Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

best darn bandsaw available?

Posts

best darn bandsaw available?

#1

best darn bandsaw available?

John K Jordan

>Oh wise ones,

I'm getting tired of my bandsaw, a 14" Delta with riser.

It's been good to me over the years and I've squeezed incredible performance from the poor little thing, from resawing 2x12s to processing huge amounts of green wood from log sections. But I can't get the blade tension I'd like to see (according to my Starrett tension gauge) without feeling I'm about to stress the bandsaw itself over some limit. In addition, I've done everything I could to align the saw properly but there are still compromises evidently due to manufacturing tolerances.

What's the best darn bandsaw available at any price, and the best at reasonable cost (say under $2000)? I'm especially interested in experiences of someone who has owned several bandsaws and cried "This is it!" out loud when they finally found the right one.

A 12" resaw capacity is sufficient for my use. I'm not prepared to accommodate one so big it needs a rigging crew to install, an electrical transformer upgrade, and a wing added onto the shop. (I used one of those at Berea College years ago - they told me it had a 25' blade.)

JKJ

Re: best darn bandsaw available?

#2

Keith Tompkins

Re: best darn bandsaw available?

keith tompkins

>HI John, My dream choice for a new saw would be the General 20" bandsaw. The entire base is cast iron, as is the rest of the machine. Many would argue this, but I prefer cast iron in a bandsaw. I use one extensively, Brookfield Craft Center, where I teach, has one in the turning shop. It is a strong, powerful saw, beautifully constructed. It would match my General lathe perfectly. :)

If I could find a used Oliver saw in decent shape, I'd purchase it and restore it rather than buy new...I love restoring old iron. The Powermatic 20" is a well-made saw, but has a steel frame. For the money a Grizzley bandsaw is better than expected.

Re: best darn bandsaw available?

#3

Re: best darn bandsaw available?

DavidWalser

>John,

There are several good bandsaws -- of much more modern design than your old Delta. One that consistently receives top or near-the-top honors in magazine reviews is the Rikon. The 14" Rikon has a 13" resaw capacity and just over 13.5" rip capacity, for just under $900 (plus freight). The 18" Rikon costs close to $1,400 and has an inch less resaw capacity and just over 18" of rip capacity. Here's a link to CSUSA's page: Rikon bandsaws

Of course, many believe the Laguna bandsaws to be the cat's meow. They're more money. Laguna Bandsaws

Re: best darn bandsaw available?

#4

Re: best darn bandsaw available? *LINK*

Ed Moore in SW Virginia

>John,

I bought a 21" Northstate from LeNeave in Charlotte, North Carolina, a few years ago and it is one great saw for a reasonable price. I paid about $1100 around four years ago. Obviously steel prices will have driven the price up, but LeNeave is a great bunch to work with. I recommend this saw and the LeNeave group. The 21" has a three horsepower motor and it is a workhorse.

A friend with an expensive Laguna has used my saw. He likes this Northstate MUCH better.

This saw was made in Taiwan and I found the workmanship to be better than on saws that are similar in appearance, such as a Grizzly.

See you soon,

Ed


LeNeave Northstate saw

Re: best darn bandsaw available?

#5

Let's up the price- what do you think is best.

john lucas

>One of my good friends called last night is wanting a good bandsaw. This guy likes to buy the best, he started turning, took a couple of classes and then drove to Canada to pick up a Oneway 2436. That's the kind of guy we're talking about. So hit me with your recommendations and I'll pass them on. He's been looking at the Laguna and Minmax. We are thinking about going to the IWF in Atlanta to check out the big stuff.

Re: best darn bandsaw available?

#6

Re: best darn bandsaw available? Link

Mark Trulock

>John

I love my Jet 14" bandsaw, but if you want to go large check the tool section at Fine Woodworking: http://www.taunton.com/finewoodworking/ToolGuide/ToolguideDirectory.aspx?dir=Bandsaws&subdir=18-in.+Bandsaws

See what the experts think.

Good luck

Mark

Re: best darn bandsaw available?

