it's all about what you practice.

Steve


img

Re: Curved Edge Skew Questions

#13

Re: Sharp is more important than profile

Russ Fairfield

>I believe a sharp edge is more important on a skew than whether it is straight or curved, ot the bevel is concave, convex, or flat. Whichever we use, the skew has to be the sharpest tool we own. The sharper it is, the better it cuts, and the easier it is to cintrol.

Re: Curved Edge Skew Questions

#14

Re: Here's a picture from my 2 skews

wilbur

>That's a great explanation, Steve.

But now I'm depressed. I used to think that I just occasionally screwed up with my curved skew, and now I've learned that I'm actually making twice as many mistakes. :@)

Re: Curved Edge Skew Questions

#15

Re: Here's a picture from my 2 skews

john lucas

>Steve I think the photo lies. When I am cutting with my straight edge skews I get a small sliver of wood coming over the edge. Even when taking pretty big cuts. The photo makes it look like there is a large patch but in reality it won't take that big of a bite.

One of the reasons your small skew catches more is the sharpening angle is much sharper. At least that's my guess because the bevel is much longer. I'll bet if you ground it to the same angle as the larger one you enjoy it more.

Re: Curved Edge Skew Questions

#16

Steven Antonucci

No, actually completely the opposite :-)

steve antonucci

>The two skews are both ground across the width at about 40 degrees or so from corner to corner. I don't obsess over angles, so I don't know the exact angle. The edge on the curved radius one is considerable sharper than the straight one, by at least 5 degrees. (I just checked it with a bevel gauge, and the radiused one is "acuter"!)

The illusion is caused by the radiused one being <3/16" thick. The straight one is a full 1/4" thick, hence the longer appearance on the blunter angle. It's actually no where near as sharp as the other one...

Steve

Re: Curved Edge Skew Questions

#17

cannot agree more.

john lucas

>

Re: Curved Edge Skew Questions

#18

Re: Here's a picture from my 2 skews

John K Jordan

>>It's a hard thing to tell from the shot, but the radius

>moves both the top and bottom edges away from the cut

I did a quick 3D model illustrating this. (below)

I used a curved skew edge, a straight skew edge, and for comparison, an insanely concave curved skew edge.

Each edge is sharpened at 40 degrees and touching the wood at 5 degrees clearance angle. For simplicity (read: I didn't make the effort), the cutting angles are set to an unrealistic 0 degrees (or 90 degrees, depending on how you measure).

At the top I plotted the clearance at the closest points between the workpiece and each skew edge. This clearly shows the increased space afforded by the curved skew (blue line) compared to the straight grind (green line) and horrors, the insane concave edge. (Someone ought to grind one like that just for fun and have a little planing contest!)

The difference between the curved and straight edge is especially striking if I zoom in on the lines in my cad program.

Note that these lines are shown tangent without the skew biting into the wood. Imagine that and it's easy to see how the difference in the "contact patch" sizes you mention increases.

To visualize the effect of tilting the skew 45 degrees or so into a realistic cutting position, imagine the circle changing into an ellipse with the long axis vertical - as the angle increases, the overall clearance decreases while the difference between the straight and curved edges further increases. (Extreme endpoint: the flat skew has 100% contact while the curved still has some clearance.)

JKJ


img

Re: Curved Edge Skew Questions

#19

Re: Here's a picture from my 2 skews

davidwalser

>John,

Dude, you've got way too much time on your hands.

Seriously, even though I prefer a traditional grind to my skew, I think a radius grind is less prone to catch on a planing cut. The reason is that I'm less apt to allow the short point to dig in with a radius ground skew than I am with a straight skew. Having said that, I find the traditional grind to be more flexible. I can turn a bead with either the long point or the short point. I can plane with the long point up or down. And, I can do a peeling cut with the entire width of the blade. It's simply a matter of personal preference, like choosing among blonds, brunettes, and redheads. (Since my wife's hair color keeps changing, I'm glad I don't have strong preferences in that regard, either.)

Re: Curved Edge Skew Questions

#20

Re: Curved Edge Skew Questions *LINK*

charlie belden in san jose ca

>Again, late to a thread, but here goes.

Before I was shown how to grind a curve on my straight edge skews - they scared me. I seemed to get more catches than cuts when using them.

But once the toe point and heel corner were ground back things changed dramatically - for me. I began using my skews as the tool of choice for just about everything I was doing - both spindle work, lidded boxes, platters, small bowls and even some larger opening "hollow forms". I even use them for roughing to round some times.

Regarding cuts that can be done with a curved edge skew that I don't thing can be done with a straight edge skew - check out the one at the bottom of the attached link page.

I doubt if it's Good Form to rough cut pretty quickly using just the very end of the long, but it works for me.

I suspect that a lot of how much you like or dislike a too has to do with how much and how often you use it.


Ogee cut with curved edge skew

Re: Curved Edge Skew Questions

#21

Re: Here's a picture from my 2 skews

John K Jordan

>>Dude, you've got way too much time on your hands.

You got that right! Since I broke the ribs last week I can't ride the horse, mow the grass, build the barn, get a good night's sleep, or even pick the okra. In fact, I can't do much other than read, sit at the computer, or run at the mouth (includes whining and moaning)!

JKJ

Re: Curved Edge Skew Questions

#22

THANKS to ALL for the FANTASTIC Responses

Tom Minehan

>