>I am out of my league here because I usually do pretty big things but I will need a mini lathe to travel with and attend regional symposiums as a vendor. I will be doing hollow form turning. A mini has no problem hollowing but I would like the most power I can get to hog off hollow form blanks. I have heard that there is power loss with the variable speed models. If true, how much power loss?? All the mini/midi lathes have the same 1/2 hp motor rating but how do you compare the power output?? Has anybody got any idea how to compare the different brands for power to the wood?? I am looking at Jet, Delta, Rikon, Vicmarc and Turncrafter. Am I missing any?? Thanks!! Lyle
>I have the Ricon and before getting the Nova 1624 I used the McNaughton coring tool on it,it takes me about 10 sec tochamge the speeds on either one.I have heard that you do loose a little power with the VS,but don't quote me on that one.I like the Ricon beause it has a 12" swing over the 10" on the jet.I turned a lot of bowls up to 11" with it.
>A Nova 3000 is a relatively portable lathe. Assuming that you had an hour to set up, I think you could do it in half that. Nothing on the lathe weighs more than 50#'s or so. I break mine down once a year to clean and tighten everything...
Steven
P.S. I don't know how portable you need... I was thinking along the lines of "fits in your trunk/one man assembly"...
>The term "mini" or "midi" is being used loosely these days. When I hear that term I think of the 10" lathes. There's quite a few of the 12 inch "big brother" versions of the 10" lathes. Most of the 12" have 3/4 horse instead of the 1/2" and the "rumors" are the new "upgraded" version of the Delta has 1 horse. I have the non-VS 6 speed Jet 1220. It's about 100 lbs without the stand, but I think it's easier to carry than the 1014 by jet since it has very convenient "handles" on the ends to carry it. When someone is turning on a 1/2 horse lathe it's hard to judge if there's a power loss since there isn't much to start with. It does seem there is some though with the VS versions. How to judge that? It would be hard to say without having 3-4 different models side by side and make similar cuts on identically matched pieces of wood. If it's a convenience issue, I'd go with the VS and just have the blanks roughed in advance, at least rounded. If it's a power issue, I'd go with the "standard".
A few more options are Steel City Toolworks (steelcitytoolworks.com) has a standard and VS lathe as well as General International and their small lathes.
>Lyle There is a definite loss of power on the VS models if you turn the speed down any at all. I turned 8" bowls for 3 days on a VS Jet with 1/2 horse and it sucked. I had to take little bitty bites. The non variable speed is better but not great. I have used a Nova Comet with 1/2 horse for years and it has a physically larger motor. It is still 1/2 horse but has more power at the tool than the jets.
My friend Don Russel was demonstrating the new Delta mini with 1 horse Variable frequency drive motor. I saw him at the IWF in Atlanta. I trust Don and he says it's strong all the way down to the minimum rpm. This would echo my experience on other larger lathes that have the VFD. To top it off this lathe also has a 3 step pulley in case you don't find it powerful enough or fast enough you can change the pulley. Delta came around to several clubs including ours and asked what we all wanted in a mini. I think they listened. The lathe is slightly longer than the Jet 12/20 and has 12" swing. Everything seems to work very well but alas I didn't get to actually turn on it. Don is a long time turner and woodworker and knows tools.
>Lyle, my mini lathe does not really suffer a loss of power, but it ain't your run of the mill mini. I have an old Vicmarc VL-100 (or whatever the model number is) that I bought back in 1996. At that time it came without a motor, so I had to supply my own. I bought a 1/2 HP DC variable speed motor with a Minarik controller from Craft Supplies along with the lathe. I've got something like five or six speed ranges, from 0-500 through 0-4200 rpm.
