Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Should a chuck seat fully against the spindle?

Posts

Should a chuck seat fully against the spindle?

#1

Should a chuck seat fully against the spindle?

wilbur

>I recently bought a used Conover lathe, and needed a new chuck to go along with it. I picked up a Vicmarc VM120 with a 1-1/2"x8 tpi insert, which does fit onto the spindle. However, I noticed that I get a fair amount of wobble with this chuck. I don't get wobble or runout with anything else that I use on the spindle: drive centers, faceplates, or an old 3 jaw chuck that came with the lathe.

In looking closely at the VM120 chuck, it looks like that the insert doesn't seat all the way up against the spindle. There's a 0.15" (3/16") gap between the shoulders of the insert and the shoulder of the spindle, so that the chuck is just resting on the threads of the spindle without any other point of contact. I've included a picture to show this.

The other faceplates and the 3 jaw chuck do seat all the way against the spindle.

It looks like this is happening because the 1-1/2"x8 tpi threads in the insert start too close to the end of the insert to allow the insert to seat all the way down against the shoulder of the spindle. If this is the case, all I'll have to do is bore out the end of the insert by about 3/16" so that there will be enough room for the insert to seat all the way onto the spindle. But I wanted to check to see if I was on the right track.


img

Re: Should a chuck seat fully against the spindle?

#2

Re: Should a chuck seat fully against the spindle?

Brian Simmons, Heflin, AL

>I ran into the same problem on my Jet. A couple of chucks did not seat and did not run very true. Made a bushing that I put on whenever I add a chuck and the runout is much less. Hope this helps.

Re: Should a chuck seat fully against the spindle?

#3

Re: Should a chuck seat fully against the spindle? *LINK*

Dave Peebles Lyons, Ohio!

>Hi Wilbur,

I did notice on the Oneway site that they list a different insert for the Conover than for the Powermatic 90. Even though they both have the 1-1/2 X 8 spindle thread. It may be something to check into.

Dave


OneWay chuck inserts

Re: Should a chuck seat fully against the spindle?

#4

Leo Van Der Loo

Re: Should a chuck seat fully against the spindle? *LINK*

Leo Van Der Loo

>Wilbur yes the chuck should back onto the shoulder, but why don't you try a machined washer between the chuck and spindle, or even a regular one that is nice and flat, should help IMO.

Have fun and take care

Leo Van Der Loo


http://homepage.mac.com/l.vanderloo/PhotoAlbum4.html

Re: Should a chuck seat fully against the spindle?

#5

Yes.

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>You are on the right track. The chuck should seat fully against the spindle.

I had the same problem with a face plate for my Conover. I used a rotary die grinder (a Dremel would work just fine) to grind back the threads on the face plate.

Re: Should a chuck seat fully against the spindle?

#6

Re: Should a chuck seat fully against the spindle?

john lucas

>Wilbur Craft Supplies sells a nylon washer that works perfectly in this situation although I don't remember if they have one that's large enough for the Conover. You can probably make one from a milk jug. It might be close to .015, if not make 2. Many people have use this method to keep the chuck from freezing against the spindle but it also makes a good spacer.

Re: Should a chuck seat fully against the spindle?

#7

Re: Should a chuck seat fully against the spindle?

Don Evans

>Yes you are correct in your thinking. There are two things that can cause this problem.

1. normally you need an area just inside the insert that has no threads IF your spindle's threads end before disappearing into the headstock bearing.

2. the spindle bottoms out inside the insert BEFORE the chuck seats against the headstock bearing.

Either of these will cause the chuck or faceplate to wobble because the threads are turned 60 deg.

You can go to a machine shop and have them turn a spacer to put on spindle first, it must have both sides turned flat and 90 deg's to its center line. This will cause the chuck to hit it before running out of thread and lock it straight.

John is right about the washer but if you lock the chuck down really tight you can still compress the washer on one side and get wobble. The machine shop should make one for you out of steel.

Other option is the insert mentioned above for that lathe.

Don

Re: Should a chuck seat fully against the spindle?

#8

ebd

Re: Should a chuck seat fully against the spindle?

ebd

>It certainly does need to seat. I had my next door machinist true a thick washer for me and I also tries the nylon washers. Both methods improved the runout but were not perfect. Since this was an Axminister chuck and thus very pricy I returned the insert for the correct one. I would advise you to do the same. In addition to not being perfect, using a spacer is a pain in the a55 and if you drop the spacer in the shavings or lose it in the middle of a project...

Re: Should a chuck seat fully against the spindle?

#9

1/4" MDF

Jerry Hall

>I got tired of sweeping up and throwing away my purchased washers. So I made some "temporary" ones out of plastic coffee can lids. Worked fine until I lost those too. Now I just make a bunch of 1/4 mdf squares, bore out the exact size for my spindle. Mounted several at a time with a spindle nut and turn them round. Hang them on a hook near my lathe. I started out with a dozen, and am now down to 4 or so. But heck it's taken me 2 years to lose the other eight! The 1/4 mdf runs very true best I can tell. Now I use similar washers to adjust the exposure of my screw chucks as needed, and it saves tools too for close in work. After I lose these and I make some more I am going to spray paint them International Orange.

