Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Placement of sand in lathe stand

Posts

Placement of sand in lathe stand

#1

Placement of sand in lathe stand

wilbur

>I read somewhere (can't find it, natch) that if you are going to add weight to a lathe stand to add stability, it's better to put it closer to the center of rotation of the spinning object, which would mean that it's best to try to put bags of sand up higher in the lathe stand than down lower.

It makes sense to me that more mass concentrated toward the center of the object (out of balance blank + lathe + stand) would do more to stabilize things than adding the same amount of weight to the outside.

Is this true?

Re: Placement of sand in lathe stand

#2

JL

Re: Placement of sand in lathe stand

JL

>Interesting thought. It could be tested.

If you got a number of the magnetic weights like we use at the gym to attach to the equipment - you could stick them anywhere you want on the lathe. I know they come in various increments (up to 10 lbs). You could start down low at the legs and gradually move them up to the ways of the lathe.

My ballast box is set down low near the feet of my lathe. A lot of that is convenience - where else would I put a couple of hundred lbs of sand and gravel? If I had the portable magnetic weights, I could just stick them anywhere - and even move them around as necessary.

Re: Placement of sand in lathe stand

#3

Steven Antonucci

I believe this is true...

steve antonucci

>And of course, most lathes give you the option of putting it low. My Nova legs have two spots for 2x6's, and I chose the higher one, but not because of the vibration issues. With the box really low, it's impossible to sweep under!

Steven

Re: Placement of sand in lathe stand

#4

Re: Placement of sand in lathe stand

Keith Newton, LR, Arkansas------WebKitFormBoundary

>You may find that there would be some improvement higher up, but there will still likely be some or a lot of movement if something is bad out of balance, if the stand is too limber to allow flexing where the lathe is bolted to it.

If I wanted to turn one of these little open legged stands into the ultimate stand, I would use the legs as the outer corners of a solid poured concrete base.

All you would need to do, is form up to the outside of the legs, work in some re-bar, and pour it full of ready-mix concrete, then wait for it to cure.

When I built my big lathe, I started with a massive casting of a headstock, then welded up what I thought would be plenty strong, out of 1/2" and 1 1/2" thick steel, but it could still wiggle a little, as surely as a bell rings. I then took it back apart and poured concrete into the cavity, while throwing in big iron cast plugs to add more weight.

The concrete cube did the trick. After I was done, it dawned on me that I could have just formed up and poured a little pyramid cube with a flat top and bolts sticking up where the lathe sits much easier than what I constructed.

Re: Placement of sand in lathe stand

#5

Huh? :@)

wilbur

>What is this "sweeping" thing that you speak of? :@)

Re: Placement of sand in lathe stand

#6

Re:I always hate to hear that sand.....

Jamie Donaldson

>.....will be used around motors, bearings and other machine parts. Washed river gravel is a much better solution, and does not pose potential hazards to your equipment. Sand always has the ability to leak out and into everything, while gravel achieves the same purposes without the potential for disaster.

Re: Placement of sand in lathe stand

#7

Re:I always hate to hear that sand.....

john lucas

>I have had bags of pea gravel under my lathe now for a while and they are getting irriting. Hard to clean around. Yea I know I said that clean and sweep nasty word. The ultimate solution is adjustable weights on a bar on the headstock but then how many of us would stop and adjust them as the piece loses weight.

I remember seeing Stephen Hogbin's lathe that was a concrete sort of pyramid. The tailstock was the same thing but slid on rails. Now that's mass.

It seems to me that mass is more critical than placement but I'm certainly no engineer. Heck I can barely balance my checkbook much less do that kind of math. I suppose there is a point where high or low would make a difference but most of the vibration reduction would be just more weight. The same is true about Sand vs gravel. Sand supposedly absorbs more vibration but I know I will have to move my lathe someday and it's much easier to move bags of gravel without worrying about them busting open, than bags of sand. In that case I agree with Jamie. Of course if I lived anywhere near the coast I would probably have 600 bags of sand lying around ready to protect my house.

Re: Placement of sand in lathe stand

#8

Re:I always hate to hear that sand.....

Michael Stafford

>On my current lathe weight is not an issue. It may be later but right now "ain't no moving and shaking goin' on".

On my previous lathe stand which I built from heavy timbers I included a box near the bottom to store various accessories. On both ends I mounted a 1 1/2" dowel which allowed me to hang 45 pound barbell plates near the bottom. I had 3 on each end and with the lathe, stand and weights I figured the whole kit and kaboodle weighed over 600 pounds.

Nothing was shaking on that lathe stand either.

