Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

of HP and Amps

Posts

of HP and Amps

#1

of HP and Amps

Kurt Whitley

>When I was at IWF, the soon to be released 12.5" swing Delta midi's got my attention. They claim 1HP compared to the 3/4HP of the Jet 1220. Knowing manufacturers sometimes play games with HP figures and thinking Amps might be more accurate I checked a few lathes to see what they showed. This is what I found:

Jet 1220VS 4.5A, 3/4HP

New DeltaVS 8A, 1HP

Jet 1442 Reeves drive 11A, 3/4HP

Can anyone offer any explanation on how this works?

Re: of HP and Amps

#2

Re: of HP and Amps

Lan Brady

>I cannot explain it, but the Jet 1442 is 1 HP, not 3/4HP.

Re: of HP and Amps

#3

Re: of HP and Amps

Harvey Meyer in Atlanta

>I learned this stuff 40 years ago (has it really been that long?) so my memory may not be perfect but here goes:

In a perfect world, a single phase motor that is 100% efficient would use 746 watts for 1 hp. Watts = volts X amps so a 1 hp motor using 746 watts would use 746/110v = about 6.8 amps.

There are no perfect motors and they all have a power factor that accounts for losses due to heat and friction, etc. A decent motor with an 80% power factor would use 1.25 times the amperage so 1.25 X 6.8 = about 8.5 amps. You can extrapolate this to any hp motor. So a .5 hp motor that is 80% efficient would require about 4.25 amps. A 1.5 hp motor that is 80% efficient would require 12.75 amps. You can also see why a 220 v motor would use 1/2 the amps that a 110 v motor uses. A 1 hp motor, 80% efficient, requires 8.5 amps at 110 v or 4.25 amps at 220v.

That's my story and I'm sticking to it.

Harvey

Re: of HP and Amps

#4

Re: of HP and Amps

Harvey Meyer in Atlanta

>It may be easier if you see the formula for determining current (amps)

amps = watts/(voltsXpower factor)

1 hp always = 746 watts.

For a 1 hp motor that is 80% efficient at 110v:

amps = 746/(110X.8) = 8.48amps

For a 2hp motor that is 80% efficient at 220v:

amps = 1492/(220X.8) = 8.48amps

Of course the manufacturers don't specify the power factor, but 80% is a good estimate.

Re: of HP and Amps

#5

Power Factor

Bill Howatt

>While the maximum drawn by a motor is indeed influenced by the power-factor, I don't believe it is correct to equate power-factor to efficiency.

Efficiency is better expressed as the real power output compared to the real power input to the motor. It accounts for losses such as resistance heating in the windings, power to magnetize the poles (magnetizing current) and friction.

The power factor is determined by the total power drawn: resistive and reactive. The reactive component does matter in sizing the wire and related equipment to supply the motor but it does not contribute to producing work and it is actually returned to the power line. This does not cost you any more money on your power bill because your house meter measures only the resistive (real) power.

Bill

Re: of HP and Amps

#6

Re: Power Factor

Kurt Whitley

>I guess what I am wondering is if the ~12" Jet and Delta midis draw 4.5 and 8 Amps (78% increase), respectively, should I conclude that the Delta has a significantly more powerful motor (more than the 33% increase of 3/4 vs. 1hp indicated by the labels)?

I understand that some motors are better than others at converting electricity to mechanical force, but I've always presumed:

1) that the differences between a typical motor and an optimal motor are not great and

2) that the motors used on these imported lathes would be pretty much the same - reliable, but not likely to have any state-of-the-art performance.

Thanks,

Kurt

Re: of HP and Amps

#7

Re: Power Factor

Curly Smith

>Two things:

First, if you calculate the HP for each of the motors @ 115V (V*A/746) you get

Jet 1220 VS 4.5A = 0.69 HP @ 100% efficiency

Delta VS 8A = 1.23 HP @ 100% efficiency

Jet 1442 11A = 1.69 HP @ 100% efficiency

Second, motors are rated by [(full-load motor speed (RPM) * full load torque (in lb-ft)) / 5250] and not by V*A. Granted, the motor can't deliver more power than it is supplied, but the V*A doesn't tell you whether or not the full load speed & torque used in the rating occur in a range that's useful. My guess is that the load curve for the Jet 1220 VS motor isn't as well suited for the task as the Delta motor is; I'd also guess that explains the comments posted by others that the VS unit is under-powered (the motor is probably more of a 1/3 - 1/2 hp motor under load than a 3/4 hp motor).

And, since I'm guessing I might as well make another one: the first two motors are either NEMA A or NEMA B motors while the last, the 11A 1 HP motor, is a NEMA E and the nameplate for it reflects the high locked-rotor current (the current at startup) rather than the actual running current.

Re: of HP and Amps

#8

Re: Power Factor

Bill Howatt

>I've long since given up ever trying to make sense of the HP claims and tend to rightly or wrongly equate more current to more power. My rule of thumb is 10A is likely to give your 1 real HP. This would allow for efficiency and power-factor.

I was on the Baldor site and they say their premium efficency motors are 94.5% efficient compared to 88% for a typical industrial motot. This more or less goes with the statement that there isn't a huge difference in efficiency. I also doubt any of the machines you mentioned or that we encounter in a typical shop are in the premium efficiency category. Apparently the better efficiency is achieved by heavier copper windings (less resistance loss), premium metal and tighter tolerance on cores (less magnetizing current loss).

Anyway I think the 4.5A motor would be weak. I had a 12" lathe with a 4A motor and it certainly was.

Bill

Bill