Re: Dogwood and Black Locust Boxes
Ed Moore in SW Virginia
>Ray,
It is clear that you are seeking a critique and some guidance. It helps to understand the person who offers comments, so let me begin by saying that I like crisp details. That doesn't mean that I am right, just that I have that bias.
So, looking at the box on the right I can say that I would have put a little crisp cap on the top instead of a rounded knob - like the top section on the left-hand box. Or, I would have taken the point off and made an ogee-like top that is lower. The edge of the locust top could be cut down like Mike Stafford does on his tops - and like the edge of the top of the dogwood box. I like the profile of the base of the locust box and how it flares out at the bottom.
The top of the dogwood box is interesting. I think that you would have a more interesting box if the base were more rounded or "fat". This might be accomplished by making the very bottom of the box about two-thirds of the current dimension and adjusting the curve to accommodate that. I am saying that you should consider having a 2" diameter footprint instead of 3" and that you should keep the overall diameter.
It looks as if you have sanded very carefully and finished the boxes very well. If these were your first boxes then you have done extremely well. My comments were intended to make you think about some design issues for future boxes. Good job.
Ed