#7

Re: best darn bandsaw available? *LINK*

DickL

>Well, if price is not a consideration, I would pick one of these. Had a chance to use one a few years ago - talk about smooth running.


Northfield Band Saw

Re: best darn bandsaw available?

#8

Re: Bandsaw considerations for a .....

Jamie Donaldson

>... woodturner and wet wood are different from other woodworker users. Several years ago I replaced my old Delta, including riser block, Carter tension release and a host of other upgrades, with a MiniMax S45, and love the additional power! However, any saw with roller guides is going to become encrusted with sap/gunk and bind the rollers/blade, and I would love to have my old Cool blocks back. I tried a Laguna with the ceramic guides, but it screeches like banshees with the guides against the moving blade. I have found no retrofit is possible, and have to scrape the blades and rollers frequently when sawing sappy wood.

Re: best darn bandsaw available?

#9

John, in the 3 HP range ...

Ed Moore in SW Virginia

>I would choose the NorthState/LeNeave over any other bandsaw. That includes Minimax and Laguna, which IMHO are over-rated and over-priced.

See you in a week and a half?

Ed

Re: best darn bandsaw available?

#10

Check the Colour Combination First

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ont

>Hi,

I have a General 490, it's been awesome for me, the only limitation has been the resaw, with a cast body I can not add a riser. If I had to by it again I would, but with the model that has a 12" resaw .....

A friend of mine bought the Steel City BS, looks great, ran well, but he fried the switch in less than 6 months of use, got great customer service and had a replacement quickly.

I have looked at the Laguna's etc.....wrong colour, too much $

If I had to, I'd buy the Jet with a riser, but I used to be friend with some one who was always replacing bearings on it

Take care,

Jim

Re: best darn bandsaw available?

#11

Re: best darn bandsaw available?

robo hippy

>I have had the Laguna 16HD for almost 3 years now, and love it. Of course, if it was my company there are a lot of things I would redesign. I like the cutting height (16 inches) and the hp (4.5). This is plenty for resawing wet bowl blanks to that height. No screaching from the ceramic blocks for me. I set them like rollers, very close to the blade, but not on it. Second best Christmas present I ever bought myself. Of course, the best was my lathe, first an old Atlas, then a PM, now a Robust.

robo hippy

Re: best darn bandsaw available?

#12

Re: Bandsaw considerations for a .....

robert davis

>i make guides from white oak. the last a long time. when they wear rotate 180 degrees. next time squsre up on disc sander. some other woods would be even more durable.of course the run tight to the blade

Re: best darn bandsaw available?

#13

JL

Re: best darn bandsaw available?

JL

>I have a Rikon 18". I like it, but I want a better fence one day. My friend Mike bought a Steel City 16" - it is very impressive - runs like a champ. I've seen the Steel City 18" - at $1,450 - that's in your ball park. The Steel City 20" is also very nice - that runs $1960 at Redmond.

Of course you can go with the Laguna or the Minmax and be very happy.

Re: best darn bandsaw available?

#14

Driving to Canada?

Martin from Granbury

>John,

If I can afford one, I would like to buy a Oneway lathe in the next year or so. I am looking seriously at their 1640 model. Can you tell me why your friend drove to Canada to get his? Did he save on shipping? price? taxes? or was it merely speed of delivery?

Just looking for a good reason to drive from Texas to Canada to pick up my lathe, or a reason not to.

Thanks,

Martin

Re: best darn bandsaw available?

#15

Re: best darn bandsaw available?

Russ Fairfield

>There is no such thing as the "best darn bandsaw, period". Looking for a saw that will make precision cuts in dry wood while having the capacity to saw large bowl blanks in green wood, is asking too much. We can configure the saw towards one extreme or the other. Trying to do both with the same bandsaw will always sacrifice the precision cuts.

If you need to do both, I would suggest keeping the Delta for the precision sawing and getting a bigger saw for the heavy-duty work. It needs a large table, and a lot of horsepower. What it doesn't need is precision. There are a lot of them available at a reasonable price.

Set up the Delta for the precision sawing by removing the riser block, installing a new set of tires, replace the tension spring, cut up some use Maple or buy CoolBlocks for it, and never run it with a blade wider than 3/8". It will run like a new saw.

