Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

OT - LCD TV Question

Posts

OT - LCD TV Question

#1

OT - LCD TV Question

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Greetings all

Last Thursday a lightning storm fried several of our electrical components, one of them being a TV. SWMBO and I are thinking of replacing it with an LCD to make some more room in our living room. I am going back and forth between a 32" and a 37" TV right now. I have already decided on the brand, so that is not an issue. I am just wondering if anyone has any sage advice on determining a size. I would like a big one, but I don't want to feel like I am in the first row at the movies either. Our current TV is a 27" conventional screen model. While it is adequate for viewing across the short side of the LR, we are going to change things around and put the TV at one end of the longer side - not that it is that much longer, but it is a little.

Any thoughts are appreciated.

Bill

Re: OT - LCD TV Question

#2

Re: OT - LCD TV Question

Barry Turner

>I bought a 42" Panasonic plasma a couple of years ago. It was on sale for $1000. It has a great picture and I was expecting to spend 2 1/2 times that much to upgrade. Go a little larger. I have never heard anyone say they should have bought a smaller TV, lathe, car, truck, etc. :-) Barry

Re: OT - LCD TV Question

#3

Re: OT - LCD TV Question

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ont

>I would not look at anything smaller than the 37 Bill.

I am about to buy a replacement TV as well, I was tossing around 42-47.....I am going 47" for sure after seeing a few in some neighbours homes.. some of the smaller TV's have less features than their bigger sisters.

Take care,

Jim

Re: OT - LCD TV Question

#4

Re: OT - LCD TV Question

WayneLeach - NW Ont

>Bill,

You will love LCD TV.

Do not worry about the size as you will really enjoy bigger.

We got a Sharp Aquos 46" and view from 8-10' and it is fabulous. Even without hi-def the picture is stunning!!!

I never watched much TV until we got this one and now when watching sports its like being right there!

So, 37" should be the better choice or even 42"!

Wayne

Re: OT - LCD TV Question

#5

Re: OT - LCD TV Question

Bill Clark

>Bill, you might want to think about adding a combination surge and electrical line filter protector to your purchase. You don't want to fry your new TV if this happens again. Don't buy a Harbor Freight quality unit. Get a good one and you'll be glad you did.

Re: OT - LCD TV Question

#6

Re: OT - LCD TV Question

Gordon Seto

>Bill,

One thing you also have to consider is with the new wide screen format. For the same size (measuring the screen diagonally), the new screen is shorter.

If you do a Google on "determine TV screen size", you will find a lot of suggestions.

Re: OT - LCD TV Question

#7

Re: OT - LCD TV Question

Ian

>Bill,

when I was 20 I couln't see any reason for anything bigger than a 19"tv, when I was 30 a 25" was needed to read the words on the screen.

Now that I i'm 48 the living room has a 37" reading the words is just fine.

what I'm saying go for the larger screen without overpowering the room, it will be easier on the eyes that ain't getting any younger.

IAN

Re: OT - LCD TV Question

#8

Re: OT - LCD TV Question

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>Bill,

We have a 32 in LCD the bedroom which is fine for viewing 6-10 feet away. For the living room or TV room go big...

The picture on a LCD is amazing.

Re: OT - LCD TV Question

#9

Re: OT - LCD TV Question

John K Jordan

>Are you looking at a widescreen model?

Something to keep in mind when considering screen size: the newer wide screens which fit the HD and movie aspect ratios will waste some space on the sides when watching normal TV programs or video tapes unless you stretch and distort the normal 4:3 aspect ratio pictures to fill the screen. Due to this, a 16:9 widescreen which measures 32" diagonally will give you about the same size image as a 26" normal screen.

BTW, while surge protection is a good idea, there is no practical device that can insure complete protection from a lighting strike. Two things work well - unplugging during a storm, and insurance.

JKJ


img

Re: OT - LCD TV Question

#10

Ric Taylor

Re: OT - LCD TV Question

Ric Taylor

>Bill,

When I was shopping for my big screen, spent a lot of time measuring and imagining what the TV would look like in the room. I went for a larger size but I was very nervous that I had made a mistake and gone too big. When it was delivered and installed, it was perfect.

