Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Shear Scraping..

Posts

Shear Scraping..

#1

Shear Scraping..

Dave Winters

>I own and use quite a few different dedicated shear scrapers, but nothing I have tried works quite as well as my freshly sharpened swept back bowl gouge turned upside down. This was my first shear scraper years ago, and still the one I go to the most.

Just me though... Anybody else?

Re: Shear Scraping..

#2

Re: Shear Scraping..

Russ Fairfield

>You are probably using a lesser angle between the bevel and the flute than you would be using on a scraper, and that "sharper" edge cuts better in the scraping mode. You would notice a similar improvement with your scrapers if they were ground to that same angle, and used the same presentation to the wood.

Re: Shear Scraping..

#3

Steven Antonucci

So much about turning is muscle memory

steve antonucci

>I agree with you. If I need to shear scrape, I reach for a bowl gouge. Why, because 80% of the time, I have a bowl gouge in my hand anyway. I know the feel of that tool better than any other in my rack. Could I shear scrape like Russ mentions?- probably with a lot of practice.

But a bowl gouge in my hands is automatic.

Steve

Re: Shear Scraping..

#4

Steven Antonucci

P.S. Bowl gouges are round

steve antonucci

>I thought a little bit more about this, and I think that a bowl gouge also works better because it is round, which means that you've typically got a lot more control in the rotational axis. The tool is always at the same leverage point, which is much harder to obtain than a square sectioned tool on edge.

Another consideration is the forces at the cutting tip are directed downward through the point of contact, which is cantilevered through the square section much greater than the round section. You would feel it as a tendency for the scraper to want to roll to a flat position. A catch also creates a ding in my tool rest that I'll need to file out later.

Also, I think the mass of the typical bowl gouge (5/8") is usually 2x the typical scraper (1/4" +/-) which helps dampen vibration. All things being equal, the wood doesn't see anything but the edge of the steel and how it is presented.

But I think it's much easier to do a proper shear scrape with a bowl gouge...YMMV

Steve

Re: Shear Scraping..

#5

Re: P.S. Bowl gouges are round

john lucas

>I have to disagree somewhat. I sharpen my scrapers at 45 degrees and raise a burr with my diamond hones. I can get a much more controlled cut with this than the bowl gouge. Partly because I can control the angle better. On the bowl gouge it's very hard to get a shear scraper right next to the foot, for example, with the proper angle. I can get in there with my smaller flat scraper.

With either tool on an 8 or 10" bowl you are only using a very small portion of the edge to do the scraping,what would you guess, 1/4" or less.

I do agree with the thickness being a factor. The John Jordan scraper isn't that thick but has a lot of width that adds to the mass. I have to take a much more controlled shaving with my 1/2" flat scraper that is only 1/4" thick. This is on the outside obviously.

Re: Shear Scraping..

#6

Steven Antonucci

Never had an access issue?

steve antonucci

>Might be because the jaws I am using provide me with the proper clearance, but I can shear scrap right up to where the tenon seats? I'm having a difficult time picturing what you mean by this?

Worst case scenario, I would switch to a smaller bowl gouge. You are correct that the contact point is very small, so the thinner gouge still doesn't really vibrate all that much if you are doing it right. For extreme cases, I have used a detail gouge. After all, the wood just sees a cutting edge and nothing behind it...

Steve

Re: Shear Scraping..

#7

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Never had an access issue?

Lyle Jamieson

>I use the bowl gouge for almost all my sheer scraping too. A little trick for you. On hollow forms access is an issue. To get down under the bottom the bowl gouge wont reach and keep the sheer angle. So JJs sheer scraper works much better than the bowl gouge. We must keep the sheering action with the downhill grain, which is from large diameter to small diameter for end grain hollow forms. On the other end, around the mouth opening, the bed gets in the way. I still use the bowl gouge here but I use an old one with no handle. Again go downhill to the grain and the bed is no longer an obstacle. Lyle

Re: Shear Scraping..

#8

Re: Never had an access issue?

john lucas

>Steve I'm talking about the angle more than access. It's hard sometimes to get the bowl gouge at about 45 degrees so I end up scraping with the tool flatter which doesn't cut as clean.

Re: Shear Scraping..

#9

Steven Antonucci

3/8" gouge on a 12" bowl with a 1/4" tenon

steve antonucci

>Sorry for the lousy picture, but I just threw the only bowl I had with a tenon still on it in the shop against the lathe to shoot this. The tenon is about 1/4", the toolrest is probably 2-3" below center, and I can run all of the way up to the jaws with a 3/8" swept back bowl gouge.

Can you stage a picture that shows me the tool and where it might be necessary? I must need a nap, cause it just isn't getting through to me?

Thank

Steven


img

Re: Shear Scraping..

#10

Re: 3/8" gouge on a 12" bowl with a 1/4" tenon

john lucas

>Steve I'd love to but won't have time until at least Friday. Too many demands on my time.

Re: Shear Scraping..

#11

Re: Shear Scraping..

robo hippy

>Silly me, I have never been able to get a good shear scrape with a gouge. A scraper works far better in my hands, after all it is a scraper. As far as size, I like the bigger is better theory. I use a 1 1/4 or 1 1/2 inch wide by 3/8 thick scraper, with the swept back design. Raise a good burr from the grinder, and set the scraper at a 45 degree angle, and take the finest of cuts. Gets just as good of a finish as any gouge. Access has never been a problem for me. I turn green to final thickness so the finish cuts are done before I reverse the bowl, but there are inside and outside scrapers. I also like to hold my tools level, and keep the handle under my forearm. Better tool control for me, and a better, stronger position if I have a catch. To get the shear scrape with a gouge, the tool is held pointing up, and I have more tool hanging out over the tool rest, so the cut isn't as steady as it is with a scraper held flat, and no more than an inch out over the tool rest. Technically, a shear cut isn't a scraping cut. You can shear cut and scrape cut with all tools (skews, gouges, and scrapers), the difference is in the tool cutting edge angle.

robo hippy

Re: Shear Scraping..

#12

What do you mean by "upside down"?

James McClure

>

Re: Shear Scraping..

#13

Steven Antonucci

See my picture below

steve antonucci

>

Re: Shear Scraping..

#14

Re: Shear Scraping..

PAUL FOWLER

>Re; Shear/Scraping, Is not this an oxymoron?

As I understand it, you are using gouge at High angle but the tool is still using shearcut. My apoligies, I have many years with metal turning. Not sure if green or dry makes much difference.

I use high relief tools on plastics and wood on my metal lathe, the effort can be felt whether rubbing, shearing, or scraping.