Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Dust Collection - Need Advice!

Posts

Dust Collection - Need Advice!

#1

Dust Collection - Need Advice!

Christine

>I am a new woodturner in need of a dust collector when sanding on my lathe. I have limited space as most of us do and need a small, portable footprint. Also, keeping cost down is a priority as well. I'm unsure if the canister or a bag is better in a dust collection system. How often does the canister filter and/or bag need to be replaced? I don't have a 220 connection so am limited to 1 to 1.5 horsepower machine. Any advice or suggestions would be greatly appreciated. Thanks.

Christine

Re: Dust Collection - Need Advice!

#2

Re: Dust Collection - Need Advice!

Stuart Johnson

>I might be misunderstanding you but in my mind a dust collector is used for the heavy stuff and is attached to machines like a saw, planer, jointer and so forth. For sanding I use a box fan with a furnace filter. It captures a good portion of the dust. I have a dust collector but in my mind it is so loud it destroys the turning enjoyment. I do plan on building an air cleaner using a furnace squirrel cage at some point that will stand behind the lathe.

Re: Dust Collection - Need Advice!

#3

JL

Re: Dust Collection - Need Advice!

JL

>I used to use a 1.5 hp double bagger (top and bottom) for collecting sanding dust and small stuff. I now have a 2 hp cyclone. If you are limited in space, any good 1 hp unit will collect the vast majority of the sanding dust.

A canister provides cleaner return air. The bags have maybe a 5-10 micron particle size pass through until they get caked up - then they filter out more fines. If you choose to go for a "shaker felt" bag, they are good for 1-3 micron particle size when caked. The canister filter will have to be replaced more often. You do have to gently blow the canister out every so often (every couple of changes). The bags last for years - do NOT clean them, just dump them.

My $0.02.

Re: Dust Collection - Need Advice!

#4

Re: Dust Collection - Need Advice!

Chip in Plano

>I feel your pain or I guess my wife does. Fine particles everywhere. I posed this question early on, too. I believe the answer is there is no one solution. I have a ceiling air cleaner unit but it was > $200. It does a good job. It'd do a better job if I turned it around so the intake side pulled from the direction my lathe is spewing fine dust. But it won't get all the fine dust we generate sanding but it'll get a lot. This and a air filtration mask will save my lungs.

I also have a dust collector but it's too far from my lathe and I keep buying turning supplies instead of another couple of 4" hoses. Then I would have to make a jig to mount it close to my spindle. It is loud but I tolerate it plus I have headphones I could use just when sanding. What stops me dead from using it is the lack of a micro/micron particle bag which makes it useless for the fine particles. Plus changing my DC's bags are a PITA so I rarely use it to pickup my turning chips. I pay my kids to sweep & bag them (LOL).

I also have a shop vac but it's 17 yrs old and is a real screamer so it's never used. I'm more likely to get a new shopvac with a muffler and use it when sanding to trap the fine particles.

1) The bags are easier to change and cheaper

2) even my wife hates my shopvac

3) it's portable

4) it's 110hz although I'm out of plugins but I have an extension cord.

That's my perspective.

Re: Dust Collection - Need Advice!

#5

Re: Dust Collection - Need Advice!

Fog Tanner

>There are quite a few posts about dust and dust collection if you search through the archives. This is always a hot topic as it is something you have to live with.

I have a 1.5hp bag unit which does an excellent job of making noise and move the dust from one place to another - very little in actually collecting it. I bought it for some hand sanding to keep the dust out of my face. For real dust collection I have a 2hp cyclone unit and a lot of metal ducting. This is the one I use when turning and all the other machines that make dust.

A good cyclone unit will filter down to the submicron level, that is the dust that does the damage to your lungs. The larger particles are stopped by your body, so if you dust system will not work in the submicron level you are wasting money. Same with respirators.

The overhead units, can filter out some dust if it happens to float by, but most don't have the airflow or filter size to do much - other than seperate you from your money. They are also in the wrong place, you want a pickup close to where you are making dust and not after it is past your face. Another reason for wearing a respirator too, since your face is like to be closer than any pickup.

When turning, I run the cyclone unit unless it is really green wood (i.e wet). You can get more dust off a gouge than you do when sanding, so it pays to run it all the time. Along with that I wear an Airstream all the time, whether its green of dry. Both are submicron level filtering devices and my lungs and allergies are happy so far.

As far as the sound ruining the turning experience, the sound of coughing and hacking lungs takes away a lot more from the experience. I can still hear my rock and roll over the cyclone unit and I am only about 10-12 feet away from the impeller exhaust.

Do a search for other posts on this subject, there is a lot of information to be had there. Good luck with saving your lungs, better to start while you are new than to wait till it too late..

Fog

Re: Dust Collection - Need Advice!

#6

Re: Dust Collection - Need Advice!

galen V

>Just started turning as well and until I can get something better the 20" box fan and allergen filter really does draw more dust away than I expected. Had the fan and a $9 filter is better than nothing for my lungs. I do use the cheap disposable mask for now as an old canister resperator I have is to bulky and hot. My fan just hangs on chains right down as close as I can live with and not be in the way of turning.

If you have a normal home 100 amp or so electrical panel then you can get to and wire for 220 single phase for a bigger motor so you may not be limited as you think. A new double breaker, wire, conduit if run open and a 220 oulet and box to put it in is not a big expense. Even when I needed at a remote shed I ran all the line and the REC connected to meter box for free.

Re: Dust Collection - Need Advice!

#7

Re: Dust Collection - Need Advice!

Darryl

>Christine, first and foremost I hope you have some sort of mask. A powered face mask like the 3m Airstream or the Trend-Pro Airshield are good for starters. the new Trend is reported to be good to 3 microns. A dust collector near the lathe is the next best thing for collection. Penn State has some good 110 V bag units. A 1.5 hp will do nicely. I have fashioned a "Big Scoop" plastic thingy on my lathe with a 30 gal garbage can for the first stage of the DC. It gets the big stuff and the bag gets down to less than 3 microns. The alount of dust that the DC picks up is amazing.

Re: Dust Collection - Need Advice!

#8

Re: Dust Collection - Need Advice!

David Propst

>I agree with Darryl, a small DC is fine for lathe DC unless you are turning really big stuff. I use a lathe dust hood attached to a Jet 650 1 HP DC with a homemade 30 gal trash can separator. I have shaker felt bags on the DC. When power sanding bowls this setup gets at least 95% of the dust. When turning pens, it also gets most of the shavings. The amount of dust collected is really amazing, especially the super fine dust in the felt bags.

I have the hood mounted to the lathe with adjustable 3/4" Loc-Line hose. It is very rigid and sturdy. I can get the hood as close as possible to the piece while sanding and can move it out of the way or reposition instantly.

This is a recycled post and pic from 2002. The hood pictured has since been replaced with a larger black DC hood, but the concept is the same. The silver flexible dryer hose links to the trash can separator and has held up very well.

Best Regards,

David


img

Re: Dust Collection - Need Advice!

#9

Re: Dust Collection - Need Advice!

Curly Smith

>You might consider two filters on your fan. A cheap filter on the intake side and your more expensive filter on the exhaust side. The cheap filter, that you'll change often, will catch most of the stuff and your more expensive filter will last longer. Or, you could stack the filters on the intake side.

Re: Dust Collection - Need Advice!

#10

Re: Dust Collection - Need Advice!

galen V

>What was I thinking! Even my furnace has the prefilter! For a whole $1 more it saves me trying to pick the bigger chips off the sticky fiber filter.

Thanks! I think I have been breathing too much dust!