Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

blue or gold sandpaper?

Posts

blue or gold sandpaper?

#1

blue or gold sandpaper?

Carol - now back in Dubuque, IA

>I was looking at Vince's sandpaper and considering the starter kit.

Pro's & con's on the blue film or the gold paper disks?

And is the Harbor Freight close quarter drill worth $40?

Re: blue or gold sandpaper?

#2

Re: blue or gold sandpaper?

eliot d

>I don't have an opinion about the blue or gold, but I do about the HF close quarter drill. I own a Millwalkee and a cheap HF, for which I paid only 29.95. The Millwalkee, even used , was near $100. I can't tell the difference. I'm sure people will tell you that the cheap unit has plastic gears, etc. and will wear out right away, but I've had mine for over a year and it still is running great. A tip, though: always blow the drill out after each use.

Re: blue or gold sandpaper?

#3

Re: blue or gold sandpaper?

Donna Banfield

>Carol, whether you choose blue or gold, (I use blue, if it makes any difference), Vince sells good quality sandpaper. I was a former user of the Rhino grip (Industrial Abrasives) that you could purchase in 1 meter by 1 yard, and was spending a lot more time sanding than turning -- 3 times longer - and still finding sanding scratches, and needing to return to a lower grit, and start over again.

I had ordered some sanding arbors from Vince, and as a courtesy, he threw in some of his blue discs, even though I told him I had several sheets of the Rhino grip paper that I was still using. That was a shrewd marketing ploy on his part, because one afternoon after several hours of frustrating sanding, (power sanding with a corded drill, hand sanding on the lathe, running, and off the lathe) I saw his sample discs, slapped them on his micro hook arbors, and was finished sanding -- no backing up for missed scratches -- in about a half an hour. But the true test, in my opinion, was whether there were scratches that showed up after a coat of finish -- nope -- none.

After that experience, I called Vince and ordered several hundred discs from 80-1200 to fit both size mandrels. I never looked back, and now feel like I'm a woodturner again, and not a 'sander'.

As for the angle drill, I used to use the Sioux angle drill. I don't have very big hands, and found that those drills were heavy to hold after several finishing sessions. My Sioux drill eventually bit the dust, with no hope of reviving (bearing case completely melted even though I used compressed air regularly -- maybe the rhino grip paper???? and all that repeated sanding???). I replaced that drill with 2 re-conditioned black & decker corded drills at less than $15.00 each. They weigh less, and the handle/grip fits much better in my hand, than the angle drills. I don't experienece the same cramping and fatigue that I would have at the end of a day using the Sioux angle drill.

I use both black & decker drills -- one with a 2" arbor, and the other with a 3" arbor, and they've been going for about 1.5 years now. When they eventually give up the ghost, I will replace them with similar corded drills. I consider them a consumable now, just like a turning tool that will eventually be sharpened down to nothing left to sharpen, and be replaced with a new one.

In all fairness, I should add that I got the suggestion to use Rhino grip 1 meter by 1 yard sandpaper from another woodcentralite, and it may work just fine for some people. But I had problems trying to power sand with it, and when switching to Vince's sandpaper, the problems that I had disappeared. I am still using the Rhino grip paper (I have a lot left), but I'm using it in different applications. But once that's used up, I will be ordering some of Vince's sponge-backed sandpaper for those sanding projects.

Yup, shrewd business person that he is, ;^) he threw some of that in with my sandpaper order, and yes, they worked quite well, in the application -- hand-sanding some carved spoons, and other kitchen utensils. He won my business.

Re: blue or gold sandpaper?

#4

Re: blue or gold sandpaper?

Carol - now back in Dubuque, IA

>Thanks, Donna.

Any particular reason you use the blue?

Re: blue or gold sandpaper?

#5

Re: There can be not doubt that ........

