Tormek w/TNT system
Bill Turpin in WNC mountains
>Has anyone seen or used this new system for woodturners? Opinions please. Is it worth the $800+?
TIA,
Bill
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Tormek w/TNT system
Bill Turpin in WNC mountains
>Has anyone seen or used this new system for woodturners? Opinions please. Is it worth the $800+?
TIA,
Bill
Re: Tormek w/TNT system
Tommy Holmes
>I've had mine for a couple of months now. I feel like my tools are sharper and and hold an edge longer. Actually I know they are sharper.I can hear the difference in the cut after sharpening and honing. I was using the Wolverine system.
I get the exact bevel every time once you get your angles set and blocks made. There is a learning curve and I'm still not through that curve with all my tools but I have not turned much since I've had it until a couple of weeks ago.
I would still not give up the Wolverine system. It's great for initial shaping of the tools although it can be done on the Tormek but it is quicker on the Wolverine. I'm not too convinced that the HSS tools are damaged to much extent from the heat by shaping on the dry wheel.
Some say the Tormek is too slow but for most sharpenings it is almost as quick or as quick as the wolverine, measure the length the tool goes through the jig, put the block between the wheel and the support bar, a few seconds on the wheel and it's done. I normally don't hone often unless I'm making a finishing cut.
You do have to grade the wheel occasionally and you do have to keep water in the in the shop. I do like that I'm not showering the shop with sparks and have the particles to clean up later.
You get the bonus of sharpening just about any other tools you use in the shop and in the house (I've got the hand tool kit also).
Is it worth $800? I believe it was Steve A. that said you couldn't pry his cold, dead hands off his. I'm not quite that attached to mine but I am happy with the results I get from it.
It was me, and I stand by the comment!
steve antonucci
>Now you want to do the ultimate in scary sharp? I have a couple of Thompson tools on my Tormek that get so sharp they'll cut you if you look at them crossly. :-)
Every Tormek owner should have the following: The gouge jig. The turning tool setter. The flat tool rest. And the Skew Jig.
I have had a few turners come through my shop, and I think every one of them thought they knew how to sharpen and what sharp meant. When they left, their tools were sharper than they hade ever been and they had a longing in their hearts...
Steven
Re: Tormek w/TNT system
wilbur
>I have the previous version of the Tormek and the jigs that come in that TNT package. I love using it for turning tools.
The one thing that people say about the Tormek is that it is "too slow". I'm not sure that's really the case. I find the set up time to be really no different than with a Wolverine/grinder set up, especially using the turning tool setup jig. You can make your own turning tool setting jig as well.
One time I got curious as to how slow was "too slow". So I went down to my shop with our kitchen timer to see how slow my Tormek is.
Total time to set up the Tormek and sharpen a bowl gouge: 2 minutes 32 seconds. (Actually, it was 2 minutes and 31.98 seconds.)
I looked over to the timer at various points to get approximate split times:
0' 45": Mounted the bowl gouge in the jig and used the turning tool setter to get the right protrusion.
1' 15": Used the turning tool setter to set the bar the right distance from the wheel. Marked the bevel of the gouge with a Sharpie, mounted the gouge and jig, and did the rub test to check position.
2' 31.98": Done grinding. The disappearance of the Sharpie marks confirms that I've gotten the whole edge.
This was going at my usual pace. I also tried going for a speed record with this routine, which was 1 1/2 minutes. I also don't usually use the Sharpie -- I did this just to make sure that I was grinding the whole bevel of the gouge, to keep the test honest.
There may be other reasons for buying a grinder/Wolverine system instead of a Tormek, but I have a hard time understanding why the time saved when sharpening a gouge would be one of them. 2 1/2 minutes seems pretty reasonable to me.
The Tormek does take longer to reshape a profile on a turning tool, but then again, this is an operation that should only be done once. If you are constantly reshaping the profile of your gouge, you should probably buy another gouge. In any case, the times I've reshaped a gouge profile, it took about 15 minutes, as opposed to about 3 minutes on a grinder. A 12 minute difference for a one time operation I can live with.
The main benefits of the Tormek as I see them are:
1. Don't have to worry about grinder wheel/metal dust floating around in my shop.
2. Don't have to worry about stray sparks and the potential for a fire.
3. I feel that I have a lot more control over the edge and how much I am grinding with a Tormek than with a grinder.
4. Turning tools last longer with a Tormek, since the jigs help minimize the amount of metal you remove during sharpening.
Re: Tormek w/TNT system
Wayne Kuhn
>My problem using the Tormek instead of the Wolverine is the water filling and emptying (my least favorite part of the Tormek.) If I could leave the water in it and just top off now and then I don't see a lot of difference.
I think the Tormek is a great system, but I think the Wolverine is a better system for my turning tools.
Wayne Kuhn
Columbia, MD
Re: Tormek w/TNT system
wilbur
>FWIW, I never really empty out the water. Eventually it just evaporates. Every so often I take the plastic bucket out to the backyard and hose it out.
Re: Tormek w/TNT system
Dan Faux
>With the help of Ronald Nelson and others on this site I believe I now have the best of both worlds, I have my Tormek on one side of bench and my dry grinder set to use Tormek jigs on the other. The angles are so accurate that I just go straight from one to the other and the shaping time is so quick it really suprises me and others who have seen this in action.The Tormek is on a swivel base so that I can use both sides.
Re: Tormek w/TNT system
Dan Faux
>View from other side
Ditto
steve antonucci
>
Re: Tormek w/TNT system
Bill Turpin in WNC mountains
>Thanks guys! My wife, who is a better turner than me (did I actually say that?) fears the heat, sparks, fire hazard, etc. of the Wolverine. Consequently she turns with dull tools most of the time. There will be a Tormek in her future.
Bill
Swivel base
wilbur
>Hi Dan,
That swivel base is a great idea. How do you lock it in place? Zaprudering your picture, it looks like you might have a toggle clamp on a corner of the swivel base -- is that right?
Re: Ditto
Dan Faux
>Hi Wilbur and Steve
For me, simple is good. Just two pins that are a firm fit do the job just fine (sorry, can't see the holes in the pic but they are about where the pins are) and there is no movement whatsoever. The base is a metal 250mm lazy susan turntable.
Dan