Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Sycamore vs Sweet Gum?

Posts

Sycamore vs Sweet Gum?

#1

Sycamore vs Sweet Gum?

Allen Neighbors

>After reading John's post concerning Sweet (red) Gum, I cut into some wood that a friend gave me. And another, mystery log, that I got from the land fill.

The tree from my friend was a tall tree, that had those little spiney balls hanging all over it, and bark that made me think it was a Sycamore.

The tree from the land fill made me think of Sweet Gum. It did have a few streaks of pink as John has described in his post.

I roughed out two bowls from each yesterday, and now I can't tell the difference between them.

I don't see the little rays that you normally see in Sycamore.

My Questions follow:

Is it normal for a novice to mistake Sweet Gum for Sycamore? and vice versa?

Does Sweet Gum have those little spiney balls growing on it?

Thanks,

Re: Sycamore vs Sweet Gum?

#2

Re: Sycamore vs Sweet Gum?

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>Sweet Gum and Sycamore do not look much alike at least the Sycamore and Sweet Gum I am familiar with. Those little foot torturing balls are gum balls from a Sweet Gum Tree.

Re: Sycamore vs Sweet Gum?

#3

Thanks, Barbara,

Allen Neighbors

>that's what I was afraid of. Doesn't Sycamore have thos little balls also? I like your description of them as foot torturing balls... you surely know it when you step on one in the grass while barefoot. :)

Re: Sycamore vs Sweet Gum?

#4

Re: Sycamore vs Sweet Gum?

John K Jordan

>Sweetgum and Sycamore have quite different fruit. (photos below) The bark is much different as well - sycamore bark is very distinctive with mottled "camouflauge" bark that is often peeling - sweetgum is indicated as having deep irregular furrows and ridges. Sweetgum has a fivepointed star leaf; sycamore looks like a maple leaf. According to my references the rays in sycamore are distinctive on a radial section while those in sweetgum are nearly invisible.

Note there is another tree commonly known as sycamore: the sycamore maple, acer pseudoplatanus (false plane tree) that has a winged seed like a maple and is sometimes called sycamore plane or plane tree. The common sycamore tree (with the fruit ball) is platanus occidentalis, also called american plane tree, buttonball, buttonwood, water beech.

As for sweetgum, I found this in one of my books: "few North American woods equal sweetgum in the beauty of its grain." After working a bit with what I cut yesterday, I can believe it.

JKJ


img

Re: Sycamore vs Sweet Gum?

#5

Re: Thanks, Barbara,

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>Yes Sycamore does have balls that are filled with seeds that float away. They do not have the spines that gum balls do.

Re: Sycamore vs Sweet Gum?

#6

Re: Sycamore vs Sweet Gum?

Carole Valentine

>I never have been able to dry the stuff (Sweet Gum) without it cracking. What's the secret? Turn it super thin and let it warp?

Re: Sycamore vs Sweet Gum?

#7

Keith Tompkins

Re: Sycamore vs Sweet Gum?

keith tompkins

>Hi Allen, Sycamore has distinct grain with huge flecks in quartersawn wood. The leaves look like huge maple leaves. Sweet gum leaves resemble a 5-point star.

Re: Sycamore vs Sweet Gum?

#8

The secret is how you dry it, and

Allen Neighbors

>what you do before you dry it, Carole. I've always soaked sweet gum in soap solution for a minimum of one month. Then I wrap it up in as many paper bags as I can get around it, and put it on the shelf for a couple of months. Then I take it out of the bags, and let it continue to dry alone or in one of my old refrigerator kilns for another month or two. Mine warp a lot, but hardly ever crack if I take these pains with it.

I've quit using the soap solution now (too expensive), and have gone to plain water soak for a month, changing the water every week. I'll keep some notes and see how it does.

Re: Sycamore vs Sweet Gum?

#9

Thanks, everyone.

Allen Neighbors

>I really appreciate the answers. Seems like I really got my trees mixed up. I know it's sweet gum, now; thanks to John's pictures.

Thanks again.

Re: Sycamore vs Sweet Gum?

#10

Re: The secret is how you dry it, and

Carole Valentine

>Well I sure don't do all that! LOL As I recall, I sealed blanks (disaster), rough turned and sealed (still cracked) and rough turned and DNA soaked then put in paper sac to dry. (Still cracked) All this was with no pith whatsoever. It's got to be some really spectacular wood for me to go through more than that!