>These are my first attempts at making peppermills. They will be Xmas gifts. They are 10 inches tall and made from walnut and maple. The pictures were enligntening in showing that I have some work to do in getting more continuous curves. Overall I'm pleased with these but can see areas of improvement. All comment on the turnings and the photo are appriciated. Of the group which one has the best form?? Oh, the small one is a salt mill.
>Looks like you got a good start there,my favorite ones are from left to right are #2,4 an 5.The noggin on 3 sorta looks odd,sorry and 1 an 6 seem like they could use a little more detail.Just trying to offer some opinions on them,so don't take it personal.Heck I havn't made one yet,but will this winter.
>I like the one 3rd from left simply because it looks like it will fit you hand top and bottom and be easier to use, although for your first ones, good going, make one for me!!! DonL
>Number 3 is my favorite as well. It's very close to Sokolowski's mills, www.sokolowskistudios.com. It would be perfect if it just was a "touch" lighter in the top. I'm not a big fan of the mills with a lot "weight" or droop in the form of the top, like the other tops. I like mills with a little more of a robust top. With that said, I also like the last one. Sometimes a simple form is all that "outstanding" wood needs.
The key to any of this is you're having fun exploring "design". Nice job!!
The one on the far right has sort of art deco quality to it. Putting three groves at the top, bottom and "middle" might intensify that art deco appeal. The lines in the top and the bottom could be a curve instead of straight lines. Think of a big arc with a 30" or 40" radius. The shape will be very close to what you have now but will have the pleasing effect that a curve imparts.
The one on the far left needs some sort of connection in form between the top and body. The rounded details on the top could be echoed in the body or the bead in the body could be echoed in the top
>congratulations Ed, your work shows considerable skills. I also like #3, it's an interesting style, with one small caveat. You may think I'm a just a dirty ole man or a prude but 2,3,4, and 5 all appear a bit too phallic for my taste. I also like the one on the far right and have previously turned several in that simple elegant style.
Nice! That sure looks like a lot of work - you will certainly have some happy people at Christmas time!
Since you asked for comments, my opinion (while under the influence of narcotics, I might add :), and without reading the other comments:
I like the top shape of #2/#4/#5 (ignoring the small one in the numbering). I like the shape of the body of #4 - it looks elegant, and the overall look of #2 and #5 the best. The overall shape of #6 is nice (tends toward Osolnik's candlesticks) but has one problem from my point-of-view: the curve between the bottom and top is not as continuous as it might be. Another little grove right at the junction might be interesting.
Another thing you might consider for those where you have a bead at the junction, such as #2 and #3: adding a bit of crispness to the detail, for example a tight v-grove with a skew. On the other hand, I imagine #5 would suffer from a crisp groove and may in fact benefit from blending the cove even a bit more into the top.
I'm not a fan of the marshmallow top of #1 and the salt grinder but perhaps it feels good in the hand. If it is intended to be part of a set with the salt grinder, the body looks a bit top-heavy.
The top of #6 makes me wonder if the edge is uncomfortable, hard to guess from a photo. The top of #3 seems a bit large to me but hey, it's starting to grow on me - if it were a bit more egg-shaped and with a sharp detail line above the bead it might be reminiscent of an egg sitting in a tall eggcup, or perhaps something vaguely alien!
I guess my favorite is #5. But I can't see how anyone can proclaim which has the absolute "best form" - what makes one best over another? Think how boring life would be if we all liked the same shapes.
>Wow, these look better than my first mills! I like #3 the best because the top is large enough and round enough to grip firmly. The others with compound curves look more difficult to use.
A great start. Man, I should take some pictures of what I have at the gallery to get feedback on them....
>Thnaks for all your constructive comments. I will incorporate them as I turn more. My choice was between 3 and 5. Number 1 was the first one I turned and I did not like it, top too small. Thanks again.