Jamie Donaldson

>... I am a serious tool and sanding guy, and after using Sioux drills for years(1 worn out, 2 still in use)I bought one of the knockoff models last year. The instant you turn it on you can hear that quality, especially bearings, is not the same. I have used it mixed in with tasks assigned to the other 2, and it is still running, but I hesitate to guess for how long. As for the sanding discs, I hate to waste time sanding, but I am a fanatic about my finishing. After trying Vinces's blue stuff I placed a significant order for the complete selection for my work. It cuts consistantly well, works faster, lasts longer, and the results speak to the quality of the product, and I'm known to be a phrugal guy. I seldom try to cut costs that will result in more time and trouble to complete a task, and sanding is work that must be accomplished well. Go blue!

Re: blue or gold sandpaper?

#6

Re: blue or gold sandpaper?

Texian

>Carol,

Item 3, if it is the orange one, is on sale from time to time for 24 or even 20. Used the first one for a year or two and the bearings are getting a bit sloppy. Have a second one ($20) on hand as backup. Mostly use a straight drill now. Seem to have several, mostly inherited as I can not recall having bought one. For ref. am not a pro. Usually turn 4-5 days a week but am slow, so not many items a week get sanded.

Re: blue or gold sandpaper?

#7

Bill Blasic

Re: blue or gold sandpaper?

Bill Blasic

>Carol,

I have been getting my sanding supplies from Steve Worcester at http://www.turningwood.com/

These are the best sanding disks that I have found. Just another option.

Re: blue or gold sandpaper?

#8

Re: Close Quarters Drill

Jeff Rich

>Hi Carol,

I have one of the HF drills and it works great for me.

HF tends to have sales ALL the time so watch the papers and you may find that item for $25.

The close quarters drill is variable speed and reversible.

Now that I have said that....I have also found that sometimes you really do get what you pay for....as in a hammer drill with bearings that went bad. I do have 2 of their swivel head lathes as well, they are my "beater" lathes.

Re: blue or gold sandpaper?

#9

Re: Close Quarters Drill

Norm Smith

>Carol, I go for the cheap drill. I have two with different size sanding pads on them so I dont have to stop and change sizes. I buy them (the same drill) at a large Canadian retailer. They work great and I use them almost daily.

They have a 2 year warranty, so if it fails in that time I return it for a new one,( I have returned 2 over the past few years) otherwise I would throw it away and buy another.

Good luck,

Norm

Re: blue or gold sandpaper?

#10

Re: blue or gold sandpaper?

Cyril Griesbach

>Carol, I switched to Vince's blue discs a few years ago and never looked back. Call him up, talk to him about sanding, he's a really nice guy.

Re: blue or gold sandpaper?

#11

Re: blue or gold sandpaper?

Donna Banfield

>I used and ordered the blue discs because those were the samples Vince threw in the box. I was impressed with the sanding and the finish I got from them, far superior to the Rhino grip sandpaper I was using before.

Re: blue or gold sandpaper?

#12

Re: blue or gold sandpaper?

Jerry Klug

>Is the "blue" sanding material aluminia-zirconia like I use on my 6x48 belt sander. That has proved to work well and outlast generic sanding belts by a power of 10. I thought there was a comparison on sanding materials back a month or so but I can't find it. Who is "Vince" and how do I contact him for sanding material. While discussing sanding, how about some direction on the mandrels for discs. The disc mandrel at my local Acce Hardware (very small town) is a flexible but stiff plastic. I have heard that some turners use a soft faced mandrel and possible have the diameter trimmed to leave the outer 1/4 inch or so of the sand paper disc unsupported. As finishing is a new experience for me, any suggestions will send me to the shop to experiment.

Re: blue or gold sandpaper?

#13

Re: blue or gold sandpaper?

robo hippy

>Another vote for Vince (VincesWoodNWonders.com). I have tried everything out there except for the purple ceramic discs from 3M that Mike Mahoney ("I go through about $200 of abrasive material a month") uses. I tried the red aluminum oxide, the gold, the Abranet, the green ceramic discs, the Astra Dot, and the Mirka discs from Steve Worchester. The Blue discs outlast everytinge else, except the ceramic discs about 2 to 1, and the ceramic is at least twice the cost of the Vince's discs. The blue discs, as well as some of the other ones out there are on plastic film, not paper, and this is much more durable than the paper discs. Vinces discs are also cut over size, 3 3/8, and 2 3/8 inches. Vince also sells sheet stock now if you punch your own discs. I may have to try the 3M discs. They are all psa (sticky back) discs. The down side is that I would want a pad for each grit. If you take one sticky disc off, it never seems to stick back on, but this wasn't a problem with most of them because they wore out so quickly. I would like to have some of it for hand sanding. Do keep your eraser sticks handy. Vince said that he blows his off first. I prefer the stick because it doesn't spread the dust as far.