Re: Should a chuck seat fully against the spindle?

#10

Re: Make your own spacer?

Russ Fairfield

>You are going to need a lot more than the thickness of a coffee can lid. More like 1/2". An option for a durable spacer is to make it from a piece of end-grain OAK with the grain running through the thickness. You can part these off of a longer piece that has been bored and turned round. The surfaces will be parallel and the washer flat enough from the parting tool. The cuts don't have to be perfect. These spacers will last for years if you don't lose them.

Other options from steel are arbor collars for shaper cutters (look in the Grizzly catalog or on-line), or shaft collars available at a bearing store. A ball bearing with a bore to match the spindle also works.

Re: Should a chuck seat fully against the spindle?

#11

LOL!

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>I am not sure I would have admitted to that. :-)

Re: Should a chuck seat fully against the spindle?

#12

Thanks

wilbur

>Thanks for the input. I'm going to try to turn down the threads in the chuck insert using a metal lathe to allow it to seat up against that shoulder. I thought about a washer or spacer, but to me that's two more potential sources for runout, and I know I'll lose it within 30 minutes. :@)

Re: Should a chuck seat fully against the spindle?

#13

Re: 1/4" MDF

Wesley Thompson

>You might try having a spacer made out of steel and have a auto body person to weld it to the insert. I did this with a Nova chuck on a Powermatic. He will be able to machine the weld so that it will be smooth. Hope this helps. Happy turning.

Re: Should a chuck seat fully against the spindle?

#14

Success!!! (illustrated)

wilbur

>I was able to fix the insert so that it seats all the way onto my spindle. At first, I was standing in my shop, wondering what the best way would be to try to remove a bit of the thread on the chuck insert. "If only there was a way to hold the insert and turn it around so that I could scrape away the inside of it. Hmmmmmm....."

Well, duh!

Fixing insert for Conover lathe

This first attempt was not real successful. Although I had this extra three jaw chuck that came with the lathe, the jaws did not have the best grip on the outside threaded area, and there was some runout as the insert was not perfectly centered.

Then I had a better idea. I simply threaded the insert directly onto the spindle backwards. This did a great job of holding the insert. I set up a tool rest and took a scraper and set the pulleys to the lowest speed I could, and started removing metal from the inside of the insert. This is a simulated action shot.

Fixing insert for Conover lathe

Again, I ran into some difficulty. After removing what I thought was enough thread, it seemed that the insert did not seat any further onto the spindle. After taking some measurements with calipers, It turned out that the issue was that the flat, non-threaded part of the insert wasn't wide enough to completely fit over the non-threaded part of the spindle. I had assumed that it was, since the opening of the insert was a little wider and did go over the non-threaded part of the spindle. A little more scraping, and I had success.

Fixing insert for Conover lathe

I chucked up a piece of wood and proceeded to hack away at a bowl I was working on. The chuck worked great -- no wobble or runout. The downside of fixing the issue with my chuck insert is that now I have no more excuses for turned pieces that turn out bad. :@)

I don't think i removed too much thread from the inside of the insert that would cause any problems, but if I have problems down the road, all I'll have to do is get another insert.

Thanks for all the input!

Re: Should a chuck seat fully against the spindle?

#15

Leo Van Der Loo

Re: Success!!! (illustrated) *LINK*

Leo Van Der Loo

>Well done Wilbur, I suggested the spacer or washer so you could find out if the seating was the problem as we assumed, yes this or another insert is the answer, now show us some of your work.

Have fun and take care

Leo Van Der Loo


http://homepage.mac.com/l.vanderloo/PhotoAlbum25.html

Re: Should a chuck seat fully against the spindle?

#16

Leo, this bowl picture is for you

wilbur

>"Well done Wilbur, I suggested the spacer or washer so you could find out if the seating was the problem as we assumed, yes this or another insert is the answer, now show us some of your work.

Have fun and take care

Leo Van Der Loo "

Hi Leo,

As you suggested, here are the first two bowls I completed with my newly tuned up Conover lathe. I think they are black locust, and are the last remnants of the wood that I got from my neighbor that I was complaining about a while ago because it has been just kicking my butt, since it's so hard.

Actually, I have a little more of this stuff, but it's going to go into the fireplace. I'm looking forward to turning something easier, like white oak. :@) After dealing with this wood, cherry, maple, and walnut are going to be a walk in the park from now on.


img

Re: Should a chuck seat fully against the spindle?

#17

Leo Van Der Loo

Re: Leo, this bowl picture is for you *LINK*

Leo Van Der Loo

>Hi Wilbur, nice going, and here's to show that even the toughest wood doesn't stop you from turning it, so everything else is going to be turned easier, and make it fun;-)).

Have fun and take care

Leo Van Der Loo


http://homepage.mac.com/l.vanderloo/PhotoAlbum4.html

Re: Should a chuck seat fully against the spindle?

#18

Re: Leo, this bowl picture is for you

Nick

>Nice work and nice wood. Is it locust?