P.S. Bowl gouges are round
steve antonucci
>I thought a little bit more about this, and I think that a bowl gouge also works better because it is round, which means that you've typically got a lot more control in the rotational axis. The tool is always at the same leverage point, which is much harder to obtain than a square sectioned tool on edge.
Another consideration is the forces at the cutting tip are directed downward through the point of contact, which is cantilevered through the square section much greater than the round section. You would feel it as a tendency for the scraper to want to roll to a flat position. A catch also creates a ding in my tool rest that I'll need to file out later.
Also, I think the mass of the typical bowl gouge (5/8") is usually 2x the typical scraper (1/4" +/-) which helps dampen vibration. All things being equal, the wood doesn't see anything but the edge of the steel and how it is presented.
But I think it's much easier to do a proper shear scrape with a bowl gouge...YMMV
Steve