Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

What to do with a Giant Red Oak Burl! *LINK*

Posts

What to do with a Giant Red Oak Burl! *LINK*

#1

What to do with a Giant Red Oak Burl! *LINK*

Claire

>I have been lurking on this forum for years now. I am a woodworker who has been bit by the turning bug, I have just started turning this past year. In Feb. I purchased a Jet 1642-2EVS on sale and have been slipping into a spinning vortex ever since.

2 days ago I got wind of an oak burl that was located nearby and my husband and I spent a few hours yesterday cutting it off the stump and moving it back to our house. It must weigh over 250 pounds!

Now that I have it, I have no idea how to proceed. The inside looks nothing like I thought it would. I expected to see tight swirling grain patterns. It also looks like some of it has been ruined by ant or some other insects.

The woman who gave us permission to take the burls also let us cut a smaller one off a standing tree. I have included pics of that also.

I could use some advice on what to do with this monster.

Thanks Claire


Red oak burls pictures

Re: What to do with a Giant Red Oak Burl! *LINK*

#2

Steven Antonucci

Some things that I do

steve antonucci

>Whenever I get a big piece of wood, I always set some aside for later. As I progress, I like to think that I will be able to produce better work in the future, so I resist the urge to be "done" with all of it.

Whatever you make, you will probably be forced to block it up to avoid it checking. If you've got bug tunnels in it, odds are there are still bugs in the wood too. It's a balancing act between leave it big vs. getting the bugs out. Whatever you freshly cut should be sealed (I use Anchorseal) to prevent checking.

Since it was so low to the ground, I think you'll probably be ok with metal. You found a rock, but there might be more, so use an old blade to cut it down and a metal detector as insurance. Nothing ruins "free wood" worse than hitting a nail on a new blade.

As far as what you should make out of it, that's really up to you to decide. Don't know what you like to make, nor what your capabilities are, but both of those should guide you to ultimate decision.

Good luck, and welcome aboard.

Steve

Re: What to do with a Giant Red Oak Burl! *LINK*

#3

Re: What to do with a Giant Red Oak Burl!

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>There are basically two types of burls. One has the traditional swirls and eyes. The other is called an onion burl because it is layered with growth rings like an onion. It is not unusual for an onion burl to come apart like an onion so be careful. The little I could see of the grain pattern in your burl leads me to think it is an onion burl.

I once made the mistake of harvesting a white oak burl. I really don't like white oak but thought maybe a burl would be ok. It was a solid onion burl. I roughed out one green bowl and gave the rest away. Even green it was the hardest wood I had ever turned.

IMHO red oak has more going for it. I have been told by someone whose opinion I respect that red oak burl is beautiful. Hopefully you will get some good figure and solid wood.

Re: What to do with a Giant Red Oak Burl! *LINK*

#4

Re: What to do with a Giant Red Oak Burl!

Claire

>Your description of an onion burl sounds like what I see. I will take caution when I decide what to do with it.

Thanks for the information!

Re: What to do with a Giant Red Oak Burl! *LINK*

#5

Re: What to do with a Giant Red Oak Burl!

Cyril Griesbach

>Claire, lots of good advice for you so far. I'm inclined to agree with Barbra on the onion burl possibilities of that larger section but it's also possible that parts of it may not be "onion". Most of the other cuts that show the inside also may not be "onion".

Another suggestion on the safety side of things...some chain saw chaps and work boots would be a wonderful gift for your husband as would a safety helmet.

Welcome to turning and looking forward to seeing what comes from these burls.

Re: What to do with a Giant Red Oak Burl! *LINK*

#6

Re: What to do with a Giant Red Oak Burl!

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>You are welcome.

Re: What to do with a Giant Red Oak Burl! *LINK*

#7

Re: What to do with a Giant Red Oak Burl!

Claire

>Thanks for voicing concern for my husband safety.

I'll let him know that it's not only me that thinks they are a good idea. I bought him a pair of chain saw chaps 20 years ago that still look brand new. It seems that he never thinks what ever he is going to work on is worth the effort of getting them out and on.

He did have steel toed boots on though.

Re: What to do with a Giant Red Oak Burl! *LINK*

#8

jim miles

Re: What to do with a Giant Red Oak Burl!

Jim Miles

>If the bug eaten wood is still solid, don't think of it as "ruined" sometimes bug eaten wood can turn out to be beautiful- lots of extra character