The stand I built is adjustable for height with a range of 10", and comes apart or goes together without any tools. The motor is mounted on a sliding dovetail, making speed range changes fast and easy. Of course, the whole thing without the stand set me back $750, 12 years ago. But that's one reason it ain't run of the mill. ;-)
>Lyle, horsepower is proportional to the product of torque (ft-lbs) and speed (rpm). As you turn down the speed of a variable speed motor, the torque stays about the same, but since the speed is less, the horsepower delivered is proportionally less. To retain a constant horsepower, you need to reduce the speed by changing pulleys rather than reducing motor speed. In this way, you increase torque as you reduce speed and (ignoring friction losses) the delivered power remains the same. In short, if you want the best performance, get a system with as many pulley ratios as possible and use pulley changes to reduce speed. This is exactly the same situation in an auto: For best performance, get a transmission with as many gear ratios as possible. Dennis
The Jet 1220 VS 3/4 HP mini has 6 positions on the pulley starting at a low of about 200 RPM. This is a very nice lathe and I find that it has a lot of power even at low speeds. Weight 100 lbs.
>Too bad Craft Supplies seems to have discontinued the Vicmarc VL100 which I think would be the best approach as Bill Grumbine did, and adding your own motor. If you can find it that's what I'd do if I were in your shoes, Lyle.
Have some kind of quick-release motor mount so you can carry the lathe and motor seperately.
I could be wrong but the stock motors on any of the popular minis like Jet and Delta etc. will probably be a disappointment sooner or later, and lose some or all of their smoke as they sometimes say. It's fairly common thing on the various turning forums to see these motors give out or have some type of issue.
If you bought one of these and replaced the motor right away with a more powerful & versatile motor, the stock motor could be easily sold as someone else's replacement.
I am leary of the minis with the pulley on the outboard end of the headstock spindle instead of between the bearings and would favor the latter (Jet, for example).
I've had several mini-lathes: a CarbaTec, a Nova Comet, a Nova Mercury, a Bonnie Klein lathe, and my most recent and in my opinion the best is my Vicmarc VL-100 evs that I purchased in Australia. I had to purchase a 110 to 220 vac transformer to run the 220 volt machine, but is works great. Its one drawback is its weight, I can't lift it. I have it mounted on a wheeled cart that I can roll up a ramp to get into the pickup, but stairs are out of the question. I've found mine to have plenty of power.
I did see a fellow at the Down Under Turnaround on Philip Island near Melbourne, Australia who hadone of these lathes fixed so that he could easily separate the lathe from the power unit and make it light enough to carry. If I did a lot of demonstrating as you do, I would make the conversion that he had rigged.
The Vicmarc VL-100 can also be fitted with a bed extension to make it longer in case you wanted to use a stabilized boring bar.
Incidentally, I think you can get the VL-100 evs with 220 power at Woodworker's Emporium in Las Vegas, Nevada.
>Hi All, Thanks so much for all your collective wisdom. Sorry it has taken me so long to respond. I have been working through all your suggestions and checking with manufacturers so I wanted to pass along my findings. Space and portibility are necessary so the nova is not the answer. The true mimi's all have 1/2 HP and I want more power. Thanks Dennis for reminding me that torque is the issus not power when using the variable speed models. As long as you change the belts so the variable speed is working at the top end of its range you have good power transfer. The motor has to be running at full rpm to get full torque. Hope that makes sense to all of you. If I was going to use it primarily at home, I really like the Vicmarc mini. It is the strongest of the group...BUT...it has 220 and is too heavy to transport easily in and out of my van, and set up on a flimsy portable venders table. So I went with the Jet 12/20 VS. Its light enough to wheel around and lift onto tables. It has 3/4HP for the little extra power I need. And I am impressed with the service from WMH see new thred above for details. Again thank you all for sharing your expertise with me. Lyle
>Hi Fred, Thanks for bringing up the bed extensions and supported boring bar systems. One reason I want a mini lathe to demonstrate with is to show how easy it is to do hollow forms on mini lathes. One of my back rest models is designed to work with mini lathes as is without the bed extension. Same boring bars, same cutters, HSS or carbide, same laser, all work with the mini lathes. Lyle