Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

turning tools

Posts

turning tools

#1

turning tools

ponch

>I am a new turner, looking to purcahase tools. anyone using Crown tools? Looks like a good product for the price. would like to hear input on these tools or any others. Thanks

Re: turning tools

#2

Re: turning tools *LINK*

John K Jordan

>I have some Crown tools, as well as Sorby and others, even some older Craftsman. The Crown are excellent, but the others are great too. I think tools from nearly any manufacturer, as long as they are made of good materials such as HSS or better, will work fine.

The current trend among woodturners is to purchase Thompson turning tools. I just got some of these yesterday and have only turned a few samples, but they appear to be very well made and well worth the money. Several people with extensive experience with them like them very well and say they seem to stay sharp longer than other tools. They come without handles so if you make your own handles they can be really quite economical.

JKJ


Thompson Lathe Tools

Re: turning tools

#3

Re: turning tools

Cyril Griesbach

>Crown makes very nice tools as do most of the makers of HHS turning tools. I've heard that the Benjamen's Best are quite good and very reasonable but I have no experience with them. I have several of the Thompson tools and think they are as good as any and better than most. They are now my "go to" tools. The web site above will give you all the info you want and if you don't like them Doug will buy them back from you. Nobody else does that!

Re: turning tools

#4

Richard Allen

Re: turning tools *LINK*

Richard Allen

>The best tools for the money are the Chinese made tools like the ones sold by Penn State. For someone starting out these tools work as well as any other tools. In time you will likely benefit from other brands.


Benjamin's Best

Re: turning tools

#5

Re: turning tools

Joe Pack

>The HSS Harbor Freight tools are just fine for a beginning set. You can buy the set on sale for $40 most of the time. They also have a smaller (in size) set for smaller turnings for about $20 on sale. I have a mixture of Crown, Sorby and Harbor Freight tools. I just used the 3/4" Harbor Freight gouge to turn 50 bracelet helpers. All were essentially straight line with a few "contour" cuts to break up the line. I only picked up a different gouge a dozen or so times, that being to fine tune an end from time to time. I don't use the 3/4" gouge on everything, but this was essentially "no worries" turning, hogging off corners quickly, then smoothing. I just use this as an example of choosing to use the cheaper HF tool instead of the more expensive ones and getting the job done just fine.

As important as the tools is a good sharpening system. I highly recommend the Wolverine system paired with an 8" grinder (slow speed if you are buying new...check Woodcraft). Kept sharp, the HF tools will do just fine. Less expensive tools kept sharp can do the job for you. The MOST expensive tools left dull will be useless.

Re: turning tools

#6

Re: turning tools

David Walser

>Here's a link to the HF set discussed by Jim, above. Better HF set. Another set, almost as good: Lesser HF set

One of the reasons to go with a "cheap" starter set is that you will need to learn how to sharpen your tools. Even with a jig and a slow speed grinder, learning how to sharpen can take some time. With a cheap tool, it doesn't cost nearly as much to practice sharpening. Once you are confident in your sharpening skills, you might want to invest in some name brand tools.

In addition to the HF starter set, you'll want a bowl gouge (1/2" shank or 3/8" shank size are good choices for your first bowl gouge) if you plan on turning bowls. You might also want to get a "thin" parting tool. A thin parting tool is great for boxes. It also comes in handy in a lot of situations.

Good luck!

Re: turning tools

#7

Re: turning tools

Don Orr

>You have received some very good info so far that I agree with. To answer your original question, I use and like the Crown tools very much especially the Crown Pro-PM line (NOT cheap). The HF tools will do what the others have said very well. One drawback is they do not have what most of us consider a normal/standard/usual cross sectional profile, and therefore act and sharpen somewhat differently than a standard Crown gouge. Probably not a big deal really. When you have learned to turn and sharpen, the Thompson tools are truly outstanding and exceptional. You can cut wood with just about any sharp piece of steel, but some tools make specific tasks easier and more pleasant.

Good luck and have fun.

Re: turning tools

#8

Re: turning tools

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>The most important tool to buy is a sharpening system... Oneway has the Wolverine and vari-grind then go to Woodcraft and buy the 8 inch slow speed grinder which is always on sale.

Get your basic set and learn to sharpen then buy tools when you see a need... most professionals only use a few tools 90% of the time. It would help if you could find a local turner in your area, the AAW has clubs in every state.

Re: turning tools

#9

Re: turning tools

keith zimmerman, Normal, IL

>I don't think the brand of tool you start with is as important as using it sharp. Any tool will cut wood if it is sharp. One thing you might do is to get some cheap tools and learn to sharpen them, then spend your money on pricier, higher quality tools.

My first tools were carbon steel, some of which I still use. I bought them second hand and actually turned my first bowl with them. I also learned how to sharpen with them. Then, I bought my first HSS Sorby bowl gouge. The only reason I bought Sorby is because that is what the store carried.

keithz