Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

sanding/finishing

Posts

sanding/finishing

#1

sanding/finishing

Jim Rutten

>Okay. The answer to this question may be a "duh, yes" and feel free to regail me with it. I am the type of person you have to hit over the head with something in order to get through. I have been working on a bowl out of sycamore which is giving me a lot of trouble. My methodology for finishing:

1. Shear scrape. After I have done this the bowl is fairly smooth and the end grain tearout is not as pronounced.

2. Start progressing through the grits

a. sand with grits at slow speed (I do NOT skip grits)

b. wipe off extra dust between grits with paper towel

c. hand sand anything that stands out

Yesterday, I did a quick turn of a small cherry bowl and it looks great. The finish is excellent. When I use the same methodolgy with the the sycamore I get, for lack of a better term, streaks. These streaks are not noticable by touch. but are a different color than the rest of the bowl. They are not by a knot hole such that it could be causing it.

So, it occurred to me (get ready with the "duh, yes") maybe some wood is just not going to make good bowls. Maybe it is time to give up on this sycamore and turn cherry for the rest of my life. That would be difficult given there is not that much cherry in Kansas. So, are there any types of wood you have given up on?

Re: sanding/finishing

#2

Re: sanding/finishing

Jim Rutten

>Question 2 would be are there any types of wood you never say no to because you know you will always get a superior finish?

Re: sanding/finishing

#3

Re: sanding/finishing

Mike Jones, Redding, CA

>Jim, You haven't told us about 2 (d) what you apply first after your sanding. If you apply an oil finish for example, without first using a sealer, you can get blotchy or streaky darks spots.

To check this, go back to a coarse grit, and sand through the streaky areas, then use your protocol same as before, but put a sanding sealer on ahead of your 'other' finish.

I use a sealer 99% of the time, regardless of my planned finish and regardless of the wood type. I use both lacquer and shellac sanding sealers

Re: sanding/finishing

#4

Keith Tompkins

Re: sanding/finishing

keith tompkins

>Jim , The sycamore is soft, often the heel of the gouge will bruise the wood, while the tip cuts, the pressure is against the heel. The bruising shows up when the finish is applied. One solution is to take an extremely light finishing cut with a freshly sharpened tool. Also, grind a bit of the heel away, rounding it over to avoid the problem. Last, lightly dampen the bowl before final sanding....it will help raise the grain, and some of the bruising. This happens with cherry too, but not so severe. Hope this helps.

Re: sanding/finishing

#5

Re: sanding/finishing

Ed McDonnell

>I'll try and turn just about anything once.

Here's some that won't get a second chance on my lathe:

Melalueca, Bischofia, Monkey Puzzle, any type of ficus (aka banyan, aka strangler fig), Ti, Carrotwood, any true north american pine, Live Oak, Gumbo Limbo, Green Buttonwood, Pond Apple, any fan type palm.

Here's some that I generally swear won't get another chance but ultimately do because the results are great if you tough it out:

Royal or Alexander Palm, Australian Pine, Lignum Vitae, Bottlebrush Burl, Chinese Orchid.

Ed

Re: sanding/finishing

#6

Re: sanding/finishing

Bill Neddow------WebKitFormBoundary+w+uCg3oRve3I+f

>Right on, Keith. That is the solution.

Re: sanding/finishing

#7

One question Keith

Jim Rutten

>You said moisten the wood before final sanding. Can you be more specific? Before 400 grit? 320?

Re: sanding/finishing

#8

Re: sanding/finishing

Jim Rutten

>I haven't even got to putting finish on it, Mike. These streaks also don't show up until the last couple of grits. It honestly looks like someone took a 1/2 wide paint brush and painted about an inch long with a slightly darker stain than the wood.

Re: sanding/finishing

#9

Steven Antonucci

Agreed.

steve antonucci

>

Re: sanding/finishing

#10

Steven Antonucci

Cocobolo

steve antonucci

>There are certainly woods that I don't make any concerted effort to accumulate, but I don't think I'd call it "give up", as much as better options.

The one exception is cocobolo. Having developed a sensitivity to it earlier this year, and having my eyes swell and itch for a week, I'm happy to give away any and all of the cocobolo pieces that I currently have (which isn't much-just a couple of pen blanks!)

Steve

Re: sanding/finishing

#11

Keith Tompkins

Re: One question Keith

keith tompkins

>HI Jim, Let me clarify a bit. If you start with a coarse grit, moisten the wood from that point, to raise the grain. Deep scratches from 80 grit are hard to sand out, but moisture raises the deep scratches closer to the surface, making the job of the next grit easier. I lightly moisten some woods between each grit, if needed, but I usually start with 220 grit, so usually only one or two cycles of moisture are necessary.

Re: sanding/finishing

#12

Re: Cocobolo

John K Jordan

>>I'm happy to give away any and all of the cocobolo

>pieces that I currently have

Steve,

If I ever develop serious sensitivity to wood dust I'll know what NOT to send to who! (I must have several hundred pounds in big pieces of cocobolo.) I'll put you down for the walnut or cherry or the maple burls or something. :)

Cocobolo dust does irritate my skin but long sleeves, a dust mask (of course) and a shower prevents a problem for me. Without that I too will itch for days.

JKJ

Re: sanding/finishing

#13

Steven Antonucci

Walnut is #2 on the list

steve antonucci

>I get a little itchy, and a runny nose, but usually a hot shower to wash away all of the fine dust is enough to save the day. I've been giving away a lot of walnut too, but I still have a bunch.

Now, those maple burls sound like a good idea :-)

Steve

Re: sanding/finishing

#14

Re: sanding/finishing

GaryG in MD

>Jim,

I agree with Keith -- it's probably heel pressure. Take a look at page 12 of http://montgomerycountywoodturners.org/Documents/MCW%20Newsletter%202008-09.pdf

I had the same experience with Bradford Pear.

Remove the heel and do as Stuart Batty -- "float the bevel" with one finger on each side of the tool shaft. See page 12

http://montgomerycountywoodturners.org/Documents/MCW%20Newsletter%202008-08.pdf

Note his finger position in the photos.

Hope this helps, Gary