Go for the big one, you won't be disappointed.

Ric

Re: OT - LCD TV Question

#11

Re: OT - LCD TV Question

wilbur

>Hi Bill,

I'm actually going through the same process, as my 13+ year old 27" TV is really starting to lose its brightness. There are two things to consider.

First, it's really hard to go from a larger screen size to a smaller screen size. With a 27" standard screen, going to a 32" HDTV screen means that your screen height actually gets smaller, as John pointed out. A 34" HDTV screen would be the same vertical height as your present TV. Going to a 37" screen will be bigger in all aspects, which is nice.

Second, there's a rule of thumb for HDTVs with the new widescreen aspect that you should sit about 1.5-3 times the distance of the diagonal of the screen. So if you are reconfiguring your room, you may want to work backwards. Figure out how far people will be sitting from the TV in the new room layout, divide by 1.5 or 3, and look for a screen in that size. For example, if the couch is going to be 10 feet (120") from the new TV position, you'll be looking for a 40"-80"(!) screen.

So now all you have to do is get your DVDs remastered in widescreen format and put them out on Blu-ray. :@)

Re: OT - LCD TV Question

#12

Re: OT - LCD TV Question

Scott Hurley in N. VA

>You can't go wrong with a Sony or a Sharp. I have one of each, and they are equally good.

Scott

Re: OT - LCD TV Question

#13

Re: OT - LCD TV Question

Texian

>Too small. Go 42. A big guy needs a big TV. You will be disappointed with 37.

Re: OT - LCD TV Question

#14

Re: OT - LCD TV Question

Jose Klipstein -Cleveland OH

>Have you ever heard any one say "My TV is too big .... I wish I would have bought a smaller one"?

Re: OT - LCD TV Question

#15

Re: OT - LCD TV Question

Charlie Anderson

>I sit 14' from my tv. When I brought a 52" home it seemed so big. But guess what? I sure am enjoying it!

Even though you don't care, I got a sony xbr4 which is being closed out with the new model coming soon.

Re: OT - LCD TV Question

#16

Re: OT - LCD TV Question

Jerry Whitaker

>Bill, I have been researching LCD TV's recently. You can go to Best Buy, Circuit City, Conn's etc and view their TV's at different distances. Locally, our stores have a living room setting where you can plop down and look and think. If you are viewing at 10 to 12 feet away, a 42 inch is NOT too big. If you are viewing at a longer distance, you might want to consider one up in the 50-52 in. range. The more HDMI ports the better. Makes it easier to hook up a variety of accessories. You said you have settled on a brand. Anyway, my opinion is that Sony, Samsung, Toshiba, and Sharp are the best and in that order. Like I said....."My OPINION". For anyone who might be looking for a new DVD player...wait awhile if you can until the new Blue Ray player/recorders go down a little in price. This format is stunning....it will knock your socks off!

Re: OT - LCD TV Question

#17

Re: OT - LCD TV Question

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Thanks for the responses everyone. I appreciate the thoughts, opinions, and sources. I know all about surge protectors, which is why we pull plugs out when a storm is coming. This particular storm came up quickly though, and we only got the computers unplugged before the bolt that got us.

Max viewing distance is going to be around 8 feet, and that will be intermittent - i.e. on extremely rare occasions when we have people over to watch TV, which is almost never. When we have company we talk. I've got a few more things to research which are peculiar to my situation. If we go with Best Buy, they offer installation, but I would hazard a guess that most of the Dork Squad members have not encountered a wall of fieldstone as the mounting surface. ;-)

Re: OT - LCD TV Question

#18

Re: Bill- I'm not clear about your ....

Jamie Donaldson

>...viewing room configuration, but remember that the viewing angles on LCD's are much more narrow than plasma screens. I went from 27"CRT to 42"plasma (Panasonic-top rated by Consumer Reports) 2yrs. ago and love it! However, LCD's are only a fraction of the weight of a plasma, so hanging it on a stone wall would favor the LCD for ease of installation in a narrow room with adequate seating pattern. Don't consider anything less than 42" if you have the space- it broadens your horizons!

