Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

has anyone tried this?

Posts

has anyone tried this?

#1

has anyone tried this?

bq in vt

>Has anyone tried using a gooseneck cabinet scraper on turnings? I turn thin - +/- 1/16th" - and I found at low speed and whith good bowl support, I can use the scraper to fine tune the inside of the bowl. With it sharp I can get very fine shavings and if everything goes well (like that ever happens...) I end up with a decent finish that requires less sanding. When the bowl is getting that thin, I find the scraper is safer than a gouge. On the other hand, it could be said I need to develop more skill with a bowl gouge, but for now it works well enough and it doesn't catch, destroying your bowl while you make your final cut(has happened a few times...).

Re: has anyone tried this?

#2

Re: has anyone tried this?

john lucas

>This also works great on the outside although you do have to protect your hands. The scraper can get very hot very quick.

If I'm in need of scraping I usually use a round nose scraper tilted to about 45 degrees. Use the lower 1/3 so you don't get catches. This gets rid of tool marks and tearout quite well. On really thin bowls I will often do this one handed with my left hand touching the outside of the bowl. A thin bowl will flex and is more likely to catch because of this. Your hand stops this flexing and makes it less likely to catch.

A bowl gouge uses as a scraper with the flute toward the bowl and the upper lip just clear of the wood works really well but doesn't leave quite as good a finish as the shear scraping. However used like this it won't catch. I learned this years ago from the guy who turns lampshades out of wood. He still used his left hand outside to dampen the vibrations.

A curved cabinet scraper works really great with the lathe off to clean up torn grain in bad areas. If you go at it from multiple directions and feather out toward the edges of the area you can get rid of a tearout section really fast. It doesn't leave the winter/summer wood ridges that sandpaper leaves but it can leave a mild depression that can be felt.

Re: has anyone tried this?

#3

Re: has anyone tried this?

bowlman

>I have used cabinet scrapers on the lathe for many years. Both inside and out. Depends on the phases of the moon and whether my mojo is working as to whether I use a bowl gouge as a shear scraper, a regular scraper like John suggested, or the cabinet scrapers. Or even the John Jordan shear scraper. I am also putting together a demo for local chapters on the proper use, maintenance,care of scrapers on the lathe and the scrapers relationship to gouges.

Re: has anyone tried this?

#4

Yes

Ron in Drums PA

>Gooseneck for the inside and rectangle for the outside.

Works great on some woods, not so great on softer woods unless the lathe is turned off.

Re: has anyone tried this?

#5

Re: has anyone tried this?

Chip in Plano

>I've only used one on the outside of a turning. I haven't tried it on the inside of a bowl because I read a post online where the writer was warning of this use on the inside of a hollow form. The poor chap had a catch, lost grip and the scraper slashed his hands and fingers pretty bad before he yanked his hand out. It happened in a flash.

So a nice open bowl might be fine but this accident is what always comes to mind when I think about using it on the inside of a bowl. I have a new perspective (consciously cautious) after sticking my left thumb and ring finger in my bandsaw last year. My mistake was being too tired to be changing my bandsaw blade that late in the day.

Re: has anyone tried this?

#6

What's the best way to sharpen...

GaryG in MD

>...a curved cabinet scraper? I've tried rubbing a steel on mine but can't seem to get a good edge. ...Gary

Re: has anyone tried this?

#7

Re: has anyone tried this?

Carole Valentine

>I have used curved cabinet scrapers on the inside of open bowls often (carefully) but any one who would stick one - along with their hand - into a hollow form needs to have their head examined IMHO!

Re: has anyone tried this?

#8

Steven Antonucci

Carefully with a file

steve antonucci

>I usually do mine with a file, and then burnish the hook on a small carbide rod. I don't do the whole curved surface at one time, or I end up with a million little cuts on my hands...

Steven

Re: has anyone tried this?

#9

Re: has anyone tried this?

Gordon Seto

>A member of our Club got cut in his hand real bad. Be careful on the inside.

Re: has anyone tried this?

#10

Re: Carefully with a file

GaryG in MD

>Thanks Steve, I assume you mean to file the flat side to remove any old burr first? How hard do you have to push on the rod to raise a decent burr? At 90 degrees? Both hand held, or one locked to the bench? Thanks, Gary

Re: has anyone tried this?

