Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

production wooturning

Posts

production wooturning

#1

production wooturning

clay rose

>can a woodturner make items such as stair spindles,ballusters, or other architectural kinds of work faster than a cnc machine like the legacy?

Re: production wooturning

#2

Keith Tompkins

Re: production wooturning

keith tompkins

>HI Clay, I don't know about the legacy, I'm not familiar with that, but there is no way possible for a turner to compete with industrial CNC equipment. Not even open for discussion. Years back, I worked for a chair factory that turned out 300 chairs daily, every day, and that was before the advent of CNC equipment.The equipment I used then is completely obsolete now, a dinosaur.

Re: production wooturning

#3

Re: production wooturning

john lucas

>Than a CNC nope. Faster than a legacy, it depends. If there are shapes that require the changing of bits on the legacy then I think a true production turner can. I've seen a guy turn a table leg that almost didn't need sanding in 23 minutes and he claimed he was slower than the production turners he teaches. However if you want spirals and such the Legacy would be faster.

I tried using a router in combination with my spindle gouge and skew to turn a mirror handle in 5 minutes. I didn't like the noise so I quit doing that and turn them in 15 minutes but with more variation so no 2 are exactly alike. I would assume a CNC could turn one in a minute or less.

Re: production wooturning

#4

Keith Tompkins

Re: production wooturning

keith tompkins

>HI John, An industrial CNC machine will cut to length, form the tenon, turn to shape, and drill any necessary holes in a matter of seconds. Once programmed, the operator only has to keep the hopper full. The way a hand turner competes is by having the ability to do small production runs, and to turn custom work that has sharp, clean detail not possible with automated equipment.

Re: production wooturning

#5

Re: production wooturning

Greg Haugen

>I agree with the others, CNC's this day and age are so advanced-there's no way. The legacy? In my opinion, yes, a turner can compete. With that system your changing bits, etc. A legacy machine, I don't think, is as much as a "duplicator" as an "ornamental" spindle machine. There are very few ways to "flute" or "spiral" a spindle consistantly, a legacy does that. There is one area that the other two systems have an issue in that a "turner" can create "more interest" to their work and that's in the details. For example, beads that are under cut-similar to a "captive ring" that's attached. It creates another line or shadow line to the element. Machines would have a hard time with that. I've also seen a porch railing's spiindles where the turner moved one element, like a bead, ever so slightly from one spindle to the next. When it was all put together the "element" moved up and down, like a wave, when your eye scanned from left to right. Very interesting effect and that would take a lot of programming for a machine to do, evey spindle is somewhat the same, but yet it's different. Also by doing "custom" jobs, or restoration jobs, we do win. The programming would be insane for those small "custom" jobs.

"Man" has tried to compete with the machine. By quantity numbers we lose. But we can compete in "customization" and "quality".

Greg H.

Re: production wooturning

#6

Re: production wooturning

Dick Coers

>Maybe some here don't know that Legacy now has both a cnc conversion on their "regular" machine, plus a mega cnc version. The big thing about any milling machine like this, that uses a router bit, the surface finish is never good. That's the reason I got rid of mine, just too much sanding. If there was any savings by using the legacy over hand turning, you would loose the time savings on additional sanding time. Setup time for accurate sizing on the Legacy is not really fast either.

A good cnc lathe will be using a v shaped shear cutting knife. They will leave a cut that will compare to hand turning.

Really want speed? A back knife lathe is really want you want. A few seconds to complete the part, with a cut that is just like a skew cut, even on beads and coves.