Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Robust lathe vs. Serious lathe

Posts

Robust lathe vs. Serious lathe

#1

Roger Dunn

Robust lathe vs. Serious lathe

Roger Dunn

>I am getting the urge for a bigger lathe. I only fiddled with a floor model of the Robust at Portland last year and wouldn't know a Serious if it bit me. Has anyone made the leap to either or gone through this exercise to make a decision? If so I'd love some input. If there are sawdust makers with either in Western Washington I'd welcome a chance to visit one and will bring a nice hunk of Tulip wood for your trouble.

Thanks

Roger Dunn

Re: Robust lathe vs. Serious lathe

#2

Re: Robust lathe vs. Serious lathe

Fog Tanner

>Roger,

I went through that a number of years ago. I had/have a 16" steel bed Delta (US made), which did everything I wanted - until I got into offcenter turning. I quickly hit the limits on that as far as swing and weight. I started looking at other lathes, including the Serious at the time. Brent hadn't started Robust at that time. I finally settled on a choice between Vicmarc and Oneway. After conversations with a number of professional turners I went with the Vicmarc 300. I also got to "kick the tires" at a symposium here in Texas. That really sealed the deal.

After reading a page on lathes that Raffan had written, I went with the 300 longbed. Richard said that most people don't need anything over a 16" swing. But the 24" 300 long bed weighs 1000 pounds, and the bed is long enough to move the tailstock out of the way and still be on the lathe. It is a scientific known fact that the weight of the tailstock increases with age. I use it quite a bit for some of the offset bowls (insurance) so it is nice to be able to just push it "down to the end" when not needed.

At the time I looked at the Serious, they were made by a different owner and had aluminum headstocks. I wasn't sure that the aluminum would stand up so passed on that one. The "new" Serious looks to be a decent lathe at 1500+ pounds. All cast iron and plenty of mass. The only thing I don't like about it is the splayed base. Those are difficult for me to work around. I have the Australian Vic, which has the most comfortable base I have ever used - at least for me.

After seeing pictures of the new Robust Sweet 16, the decision on lathes just got a little more difficult (I have the urge for a bigger lathe too). It has a fixed head, which is a must for me with the offset turning, and you can configure it to go up to 30". I look forward to seeing one next month here in Texas.

Either way you go, your turning will improvde just by going to the larger machine. After getting mine, I found out why all the video/DVDs that the pros make are on large lathes. They are really that much more solid and easier to work on. I have also come to the realization that one can never have too many lathes. Good luck in your quest, I know it is agonizing - but worth it in the end.

Fog

Re: Robust lathe vs. Serious lathe

#3

Re: Robust lathe vs. Serious lathe

Ralph

>Interesting question, lets look at some items:

Serious

  • Heavier

  • Imported

  • New owners (who do it part time, one of the owners was the Demo at the club just before Portland)

  • locally sold (Oregon)

    Robust

  • Assembled in the US

  • Longer track record, with regard to current owners

  • Local dealer (Don Pencil up at Orcas Island)

    I looked at both the "old" Serious and the big Robust at Portland, hands down I would buy Robust.

    Regionally Robo-Hippy (Reed) down in Eugene has bought a Robust

    TTFN

    Ralph

  • Re: Robust lathe vs. Serious lathe

    #4

    Re: Robust lathe vs. Serious lathe

    Bill Grumbine - Kutztown PA

    >Roger, people often ask me why I bought a Robust. My answer is that I have turned extensively on just about every lathe on the market - Poolewood, Vega, all the Oneway machines, all the new and most of the older Powermatics, Vicmarc, Stubby, the VB-36, all the Generals, Woodfast, the new big Rikon, etc. With the exception of a few of the newer minis and all the Harbor Freight lathes, I have turned on just about everything, even an old Blount from the early 1900s. And after all that, I chose the Robust. I have not turned on a Serious lathe though.

    Two things that are very important to understand. I am a Robust dealer, although that did not happen until after I made my buying decision and plunked my money down. That means I might be a little biased. But of course, I am not. ;-) The second thing is, it is hard to go wrong with just about any of these machines. When you get to this level, it is features and service that you want to see. If it is at all possible, it is a good idea to spend some time turning on the machines in which you are interested before spending your money. I had a guy in my shop just two days ago drooling over my Robust. He bought a Powermatic 4224, and said he wished he had waited just a bit more before he did. Don't get me wrong. The 4224 is a very good machine. I'm just sayin' what he said to me.

    Bill

    Re: Robust lathe vs. Serious lathe

    #5

    Re: Robust lathe vs. Serious lathe

    Martin from Texas

    >While I don't have the $$$ quite yet, I am looking at and comparing the Robust Sweet 16 vs. the Oneway 1640. If anyone has any thoughts on those two, I would love to hear them.

    Unfortunately, the Robust lathes will have a price increase September 15, before I will be able to afford one.

    Still, I would like to know where, and when, I could look at a Robust lathe in Texas in person.

    Thanks,

    Martin

    Re: Robust lathe vs. Serious lathe

    #6

    Re: Robust lathe vs. Serious lathe

    Doug Thompson near Cleveland

    >Martin, Robust will be at SWAT (Waco) in October. All lathes went up in price so nothing can be done. Robust has a sliding headstock and stainless ways... great lathe.

    Re: Robust lathe vs. Serious lathe

    #7

    Roger Dunn

    Re: Robust lathe vs. Serious lathe

    Roger Dunn

    >Thanks everyone for your input. I have a Powermatic 4224. I chose that over a Vicmarc 4 years ago. The PM is a good lathe but I turned on a bowl lathe recently and that is what started me thinking of how much easier it is to stand in the middle of the work instead of leaning over the ways. Thanks Ralph, I didn't realize Don Pencil was a Robust dealer, I've been waiting for Brent to get back from vacation, so I might need to take a trip to the San Juans.

    Re: Robust lathe vs. Serious lathe

    #8

    Re: Robust lathe vs. Serious lathe

    robo hippy

    >For me, it was the Robust. I didn't even consider the Serious, or the Oneway, but I did look at the VB36. The sliding headstock is the kicker. I don't care about cast iron, or stainless steel. Noises are different, but not a deciding factor. For me, the place in my shop for the lathe is in a corner. No outboard turning for me. Also, the sliding headstock means no leaning over the bed of the lathe for anything, not boxes, not hollow forms, not the inside of bowls. If you are spending 4 to 6 hours in a day at your lathe, this means a lot to your back.

    robo hippy

    Re: Robust lathe vs. Serious lathe

    #9

    Roger Dunn

    Thank you all for your help!

    Roger Dunn

    >

    Re: Robust lathe vs. Serious lathe

    #10

    Re: Thank you all for your help!

    Brent English

    >Hi Folks, just for clarification, Don Pencil is not a dealer, but I do supply one of his face plates in the accessories that come with the lathe. Don put a rather prominent link to Robust on his website in response. Thanks, Brent