As far as the angle drills, I have 4 of the Sioux/Milwaukee type. I prefer the slow speed models. The last drill lasted through over 400 bowls before the bearings went out. I use the 3 inch discs almost exclusively. I had one of the clone type of drills, and it didn't last even a month before the case wore out, not the bearings. Not sure how many bowls I sanded with it, but I didn't get another one. The last drill lasted longer than others (usually about 300 bowls), probably because of a hint that Vince told me: turn the speed down, 600 rpm max. As a production turner, I was a bit dubious because of the time factor, but I tried it. I put a 1/4 inch piece of cork under the trigger and sanded. It is still that way. You don't generate as much heat, and the disc won't bounce as much, so you get a better job. There is no more time involved, and perhaps it is a bit faster. Also, I use a firm disc for grits up to about 220, then switch to the softer pads for the finer grits. I am very good about blowing out the sander, even several times a day if I am sanding for hours. I did get some fancy bearings (double sealed) and they don't seem to last any longer than the factory ones, but that is some thing I am still testing. I also sand with the lathe on slow (10 rpm or so) speed. I turn green to final thickness, and then let them dry and warp. Can't sand these bowls at anything higher than about 20 rpm. The variable speed lathes shut off at about 50 rpm. My old PM3520A model would go down to almost zero before shutting off, and the B models shut off at 50. My Robust would shut off at 50 as well. I called Brent English and talked to him, and he walked me through how set the machine down to the lower shut off speed. Most turners don't need that low of a speed, but you can probably get them adjusted if you want. I did try a pneumatic sander, and don't like it as well. The air hose is more in the way than the electrical wire, and it would keep the compressor running full time. This wasn't too bad in the winter to add a little heat to the shop, but not in the summer. Also, it is cheaper to run the electric drill than the compressor. I do keep both hands on the drill when using it. This doesn't fatigue me as much as one handed holding. Some times I will hold with one hand and turn the bowl by hand.

robo hippy

Re: blue or gold sandpaper?

#14

Re: blue or gold sandpaper? *LINK*

Cyril Griesbach

>Jerry, here is the link to Vince's web site. Lots of sanding info on the site and you can call him with your questions. He's a nice guy.


http://www.vinceswoodnwonders.com/

Re: blue or gold sandpaper?

#15

Re: blue or gold sandpaper?

keith zimmerman, Normal IL

>Carole, I also use Vince's blue disks on a Sioux clone angle drill and wouldn't use any other disk for power sanding. I also use his 1" wide strips for small turnings like pens and bottlestoppers. I bought one of his sample kits at Indyfest one year, along with several of the strips. I had tried a lot of different types and I feel his are the best of them.

The drill has been in use for over 1 1/2 years with no problem.

keithz

Re: blue or gold sandpaper?

#16

Dick Hines

Re: blue or gold sandpaper?

Dick Hines

>You can't go wrong with the blue disc. I have been useing then for a couple of years and love them. I don't think he is selling the blue in sheets. If he does I will move over from 3X which is great paperbut not as good as the blue disc.

As far as the close quarter drill. I bought one a couple of years ago for $40. It is not as quite as the high end ones but it will work until I can get a cheap air sander.

Re: blue or gold sandpaper?

#17

Neither blue nor gold

bill Crommett

>I find the fastest and cheapest stuff is the Klingspoors rolls of hook and loop. I just cut off a square and the corners act like the deckle edges of the expensive stuff. One problem is that it only goes up to 600 grit.

Re: blue or gold sandpaper?

#18

Re: Neither blue nor gold

robo hippy

>Bill,

Been there, done that. The sanding discs from Vince are far better, and the price is worth it, you get far more for your money.

robo hippy