Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Bowl gouge

Posts

Bowl gouge

#1

Bowl gouge

pat28

>I started spinning wood about a year ago and definitely got addicted to it (I now spend a minimum of 2 hours per day in the garage!). I first bought a small tool kit as I was advised to buy tools gradually to get better quality and to choose the ones that would be specifically adapted to the kind of work I was doing. I am now ready to purchase a first bowl gouge. What size should I first buy? I sincerely appreciate the input of more experienced turners! Thanks!

Pat

Re: Bowl gouge

#2

Re: Bowl gouge

john lucas

>Since I just did a survey of people to find out what bowl gouge to buy I can give you my suggestions. The most common answer was 1/2" American or 3/8" British gouge. We measure by the shaft size the British measure by the flute size so for all practical purposes these are the same size gouges.

It was split fairly evenly between V and U shaped flutes with some suggesting the Superflute which is kind of inbetween.

the Grind most common was a sort of Ellsworth grind. I say sort of because the ones I had photos of all roughly resembled the grind you get using the Ellsworth or Wolverine jig.

I have an article coming out in American Woodturner that shows 3 different grinds to give you some frame of reference. I don't have photos of those because they turned them into drawings which made them easier to understand.

You can go to the grinds library here on Woodcentral to get an idea of what grinds people use.

Re: Bowl gouge

#3

Re: Bowl gouge

robo hippy

>For size, it depends on what feels best in your hands. I have always liked bigger and heavier tools. They just fit me better than the little dainty ones. I can do the same cuts as well. A 1/2 inch will do well for smaller bowls up to 12 inches or so. If you are going to do a lot of bigger sized ones, then a 5/8 gouge would be better. I, and many others will recomend the gouges that Doug Thompson makes. The best steel out there for wear and tear, and a really good price. You do have to make your own handle, which I consider a plus.

robo hippy

Re: Bowl gouge

#4

Re: Bowl gouge

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>When I'm teaching beginning bowl turning classes, students almost always ask me what tools to buy. I let them try the 3/8 bowl gouge and the 1/2 inch gouge (UK sizes...actual size 1/2 in. and 5/8 in). A high percentage of the time they choose the larger gouge.

Wally

Re: Bowl gouge

#5

Re: Bowl gouge

pat28

>Thanks guys for the quick responses. I guess it is the same as for skew chisels. The heavier the tool, the greater the stability. I will be going for either a 1/2 in. or else a 5/8 in. and will let you know how things are going with the prototypes... Thanks again for your help!

Pat

Re: Bowl gouge

#6

ebd

Re: Bowl gouge

ebd

>It is far easier to tap a finishing nail home with a hammer that is too heavy than it is to drive a 10 penny nail with a tack hammer.

Re: Bowl gouge

#7

Re: Bowl gouge

BobM

>I would go with the Thompson V shaped 1/2" gouge. I have several of his tools and have been very pleased with them. In my opinion they are much better than the high speed steel ones I had previously.

Re: Bowl gouge

#8

Re: Bowl gouge

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>A lot depends on the diameter of bowls you plan to turn, something smaller say in the 10 inch range can be done with a 1/2 diameter gouge, larger bowls need a larger diameter tool. A 1/2 or a 5/8 inch diameter gouge are your choices and either will turn a bowl from start to finish.

Re: Bowl gouge

#9

Re: Bowl gouge

Dave Peebles Lyons, Ohio!

>Hi Pat,

I think it depends on what lathe you are turning on. If you have a mini the 1/2" will do just fine. But if you like to turn bigger pieces on a bigger lathe, I would go with the 5/8" size.

But rest assured, you will probably end up with both... and many more.

I am also a fan of the Thompson tools, great price and a great tool, no matter what size you choose.

Best wishes,

Dave

Re: Bowl gouge

#10

Re: Bowl gouge

john lucas

>I find it interesting that everyone seems to use a 5/8" gouge on big bowls. I've turned up to 19" using my 1/2" gouge. If your tool rest is close enough you don't need a big tool. I have a 5/8 and 1" but I only use those for roughing really out of round bowls. that's because I do end up with more tool over the tool rest on these pieces. Once I get them round I go back to the 1/2". I prefer the balance of the 1/2" tool.

Re: Bowl gouge

#11

Thompson

John K Jordan

>I turned my first bowl today in many months - I used the 1/2" and 5/8" Thompson gouges in Monster handles. Wow! You were right - these are fantastic tools. Sharpened on the Tormek it felt like I was cutting cedar instead of hard maple. I'm going to call Monday and order some more so I can have different grinds.

I guess I'll make garden tools out of all my sorby and crown bowl gouges and use the Elsworth signature gouge to stake out the goat.

JKJ

Re: Bowl gouge

#12

Different strokes John

Dave Peebles Lyons, Ohio!

>John,

I guess I should have added that this is my opinion, and what I prefer to use.

Dave