Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

maple hollowform

Posts

maple hollowform

#1

maple hollowform

Steven Kubien

>Evening folks,

This is hollowform #3 for me. Ambrosia maple with some neat-o curl happening on the sapwood side. I've got a bunch of coats of dewaxed shellac on it and it measures around 6.5" wide and 6" high.

How did I do on the shape/form? No really, I can take it.

Thanks for looking.

Steve Kubien


img

Re: maple hollowform

#2

Steven Antonucci

Better than my #3

steve antonucci

>By leaps and bounds.

One thing that I think will help you in turning it to learn to feel the curve with your eyes closed. Overall, the shape isn't bad, but I think I can see a couple of flat spots in the upper section. If you can't see them, you can probably feel them.

Try it and let me know if you don't. It might just be the picture.

Steve

Re: maple hollowform

#3

Re: maple hollowform

Dinyar Chavda

>As Steve says, this is an excellent piece, and the only reason for my comments is because you explicitly asked for suggestions. I'd look at these, not so much as "errors", as much as alternatives that you may wish to try in future pieces.

As I have mentioned in prior posts, I do not have a good eye, and so I compensate by taking a picture of the piece, and then printing it in black and white. Doing so, reduces it to 2 dimensions, which I find easier to deal with when it comes to form, and it removes the distraction of grain, allowing me to focus on shape.

I tried this approach on your piece, using software to simulate the process, and came up with 2 alternatives.

The first one smoothes out the curve on top to a slight extent, making it flow a bit easier.

The 2nd one takes in the curve even more, and while you could stop there, I also played with exaggerating the ogee curve at the bottom to better reflect the top. I haven't done a great jon with the line, but, hopefully, you get the idea.

I hope the basic approach of using pencil and paper to refine or change a shape helps. If you do this, make sure you cover your piece with a plastic bag, to avoid changes in shape as well as possible cracks due to moisture loss.


img

Re: maple hollowform

#4

Re: Better than my #3

Steven Kubien

>Nah, it's just the picture. I had felt flats while it was still on the lathe, reworked them, used a straight-edge, used my hands... Eventually, everything did curve. I have a couple of my earliest pieces and there are definite flat areas (read: expanses) on some of those.

Thanks,

Steve

Re: maple hollowform

#5

Re: maple hollowform

Steven Kubien

>Hey Dinyar,

I like your 2 dimensional approach to this. It sure see the lines easier. FWIW, I think you may be right, especially about the lower portion needing more of an ogee shape. When it was on the lathe it started to look like it would have a tippy look to it. Next time I find myself in that situation, I will "go for it" (as R. Raffan would say) and see what happens. Thanks for taking the time.

Steve Kubien