Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Wood ID / Confirmation?

Posts

Wood ID / Confirmation?

#1

Wood ID / Confirmation?

Ray Carson - Lawrenceville, NJ

>Hello,

My wife and I recently visited Vermont (Manchester area) and we were staying at my Boss's house. I noticed he had downed a few trees. I can't say how long the pile of logs had been there. As a possible Christmas gift and thank you for letting us stay there, I brought a log home that sounded solid upon thumping it with a hammer. (very high tech stuff) I checked as best I could for cracks, splits, etc.

I think this log is from a Maple tree. I didn't have any leaves to post, sorry. Anyway, after halving the log and taking a thin slice, I noticed some radial cracks. I started second guessing myself on whether I should risk turning this. The sample is laid out on a Maple cutting board I am working on. It looks similar to it. I'll post a couple of PICS.

Questions:

1) What kind of wood does this look like to all of you?

2) Should I turn it?

Thank you,

Ray


img

Re: Wood ID / Confirmation?

#2

Re: Wood ID / Confirmation? #2

Ray Carson - Lawrenceville, NJ

>I accidently posted this thread over on the flat side so disregard if your seeing this for the second time.

Sorry,

Ray


img

Re: Wood ID / Confirmation?

#3

Re: Wood ID / Confirmation? # 3 

Ray Carson - Lawrenceville, NJ

>


img

Re: Wood ID / Confirmation?

#4

Keith Tompkins

Re: Wood ID / Confirmation? #2

keith tompkins

>Ray It does appear to be red (swamp) maple, but with those cracks, I'd use it for firewood, and look for sound material to turn.

Re: Wood ID / Confirmation?

#5

Steven Antonucci

One possible chance to save it...

steve antonucci

>Agree with Keith, but before you burn it, try this:

Chainsaw the end off 1" at a time until the cracking is gone from each end. You may just end up with a usable, but smaller piece of wood.

If not, you won't need to split it :-)

Steven

Re: Wood ID / Confirmation?

#6

After shaping a blank,

Allen Neighbors

>I'd put it on the lathe, and slather on a coat of Lacquer Wash. Then I'd superglue the cracks, let it sit for a half hour or so, then turn it. After getting it on the lathe, I'd make the decision to turn or burn.

Re: Wood ID / Confirmation?

#7

Re: Wood ID / Confirmation?

John K Jordan

>I would do as Steve mentioned and cut into it to see how deep the cracks go. However, after the first slice off the end, if cracks still remain I might put it on the bandsaw and cut lengthwise into smaller pieces, then slice thin sections off the ends of these until clear wood is reached. You didn't mention the kinds of things you turn, but I've salvaged some great smaller turning squares from wood others may have split for firewood.

If you really want to know what kind of wood it is, cut a small piece, shave the end grain with a razor blade, and look at it with a magnifier. Knowing whether it is ring porous or diffuse porous and the nature and distribution of the pores and rays can eliminate a bunch of wild guessing.

JKJ

Re: Wood ID / Confirmation?

#8

jim miles

Re: Wood ID / Confirmation?

Jim Miles

>Turn it! All you lose is a piece of firewood and a little time doing something you hopefully enjoy. Yes, cut the ends. Some of my best turnings are wood that most folks would say it would'nt even make good firewood! You don't know until you get into it, and you can always stop and trash it.


img

Re: Wood ID / Confirmation?

#9

Re: One possible chance - Thanks everyone.

Ray Carson - Lawrenceville, NJ

>I got similar advice over on the flat side. Some thought it might be Butternut. I've already considered investigative cutting and trimming to get a possible blank. Maybe even a mini bowl or something.

My intent was a flared top bowl. I've already halved the log lengthwise and it appears to be okay in spots. I'm an amateur turner and have been turning scraps just to get my skills back. This was the first attempt at a "project." I turned a little (12" lg.) Red Oak baseball bat for my son which he thinks is the "bomb" but I don't consider that a big deal. I was going to give a hollow turning a go but I'm not comfortable with skill level yet. I also don't have any hollowing tools.

Anyway.......thanks again to everyone who responded. I let you all know how I make out. :-)

Ray