Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

OT - Ping Mr. Sfirri

Posts

OT - Ping Mr. Sfirri

#1

OT - Ping Mr. Sfirri

charlie belden

>Apologies for this non-turning post, but I seem to recall that Mr. Sfirri participates in this forum and I hope to reach him here.

Sir:

Your article on the Esherick Corner Desk in the August 2008 issue of Woodwork magazine has had my head spinning (turning reference?) since I read it - the first time. I've since gone through it another 10 times, and studied the accompanying photos 30 or more times. Like you, this piece absolutely fascinates me. And I totally agree that this desk begs to be played with - flipping things open, slipping out very oddly shaped drawers, sliding a panel back, ...

So - I've spent hours sketching how I think some things work, more hours doing simple 2-D drawings of what I think might be "front", "top" and "side views" in order to attempt to visualize the 3-D piece - and even more hours trying to do a SketchUp 3D model of the desk - which allows parts to be moved as they would on the actual piece.

Because almost nothing in this piece is rectangular - everything seems to be trapezoidal, and lacking any dimensions in your article, I'm having a hell of a time trying to visualize, let alone make virtual models of the external surfaces of the piece, let alone the details inside - or the methods used for moving parts.

If I had the dimensions of the top view and

the footprint I think I can work out the rest close enough to do a representative 3D model in SketchUp - with drawers that can be pulled out and triangular panels that could fold out.

Help! This piece is driving me crazy (and must've challenged Schmidt's knowledge, skills and abilities).

charlie belden


img

Re: OT - Ping Mr. Sfirri

#2

Did you mean the main board

john lucas

>I don't remember seeing Mark post on the turning side. I love his work and probably would remember. I also love the Esherick desk. Fascinating piece of work. I'd love to see it in person. I wish I had the time to build something like that. Assuming of course that I had the skills.

Re: OT - Ping Mr. Sfirri

#3

Re: Did you mean the main board

charlie belden

>John Lucas wrote:

I don't remember seeing Mark post on the turning side. I love his work and probably would remember. I also love the Esherick desk. Fascinating piece of work. I'd love to see it in person. I wish I had the time to build something like that. Assuming of course that I had the skills.

=============================

Perhaps I saw some of his posts in one of the KNOTS forums that Tauton Press has.

The Corner Desk certainly is fascinating - visually deceptive - and probably a hell of a lot of fun to explore.

As for building one - Esherick had only been into furniture making for about 6 years when he came up with the concepts for this piece. Being basically self taught, I doubt he actually made much of the piece himself. Fortunately he had John Schmidt - with all his knowledge, skills and abilities to make the idea a reality.

Since this thing is made up of so many trapezoidal and triangular parts, with compound angles everywhere, trying to do conventional drawings - top, front, side - wouldn't get you even close to the information required to make the parts. Which is why I'm trying to do a 3D model in SketchUp.

Once I've got the outlines of the desk I can start filling in the parts. And once I got the parts I can figure out how to allow them to move. And THEN I can start trying to figure out how to hold all the parts together.

But first I need some outlines dimensions . . .

Posted early attempts at line drawings to the general "messages" forum if you want to see my first passes at the Esherick Corner Desk.

If you've got any images of this thing, which weren't in Mark's article in Woodwork, I'd sure like to see them.

charlie belden

Re: OT - Ping Mr. Sfirri

#4

Ellis Walentine

Message sent to Mark

Ellis Walentine

>Let's see if he weighs in.

Cheers,

Ellis