Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Spindle Gouge Help

Posts

Spindle Gouge Help

#1

Spindle Gouge Help

GalenV

>Being new to turning I stayed away from small fine spindle work like finials, Chistmas ornaments, and tops for lack of knowledge how to use a spindle gouge for small details. I did not need for doing pens.

The spindle gouge in a set of tools I bought is terrible to try and use. 7/16" dia. with flute about 50% of diameter. Factory ground to a pencil point! Sweep maybe 35 degree and bevel 25. Looks similar to the detail gouge shown in tool grinds on Wood Central. Great for catches as hard to rub a bevel like it has. I see Thompson even has three types of spindle gouges based on flute depth alone, let alone knowing best grind angles. I see in some video spindle gouges being used to cut up hill as well as downhill on these small turnings. No rules seem to apply. I may get lots of variation but would like to hear experienced turners opinion on a spindle gouge size and grind for small turnings. Link to a good video or pictures of grinds would be great.

Thanks

Galen

Re: Spindle Gouge Help

#2

Re: Spindle Gouge Help

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>Galen, the way I discribe the three tools is like this;

Spindle gouge - made for long flowing curves.

Detail gouge - made to turn coves and beads.

Shallow detail gouge - made for offset turning.

Flute depth is everything on a spindle tools, a flute depth of 50% on a spindle gouge creates a wide flute while a flute depth of 33% like on a detail gouge creates a narrower flute that has extra steel on each side of the flute so it can be ground into a fingernail shape.

I would like to hear what everyone else thinks about this.

Re: Spindle Gouge Help

#3

JL

Look up Fingernail grind *LINK*

JL

>Another resource is the WC Tool grinds library - though that has mostly bowl grinds in it (http://www.woodcentral.com/newforum/grinds.shtml).

I use a fingernail grind on my spindle gouges. I've got a 3/8" for fine stuff and a 1/2" for general stuff - I also use a small roughing gouge for general work.


Turned Treasures

Re: Spindle Gouge Help

#4

Re: Spindle Gouge Help

Greg Haugen

>Not all gouges are created equal either. Henry Taylor spindle gouge have much higher "sides or wings" than say a Sorby. While comparing my Sorby to my Taylor, it's almost a thin walled bowl gouge it seems. For 95% of my spindle details, heck spindle turning in general, I like my Thompson 3/8" detail gouge. I also think the majority of the time a 3/8" size of any spindle gouge is enough. I recently turned a 14" diameter table support that was stave constructed and I used the detail gouge for the beads. I don't use my 1/2" size very often it's probably my dustiest tool, it is nice for suttle, sweeping curves but I'll often use a skew or roughing gouge for that.

Also often times in these "sets", especially the less expensive style gouges are "forged" or more commonly known as "continental gouges" with horrible grinds from the factory. In my opinion, they're more limited in their use than round bar gouges.

When I teach "sharpening" I don't use a "specific" angle. The angle is related to the presentation of the gouge to the wood. It varies. For spindle and detail gouges any where from 30 to 45 degrees will work. 45 degrees being the "top" end of a spindle gouge range and also the bottom end for a bowl gouge. 30-45 for spindle and 45-60 for a bowl gouge. I tell students to grind the tip so it's a half of a circle or arch-if it's a little less that no big deal but it's a guideline. A lot of times I think the gouges can get too pointed. The swept sides could be anywhere from 1/2 to 3/4 of the diameter of the gouge for a spindle gouge. The key is to get the "tips or corners" off.

For a "first" spindle gouge, I'd say a 3/8". Most newer turners will start with "bottle corkers" etc. as "skill building" projects and a 1/2" gouge can be "large" for those details. The amount of grind on a detail gouge can be a challenge for a "newer" turner to get right, even with a jig.

Just my two cents...

Greg H.

Re: Spindle Gouge Help

#5

Keith Tompkins

Re: Spindle Gouge Help

keith tompkins

>HI Galen, I've posted this image several times, but it should be helpful. Starting the cut on the centerline with the flute at 90 degrees to the turning is the traditional way to start beads or coves. If you only learn to cut flute-up, you will never discover the true usefulness of the spindle gouge. My gouges are ground with a swept-back grind at a 45 degree angle, if that helps.


img

Re: Spindle Gouge Help

#6

Re: Spindle Gouge Help

John K Jordan

>Keith, do you have that in a bigger image - the text is difficult to read.

If you can't get the file size reduced enough for WC I could probably do it for you if you email a larger image.

JKJ

Re: Spindle Gouge Help

#7

Keith's image, bigger 

John K Jordan

>


img

Re: Spindle Gouge Help

#8

Re: Spindle Gouge Help- Thank you

GalenV

>I thank you all for your input.

I save printed copies of helpful pictures in a three ring binder by the lathe for reference.

Carol Reed's request for tools for finials added to the information.

I did all right on practice beads and cover and did a dozen wine stoppers. My problem comes when the spindle diameters shrink and I guess it is in part a need for more practice and better tool shape and control.

Carol says she has a Thompson 1/4" detail gouge but that size is not listed so she must have a special order? Doug maybe you can confirm what she really has and if it is your 33% flute depth?

The Ames Woodturners Club I joined has a demostration weekend at our local mall so hope to get some needed help on small turnings.

Thanks again

Galen

Re: Spindle Gouge Help

#9

Re: Spindle Gouge Help- Thank you

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>Carol has a 3/8 detail which the same tool could be called a 1/4 if you measure the width of the flute or buy a European brand. In this world sizes can get very confusing.

Re: Spindle Gouge Help

#10

Re: Spindle Gouge size

GalenV

>Thanks Doug:

Different terms are used to describe the same thing at times so makes it hard for someone new to understand.

What is the "skewchigouge" you reference in Carol's message? Don't see it identified in your web site. Something new or play on words?

Seems like it is used in reference to cutting finials then you say it is good for turning bowls when in a bigger size.

Confussed

Galen

Re: Spindle Gouge Help

#11

Re: Spindle Gouge size

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>Galen, look at the other post about spindle tools. Ron in Drums PA has a picture of his grind which is perfect. Hopefully he can post it.

Re: Spindle Gouge Help

#12

Re: Spindle Gouge size - skewchigouge

Carol - now back in Dubuque, IA

>I also have a skewchigouge, but not one of Doug's. It is a pretty special purpose tool, useful for a few seconds of turning in the grand scheme of things. I've used it for a slight undercut to create a 'band' in nearly the same plane as the rest of the bowl surface. Sorry I can't provide a picture as I no longer have that bowl. Went out the door as a gift.

But I can see its usefulness on finials for a slight undercut of the 'onion' top of the finial to add definition to the shape and to emphasize the elegance of the stem to the bulb top.

Re: Spindle Gouge Help

#13

Re: Spindle Gouge size

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>EDIT - For Bowls a larger diameter piece of steel is used. I have played with 5/8 stock which works well.