#11

Sharpening *LINK*

Ron in Drums PA

>I purchased this tool about 8 years ago, it works great.

I only raise a burr on one edge of a rectangle cabinet scraper and round over all the corners and other edges. On a curved scraper, I only raise a burr on a 2" section the rest is rounded over. Safer that way.


http://www.woodsmithstore.com/cabinetscraper.html

Re: has anyone tried this?

#12

thanks Ron

GaryG in MD

>

Re: has anyone tried this?

#13

Steven Antonucci

If you have a diamond stone, use that on the flat

steve antonucci

>If not, your finest file is good.

What I do is gently file the flats to remove the burr, and then perpendicular to the flats along the edge. One pass usually removes any work hardened steel.

To raise a burr, I used to use a screwdriver shank, but then I bought this little carbide rod from Enco, thinking I would cut it into a bit for a hollowform. Three cutoff wheels later, I knew I wasn't going to be able to cut it :-)

I raise my burrs with the intention of fine work, and I use "moderate pressure." After 2-3 passes, I feel for the burr. If it isn't very good, a couple more passes. The pressure should be about the same as buttering toast with semi-solid butter.

Take a few practice passes at it before trying it on a bowl. If it won't cut on a flat piece on a bench, it won't cut a round moving piece on a lathe either.

Hope that helps

Steve

Re: has anyone tried this?

#14

Re: Is Craig Daymon here?

Mike Hamilton

>Might be time for some safety reminders and shot of some scars related to cabinet scraping the inside of a bowl.

Let's be careful out there.....

Regards,

Mike

Re: has anyone tried this?

#15

Thanks Steve...

GaryG in MD

>That's very clear. Just what I needed. Love the toast. I'll give it a try. ...Gary

Re: has anyone tried this?

#16

Use this often

John K Jordan

>I use cabinet scrapers a lot, especially on problem grain and on soft wood that tends to tear. As in the picture, I cut the end off the scraper and make a flat edge to use for flat and convex surfaces. It does have to be kept sharp.

As for safety, putting your hand inside a spinning closed form with a full-sized scraper doesn't seem wise to me. However, I believe a small scraper is safe in a variety of situations.

BTW, I do most of my scraping with the lathe turned off, working directly on the problem areas, but I have used it on both the inside and outside of spinning bowls and boxes when appropriate. For fun, I once finished a goblet with scrapers only (no sandpaper) just to see if I could do it and it worked fine.

A few years ago I purchased a set of small scraper (oval, etc) from Highland Hardware. They are useful as well, but I prefer using the one illustrated.

JKJ


img

Re: has anyone tried this?

#17

Away for Labor Day, but I'm back. DON'T DO IT!

Craig Daymon

>DO NOT, I repeat, DO NOT use a cabinet scraper on the inside of an in-turned bowl with it on the lathe! I foolishly tried this, and have posted about it here, and I required surgery to reattach a nerve and a tendon in my wrist. The side of my right hand is still numb.

I actually think John's small scraper could be just as dangerous inside a rotating bowl. If it gets away, you can't be certain where it won't try to go and that smaller scraper is just that much harder to keep a good hold on.

I have mounted a 1.25" disk cut from a scraper (the one that cut me) to the end of a Sorby Multi-Tool handle, which would allow me to work inside without being in there, but PLEASE DON'T hold the scraper inside a turning bowl.

When using one on the outside, I would keep the scraper below center so it should not get thrown toward me. Or possibly reverse the lathe so it would be thrown away from me. This seems like the safest approach. Wear a face shield! A shop apron tied tight might be a good idea as well. Just read an old FWW where someone suggested wearing a welder's apron while turning. That might be good too.

I was very surprised to read that article at the end of the recent Woodcraft magazine. I'd almost bet he was in the audience or heard it from someone who attended one of the meetings where I confessed my foolishness when I was living in Pennsylvania. He lived too close to the area I was from. If so, he's just all the more the fool.

Don't think that you're smarter than me. If you try this, you will sooner or later prove you're not. Don't think you're stronger than me and can hold onto the scraper without it getting away. Just say "No" to being a dope!

Besides, if you really like the color of blood on your bowls, just turn some box elder.

-Craig