Re: OT - LCD TV Question

#19

Re: OT - LCD TV Question

Tony - Memphis

>I just did that. Our old TV was a 26" I think. Our issue was that all of the tv shows were in the new format and on our tv, they were 13" tall! Our requirement was that the tv fit in our existing cabinet. We really don't watch tv much and don't want to look at it when its not on. We got a Sharp 37". Almost had enough room for a 40", but were short about 1/2". I've been real happy with the size. Also, since we don't have cable, getting a tv with a digital tuner made a huge difference because we now get the digital channels through our attic antenna. So, our viewing quality when up tenfold. But, just based on size, I am real happy with the 37". I watch tv from the breakfast room 25' away and I can see it just fine. Doesn't seem too overpowering from 8'-10' away either. Still can't say it was worht the money. TV just isn't that important to us.

Tony

Re: OT - LCD TV Question

#20

Dick Hines

Re: OT - LCD TV Question

Dick Hines

>Bill, just remember, size does count. I don't watch much TV but if I did I would get the biggest one my wall would hold. Just remember you have to hang it so you wouldn't pull your wall in to the room.

Re: OT - LCD TV Question

#21

Hanging TV on the wall

wilbur

>One other issue to consider is that if you put the TV on the wall, you are effectively moving your seating location about a foot or so farther back than you would if the TV was sitting on a TV stand, which would increase the size of the TV you should be considering.

You could put a flat screen TV on a low stand. Many models or available, or you could just build one. However, that would involve flatwork. :@)

Re: OT - LCD TV Question

#22

Re: OT - LCD TV Question

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Okay, I spent some time at the store, and here is what I have decided. I am buying a 42" plasma. The picture was a lot brighter overall, and especially from the sides. It will fit in either place, but that is going to be a judgment call on the part of SWMBO. Even if I put it where the old TV is now, we will still gain about 22" of space in the living room. It is a small house, built well before the advent of electricity, much less TV. I measured, and the longest sight line with a wall mount is nine feet.

I will have to do some flat work (Wilbur). I am already on the list for two tables, and now I have to build a stand to hold the rest of the components and all the DVDs, plus those old fashioned VHS tapes. I won't have any time to watch the thing - not that there is that much on, but I do love my movies. ;-)

Re: OT - LCD TV Question

#23

Looked At Plasma, then

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Saw the Samsung "71" and "81" series LCDs. Kicked the visual ass of every plasma in either Best Buy of Circuit City. The difference was truly striking.

SWMBO [Go Devils!!] now has a 50" 71 series Samsung which is outrageous. Hooked up to a true HD source (hd-dvd or blue ray), the aerial scenes will almost give you vertigo.

I moved the "old" Sony HD DLP 60" to the play room.

Re: OT - LCD TV Question

#24

Re: OT - LCD TV Question

Bill Leathers

>Bill , you mentioned that brand wasn't a major factor in your decision but it could be if the flat screen dies.Stick with the major brandssuch as Magnavox, Sony, Toshiba ,Panasonic ,Sanyo. Lesser known brands may not have available parts even in the warranty period. You'll find the plasma puts out a fair amount of heat(good on a winter's day), so don't obstruct the ventilation and don't hang over a fireplace. This would shorten the life of the electrolytic capacitors inside the plasma TV. Just my 2 cents and then again I have seen LCD's with bulging capacitors as well. Bill Leathers

Re: OT - LCD TV Question

#25

Re: OT - LCD TV Question

Jeff Rich

>Hi Bill,

I bet you are right!

I come across all kinds of wall surfaces in my "pro" life.

If you are hanging the TV, a ceiling mount option maybe what you need.

Make sure to get a beefy mount like Peerless or Mustang.

As for size, that is really a personal preference.

Room size and viewing distance have a lot to do with projection screens.

For example, a 37 to 40" would be perfect for my space as I have a small living room of 13x17. The difference between LCD and plasma are another matter....on LCDs response time and brightness have an effect on picture quality. Plasmas look more like the older TVs.

I have not started shopping for my TV yet.

Another thing to look for is a Clear QAM tuner, this will allow you to pull in the digital cable signals, if you have cable. By FCC mandate, if the unit has a tuner, it will be able to receive th off air digital signals. So there is a little bit more to think about.