Meteor follow-up
keith tompkins
>Steve's "Meteor" post touched on an important topic, one that deserves much more attention that it usually receives. When the topic of "finding your own voice" comes up, many turners interpret the term as simply "come to my demo, learn my techniques, but don't copy my work". I think Steve's post illustrates the true meaning of finding your voice. If you can put a piece of yourself into your work, there is a tangible, palpable quality that viewers can sense. David Ellsworth once told me that at first he was concerned when people copied his work, but soon came to realize that the copies didn't generate the same responses that his own pieces did....something was missing. A music analogy I often use: Let's say I do a remake of a Beatle's song. My harmonies are better, the instrumentals are better, production is better; technically the original pales in comparison. Yet, my version is still just a copy; I'll never capture the feeling of the original, nor will my version ever gain even a remote amount of recognition as the original. The orignal song was inspired by real life experience, and has feeling, soul, meaning. The copy is dead and lifeless.
Likewise, many turnings may be technically brilliant, but lack a certain spark that makes them stand out from the crowd...they could have been produced by a number of turners, but impossible to say who. Putting a piece of yourself in the work is missing key. Steve's piece is a great example of what I'm referring to. Perhaps now when we see a meteor(ite) or asteroid we will instantly think "yep, Steve did another one!"
I find it amazing how many people who have attended my demos or classes tell me how much I've influenced the direction of their work by sharing the simple concept of capturing their life experiences, and expressing them through their work. Maybe this post will generate some discussion; btw, my discussions with Mark Mandell have broadened my own horizons a great deal, and have forced me to rethink many of my preconceived ideas...thanks Mark.



