Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Lathe motors -

Posts

Lathe motors -

#1

Lathe motors -

wilbur

>I'm planning on replacing the motor that's on my lathe with a VFD/3 phase motor setup to give me variable speed and lower RPM capability. In looking around, it seems that all lathes that are commonly available with 1725 RPM motors. I know that there are motors that run at 1140 RPM. Why not use one of those? It seems to me that, say, a 2 HP motor that runs at 1725 RPM will lose more torque as you drop the RPMs than a 2 HP motor that runs at 1140 RPM that drops to the same speed.

Re: Lathe motors -

#2

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Lathe motors -

Jesper, Denmark

>Since you will step-up the spindle speed to the same spindle rpm on both motors, the low torque will be the same. The Nominal 1725rpm 4 pole motor is smaller and more common and less expensive than the more unusual 8 pole 1175 rpm.

Re: Lathe motors -

#3

Re: Lathe motors -

wilbur

>My understanding is that torque generated by a motor is related to the horsepower of the motor and its RPMs : T = HP x 5252 / RPM.

Which implies that a 2 HP 1140 RPM motor generates more torque (9.2 lb-ft) than a 2 HP 1725 RPM motor (6.1 lb-ft), unless I am missing something here.

Re: Lathe motors -

#4

Re: Lathe motors -

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>If you use a set of pulleys to drop reduce the rpm of the 1725 motor to 1140 rpm, the two motors will have the same torque at that speed (ignoring transmission losses).

Usually the motors are connected to the spindle through stepped pulleys. If you adjust the pulleys to give the same nominal spindle rpm, the torque from each motor will be the same.

Re: Lathe motors -

#5

p.s.

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>If you use the same pulley set for each motor, then the 1140 motor will have better low end torque, but at the sacrifice of high end speed. (i.e. top end spindle speed will be 2/3 of the 1725 motor.)

Re: Lathe motors -

#6

Re: Lathe motors -

Curly Smith

>The short answer is "yes". The long answer is "it's complicated".

As Jesper said, the 1200 RPM motor is more expensive and more massive than the 1800 RPM motor as these links illustrate:

Baldor 1800 RPM

Baldor 1200 RPM

The 1800 RPM motor is $327 and weighs 46 lbs while the 1200 RPM motor costs $510 and weighs 74 lbs. There are certainly applications where the more expensive motor is the best choice but a lathe may, or may not, be that case.

The lathes that deliver insufficient torque at low speeds are likely equipped with a "variable torque" VFD (or what used to be called "constant HP" VFD) when they probably should have used a "constant torque" VFD.

In general, a "variable torque" VFD has a speed ratio of 5:1, meaning that an 1800 RPM motor can be slowed to 360 RPM (a 1200 RPM to 240 RPM) and a "constant torque" VFD has a speed ratio of 2:1 so an 1800 RPM motor can be slowed to 900 RPM (a 1200 RPM to 600 RPM). The limiting factor in both is heat generation in the motor.

So, you should get the performance that you want with an 1800 RPM motor, a "constant torque" VFD, and, as others have mentioned, step pulleys to give the desired lathe speeds.

FYI - it's best to buy the motor and VFD from the same place unless you're certain that both will work (a) together and (b) in your specific application.