Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Suggestions for grinding wheels for turning tools

Posts

Suggestions for grinding wheels for turning tools

#1

Suggestions for grinding wheels for turning tools

Michael Stadulis in Southern NJ------WebKitFormBou

>Hello,

I have an 8" slow speed grinder and want to upgrade my wheels to Norton 3X. I'm thinking of a 46 and 80....but I'm wondering if I should go to a 46 and 100 grit wheel. Any suggestions for me and reasoning would be really appreciated.

Best,

Mike

Re: Suggestions for grinding wheels for turning tools

#2

Just my 2 cents....and a little rant

Greg Haugen

>Michael,

If you want to go with 3X, I'd stay with the "K" grade and I've only seen 46 and 80. I've seen 100 and 120 in "I" grade but it's really soft and requires alot of dressing shortening it's life. If you've found a "k" wheel in something other than 80 and 46 please let us know.

Sharpening is really personal preference there is no right or wrong. If you have a club near you I'd recommend finding someone with those wheels and others and ask for a "turning night". Sharpen your tools on that wheels and cut with them. Like or not?? Also use the search funtion at the bottom and "search" the archives for grinding wheel posts. You'll come up with a lot of information.

I have to rant about something that is often over looked!! Dressing and "sharpening" pressure.

I currently have a 120 White AO wheel I use for sharpening. Some think it's too fine and that it burns tools. It doesn't when the sharpening is done properly. That's what I like, it's not the only way.

Another point to make about sharpening that is often over looked. Everyone gets caught up in the grit of a wheel or the color. But they forget how to sharpen!!! They're apply way too much pressure to the tool while grinding resulting in excessive heat and a shorter tool. Also "dressing" the wheel. Too much pressure and you can create, or screw up a wheel's surface, a "bounce". When the tool "kisses" the wheel it should bounce or vibrate. Grinding is a light touch, kissing the wheel. It should be looked at as "touching up the tool instead of GRINDING the tool. The best wheel you can buy, won't help if it's not properly dressed and a light touch is used to grind.

I was recently at a friend's house that has issues with grinding. "I" dressed his wheel and sharpened a tool. It was as smooth as a baby's butt!! The tool "kissed" the wheel, no bounce-just smooth. I apply no force down on the tool, I hold enough to keep it from falling. I'm talking about sharpening, not shaping here. He dresses it and grinds a tool, it's burned (which doesn't matter with HSS but it's not good practice) and it sounds like a bad rhythm from tribal drums or something. The wheels weren't not "high end" wheels. They are $20 white wheels from www.sharpeningsupplies.com. No "balancing" system or anything else. Properly dressed wheels with a light touch is the key. I have had a student push so hard trying to dress a wheel he tipped the grinder over!! Pressure and force is not your friend in gtrinding. No matter what the wheel is!!!

Turning is an artform, however "sharpening" is an artform also.

Just my 2 cents.

Greg H.

Re: Suggestions for grinding wheels for turning tools

#3

Good Rant

Allen Neighbors

>Glad you ranted, Greg. I just learned something else. Thanks for the info.

Re: Suggestions for grinding wheels for turning tools

#4

I wish everyone would read Greg's post.

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>Greg, this post covers so much of the basics... thank you. Grinding can be done with a gray wheel but the new wheels grind cooler.

Re: Suggestions for grinding wheels for turning tools

#5

Amen

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>You hit the nail on the head Greg.

Grinding is an art.

I'd add that sanding is an art.

And many are too impatient to spent the time to learn those important skills.

Re: Suggestions for grinding wheels for turning tools

#6

Re: Suggestions for grinding wheels for turning to

Dave Anderson (PacNW)

>The Norton Grinding wheels are on sale for 25% off at Hartville tools. Spend $75.00 and free shiping. Go with the 46 and 80 grit "K" Bond. Do yourself a favor and buy the ONEWAY grinding wheel balance Kit. It greatly improves the smoothness of the grinder.