Re: Placement of sand in lathe stand

#9

Re: Placement of sand in lathe stand

Barry Irby

>I think that if you had the dead weight up high in a sturdy stand it would do more good than if it were low, but there are a lot of variables. To "improve" the center of gravity, you either lower the weight or spread the base. So, to make your car corner better you would put the wheels further apart or amount the engine and other heavy components lower and decrease the ground clearance. OTOH, your lathe is not cornering, what you are trying to do is increase the mass and inertia. Putting the weight high, closer to the shaft of the lathe means there is less of a "lever" and the unbalanced weight is trying to make the dead weight move without the advantage of a lever. So, as the shaft spins the lathe would be trying to jerk the dead weight forward, up, back, and down in each rotation.

What I did was build a sturdy rectangular cabinet with a vertical compartment under the head stock. Its about ten inches by eighteen inches by about thirty inches tall. Its full of sand. The top of the cabinet is a read oak cutting board I glued up. Under that is a tray about two inches deep, also full of sand. There are six drawers in the cabinet on full extension rails. There is a toe kick under the drawers and that is full of sand. There is a plug in the vertical compartment and I can drain the sand out if I want to move the cabinet. The sand weighs about four hundred pounds and the cabinet probably weighs close to a hundred. The lathe weighs about two hundred (Nova DVR). Not counting the stuff in the drawers. It worked pretty well. The thing that put it over the top and really settled it down was the fact that I found a roll of sheet lead about three feet long that weighs about a hundred pounds and laid it on the top behind the lathe. It might be that I simply overwhelmed the situation or that having that last bit of weight high and parallel to the shaft was the magic.

I like having the drawers in the cabinet (I have a small shop), but they tend to fill up with shavings and crap if you are not careful about closing them.

Re: Placement of sand in lathe stand

#10

Re: Placement of sand in lathe stand

Allen Neighbors

>I don't know where to find it, but I read an article about a person using a bucket filled with concrete, mounted on a pole (attached to headstock). The bucket was about 2 feet or so, above the headstock. The gist of the article was that the weight, above the headstock, was more stabilising than below, and required less weight.

There were pictures also, that showed the lathe on a dirt floor under a shed.

Anyone know where to find this article?

Re: Placement of sand in lathe stand

#11

Re: Placement of sand in lathe stand

John K Jordan

>>...what you are trying to do is increase the mass and inertia.

A friend of mine solved vibration problems by adding the mass of his shop wall to the lathe. He fastened the lathe to the wall with pipe clamps. He turned heavy, out of balance pieces outboard on an older mid-sized lathe.

JKJ

Re: Placement of sand in lathe stand

#12

Steven Antonucci

It's what you do when the shavings...

steve antonucci

>are so high behind the lathe that the work starts throwing them from the pile :-)

I am more guilty of shoveling than sweeping. Usually 4-5 snow shovels full into a bushel basket, and 2-3 baskets...

Steve

Re: Placement of sand in lathe stand

#14

Re: Placement of sand in lathe stand

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Wilber I was assisting a class given by Alan Lacer last week and he discussed this very subject with the class. He says that you should have the weight, whatever it may be, low to the ground so he suggested to build a platform low, between the legs of your lathe in order to place bags of weight low.

I use two 70lb. tubes of sand on my lathe.

Jennifer

Re: Placement of sand in lathe stand

#15

Re: Placement of sand in lathe stand

Allen Neighbors

>Thanks, Peter, that's the one I saw. I was mistaken about the concrete, though, he used sand.

Thanks again. You're a gem.

Re: Placement of sand in lathe stand

#16

Jennifer, read the link...

Allen Neighbors

>in Peter's post just above. It gives some technical info about the best location to place the weight. It doesn't look to be as practical as mounting it low, but it will take less weight. Just info... :)

Re: Placement of sand in lathe stand

#17

Higher is usually better...

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>The more closely coupled the mass is to rotating blank, the more effective the mass is. Barry's explanation is good.

The stand for my Jet Mini has a 5x8 box beam filled with sand under the lathe. I also attached two lead weights, one on top of the headstock and one on top of the tailstock. The lead weights really helped to tame the vibration.


img

Re: Placement of sand in lathe stand

#18

Re: Placement of sand in lathe stand

Bob Macgregor

>I built brackets on the ends under my lathe table to hold 24" concrete pavers on edge. They helped calm down the shaking from my old tube lathe. I haven't yet added any weight to my Craftex 18/47, but I would be inclined to use solid weights like steel or concrete chunks that could be removed if I wanted to relocate the lathe in the future.

BOB

Re: Placement of sand in lathe stand

#19

Re: Placement of sand in lathe stand

John K Jordan

>>...He says that you should have the weight, whatever it may be, low to the ground

From what little I remember of physics and dynamics classes way back in ancient times, seems this advice fails to consider some issues including properties (stiffness, springiness) of the specific structure (the lathe legs/frame) connecting the dampening mass to the moment of inertia of the rotating mass. However, I'm not a mechanical engineer, but I do know some I could possibly consult.

What I would like is a lathe with a dynamic balancing headstock that sensed, measured, and counterbalanced automatically as needed!

JKJ