Re: best darn bandsaw available?

#16

Re: best darn bandsaw available?

bill Crommett

>I have a Laguna 18 which is adequet but like every tool it needed some tweeking. I have two other bandsaws: A Gillium kit saw I made in the 50 s and a second hand Montgomery Ward that takes a 96 inch blade, which I use for pecission stuff. The Laguna runs a 150 inch blade and is equipped with a half inch 4 tooth blade for wet timbers and rough chopping. I have no need to upgrade anything, and Russ is right again.

Re: best darn bandsaw available?

#17

Re: best darn bandsaw available?

steve worcester

>I had a Delta with riser, then a Laguna 16HD, now a Laguna 24. The version I bought at the time was a custom to 24" of resaw, and yes I have used every inch of it. They are available now in a 24" with 24" resaw stock. Good saw though and I don't agree that you can't cut precision (dry resawing for veneers,etc, and wet wood), just change the blade.

http://www.turningwood.com/moab.htm

Re: best darn bandsaw available?

#18

Keith Tompkins

Re: best darn bandsaw available?

keith tompkins

>HI David, The one concern I have for the Rikon is that the support for the table does not appear to be substantial enough for heavy useage. It appears to be a thin aluminum casting on all models. To be fair, I haven't heard of any failures, for the money, I'm sure it's fine. I use several Northfield products at work, including a massive sliding table saw, 16" jointer, and double-spindle shaper. This is massive industrial equipment, all three phase 440 volt.

Re: best darn bandsaw available?

#19

and you can do all of this for less than $2000

Russ Fairfield

>You said that was your budget number.

Re: best darn bandsaw available?

#20

Re:

Jerry Hall

>I have a five year old Laguna HD16. I have used a MM16. Both great saws. Today I would give the MM16 a long look. Both offer fine customer service, parts, and have a large user base. Important to me.

Here is a good, and accurate discussion that makes points I agree with:

http://www.sawmillcreek.org/showthread.php?t=45339

And here is an article on Wood Central on the MM16:

http://www.woodcentral.com/bparticles/mm16bs.pdf

I think the Laguna ceramic guides are a slick idea, but the sparks it produces are unnerving and do wear and on balance the Euroguides do the job well. If veneers are your thing the ceramic guides might be worth another look.

MM16 $2,395 and specs here:

http://www.minimax-usa.com/index.php?page=shop.product_details&flypage=flypage.tpl&product_id=18&category_id=1&option=com_virtuemart&Itemid=36

Laguna $2,995 and specs here:

http://www.lagunatools.com/bandsaw.lt16hd.htm

Note MM16 is heavier.

For working blanks for woodturning both these saws are overkill. But they sure are nice! The healthy horsepower/amps does make it very nice to work big blanks, and should be a consideration in any purchase.

Re: best darn bandsaw available?

#21

Re: best darn bandsaw available?

John K Jordan

>>...If you need to do both, I would suggest

>keeping the Delta for the precision sawing and

>getting a bigger saw for the heavy-duty work.

That was my plan. The Delta has been a great saw, especially after I replaced the tension spring and tensioner arm, installed CoolBlocks, added a Carter quick tensioner arm, and did a coplanar alignment. (and I usually prefer a 3/8" blade.) It runs great and cuts smoothly and precisely with smaller, and especially drier, stock. But I feel like I'm pushing it's design limit and a larger saw with a sturdier frame could better tension a larger blade for sawing thicker stock.

This thread has given me lots of good ideas for research.

JKJ

Re: best darn bandsaw available?

#22

Re:

John Scheideman

>I replaced my old Delta/Rockwell with riser block and got a MiniMax 16 about four years ago. I love it. It cuts accurately with dry stock and also handles big bowl blanks with ease. It is slightly more than your budget but I'd consider it anyway. As stated by others, you need to change blades and reset everything to get accurate cuts depending on what you want to do....cutting bowl blanks is going to be a different setup than cutting dry flat hardwood. But that is true of any saw. The customer service from MiniMax is the best you will find anywhere. I haven't been sorry I made the MM purchase.

John