Dave Anderson (PacNW)

Re: Suggestions for grinding wheels for turning tools

#7

Correction

Greg Haugen

>"When the tool "kisses" the wheel it should NOT bounce or vibrate."

Sorry, I missed the "not" in the first post.

Greg

Re: Suggestions for grinding wheels for turning tools

#8

Re: Amen

Greg Haugen

>Absolutely!!

So many DVD's and books are made to spend so much time on the turning but forgets the "techniques" of grinding and sanding.

Greg H.

Re: Suggestions for grinding wheels for turning tools

#9

Steven Antonucci

Cutting cleanly in the first place is an art!

steve antonucci

>Sanding is a pain. :-)

Steve

Re: Suggestions for grinding wheels for turning tools

#10

why not go all the way

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>the 3X wheel is a consumer version of the ceramic or seeded grain wheels that several companies are now selling. These wheels have been available from metal working supply houses for some time. If you feel you need the benefit of the SG wheels, which is longer life, why not buy the commercial version that has a much higher content of the SG material, rather than the dilute consumer version?

If you are not wearing out wheels at an unacceptable rate the SG wheels make little economic sense.

Re: Suggestions for grinding wheels for turning tools

#11

320 grit AO

Nick

>I just bought a 320 grit AO wheel and I'm very happy with it. And no, it does not burn.

Re: Suggestions for grinding wheels for turning tools

#12

We knew what you meant Greg :)

Dave Peebles Lyons, Ohio!

>Good post!!

Dave

Re: Suggestions for grinding wheels for turning tools

#13

Keith Tompkins

Re: Just my 2 cents....and a little rant

keith tompkins

>Good post Greg, but if you mentioned the use of high-speed grinders it would be perfect! :) Yes, I use a high-speed grinder.

Re: Suggestions for grinding wheels for turning tools

#14

Re: Just my 2 cents....and a little rant

Greg Haugen

>:-) Yep, high speed grinders work too. If someone learns how to grind, all of these details that we get so stuck on would be "mute" points. I prefer a slow speed, but I've used high speeds while traveling and demoing. It's all personal preference.

Thanks for mentioning that.

Greg H.

Re: Suggestions for grinding wheels for turning tools

#15

a case for slow speed grinders

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>First, let me agree so the experts don't lynch me, that wheels are designed to run at 3600 rpm, they cut best at this speed because of this fact, and with proper wheel selection and technique burning is not a problem. I sharpen even thin Stanley plane irons on a grinder and grind right to the edge without burning. (Let me reemphasize the light touch explained above. I am gripping the tool like I am carrying a thistle stem).

However, metal goes away quicker at 3600 rpm than less rpm. When I was learning I found that slower speed enabled me to learn tool control. I had a 3 phase grinder and ran it off a variable frequency drive so that I could dial in any speed I wanted. I learned the motions at very low speed. But now I find that I crank the grinder to 3600 rpm and have at it, including plane irons and chisels.

A point not necessarily known, the slower the speed, the coarser the scratches for a given grit, and it is not a subtle effect.

Ideally, we should have a slow speed grinder to rent and when the renter learned to grind he/she could pass it along to the next student and replace it with a conventional grinder.

Re: Suggestions for grinding wheels for turning tools

#16

Re:Nick-don't you mean a 120 grit wheel?

Jamie Donaldson

>

Re: Suggestions for grinding wheels for turning tools

#17

Re: a case for slow speed grinders

Michael Stadulis in Southern NJ------WebKitFormBou

>"A point not necessarily known, the slower the speed, the coarser the scratches for a given grit, and it is not a subtle effect....."

Exactly why I mentioned that I had a slow speed. I am leaning to the finer grits for that reason. Same goes for shaper/router sppeds. Speed or cuts/inch equal smoothness.

Mike

Re: Suggestions for grinding wheels for turning tools

#18

Re:Nick-don't you mean a 120 grit wheel?

Nick

>No. I have 320 grit wheel-got it from Grizzly on sale $23.