Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Turning locust is a big fat pain in the tuckus

Posts

Turning locust is a big fat pain in the tuckus

#1

Turning locust is a big fat pain in the tuckus

wilbur

>I tried turning a green piece of locust tonight that I got from a neighbor who took a tree down. From what I can tell, it's black locust.

I have to say that I don't have huge amounts of turning experience, but boy, did this wood just kick my behind. It seems really hard, and did a number on the edge of my gouge. I was using one of Doug Thompsons' bowl gouges, and in the process of roughing out and turning the outside of an 8" diameter blank I had to resharpen twice, whereas with the same gouge I can make a bowl out of a piece of kiln dried white oak start to finish without resharpening.

To add insult to injury, as I was getting close to having a good shape on the outside, I found an internal crack that made me ultimately just scrap that piece of wood for turning.

I bought a honey locust blank on eBay once, and I also remember it being really hard.

Is this stuff supposed to be this hard? I've made bowls out of dry white oak that were not this hard to deal with.

Re: Turning locust is a big fat pain in the tuckus

#2

Re: Turning locust is a big fat pain in the tuckus

Karen F

>I have some Honey Locust and it was hard, dense and heavy as you know what! It takes some time to turn it but it sure is pretty when it's done. This one had a nice almomd color with good grain pattern. I have some more but I haven't got the urge to try it again.

Good luck!

Re: Turning locust is a big fat pain in the tuckus

#3

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Turning locust is a big fat pain in the tuckus

Jesper, Denmark

>Black Locust is really not that hard when green, as yours must have been. It is prone to tear-out of fibres in the end grain, but otherwise OK.

Dry stuff that has been around for a while is another matter. It is tough and hard and gets harder the longer you keep it. Black Locust is also prone to a lot of insect damage when growing, but lasts forever when felled.

In all manners of working with Black Locust, it demands respect from the woodworker. Any flaw in technique is not forgiven :) Ripping, Re-sawing and planing requires careful consideration, as it is likely to be full of internal stresses and wild grain as well as channels from borers, which you cannot see from the outside of a perfect looking board.

It is sortof a love-hate relation: Difficult to work, but lasts forever indoors, outdoors in salt water or as fence posts. Finally, it is the best firewood if you give up working it.

Re: Turning locust is a big fat pain in the tuckus

#4

"Life's Too Short . . . . . . ." |;-}}}

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>

Re: Turning locust is a big fat pain in the tuckus

#5

Dick Hines

Re: Turning locust is a big fat pain in the tuckus

Dick Hines

>If you think it is hard now, just toss it in the back of your shop for a year or so.

Then you will need a milling lathe.

Re: Turning locust is a big fat pain in the tuckus

#6

Re: Turning locust is a big fat pain in the tuckus

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Wilbur, just about all locust is hard. A lot of it is harder. ;-) It sure burns nice, and does great for fence posts. The old saying around here is that a locust fence post will outlast two post holes!

I've turned a bunch of honey locust, and it is worth the effort most of the time, but black locust goes straight to the burn pile, unless I have a specific use for it (other than the specific use of keeping warm that is!)

Re: Turning locust is a big fat pain in the tuckus

#7

Re: Turning locust is a big fat pain in the tuckus

jerry cox

>turning locust, black or honey, requires patience, determination, respect,and sharp tools....

results can be outstanding....

I try to get elm, locust, mesquite, bois d'arc (osage orange), walnut and my favorite=red cedar. Here in the Texas Panhandle, all trees are scarce.

turning green maple, cherry, etc,can be fun; but,this old guy needs a

challenge.

Re: Turning locust is a big fat pain in the tuckus

#8

Re: Turning locust is a big fat pain in the tuckus

Don at Central Illinois

>When I worked for the phone compnay, years ago, the pins that held the glass insulators were all made from locust. Once dry, the last forever in all kinds of weather. I have turned some honey locust and it is a beautiful wood.

Re: Turning locust is a big fat pain in the tuckus

#9

Re: Here in rural KY we say.........

Jamie Donaldson

>....that a black locust fence post will wear out 1 hole, while an osage post will wear out 2 postholes! Black locust is a definite challange to turn, but can have some beautiful grain when used properly. As Bill says, it is an excellent firewood, so if it's too hard to turn, then it's just right to burn!

Re: Turning locust is a big fat pain in the tuckus

#10

Adding to the firewood pile

wilbur

>Thanks for the input, everyone! I think I'll take a pass on trying to do anymore with the locust wood I have. Having seen photos of honey locust bowls, I can see why people like them, but [1] the wood I have isn't that good looking, and [B] this stuff obviously doesn't lend itself to the "I-want-to-turn-a-bowl-fairly-quickly-in-the-two-hours-I-have-after-I-get-the-boys-to-bed" scenario.

Luckily, I also have a chunk of red oak that I got from the same neighbor (they were taking down a few trees that day), which should be a piece of cake in comparison.

By the way, the locust that I have has a definite greenish tinge. Does this change as it dries?

Re: Turning locust is a big fat pain in the tuckus

#11

Aage Rendalen

I like it for natural edge vessels

Aage Rendalen

>I've only turned it green, in which case it is easy to work and if you make natural edge vessels the resultant warping will only enhance the boat-like shape of the bowl. It takes a great finish.

Re: Turning locust is a big fat pain in the tuckus

#12

Re: Turning locust is a big fat pain in the tuckus

John K Jordan

>Black Locust trees are one of the toughest on chain saws. It's the worst wood I've cut so far on my sawmill. I've turned some pieces green and there was considerable warping. I like to turn it better when dry but I prefer hard, dense woods in general. It does in fact dull tools edges quickly.

JKJ

Re: Turning locust is a big fat pain in the tuckus

#13

Re: Turning locust is a big fat pain in the tuckus

John K Jordan

>>...and my favorite=red cedar.

Jerry, you need some red cedar? I've got some large logs which would make some great turning stock. Planning any trips to East TN?

JKJ

Re: Turning locust is a big fat pain in the tuckus

#14

Gee post of encouragement!

galen V

>I guess I throw out the rest of my honey locust! The first green wood I got for free to try and turn bowls and it sounds like junk. Yes three bowls started ended up trash when I found splits. Two are now drying with anchor seal and one is split at the tennon. Two are in DNA. My Sorby bowl gouge has been ground enough now I have had good sharpening practice.

Oh and it does not even smell good turning, but it is practice for a novice turner.

Do I use the rest to roast hot dogs and marshmellows?

Re: Turning locust is a big fat pain in the tuckus

#15

Makes nice boxes

Ed Karch

>Just finished a couple of dry black locust boxes. A large project would probably beat you to death, yes it is hard but polishes up to a nice light tan color. Really holds detail nice and would probably thread up well. I am searching my wood pile for more.

Re: Turning locust is a big fat pain in the tuckus

#16

And of course...

wilbur

>In addition to your success with black locust, Ray Binnicker posts pictures of his very nice black locust box after I started this thread.

I guess I'm just lame. :@)

Re: Turning locust is a big fat pain in the tuckus

#17

Re: Turning locust is a big fat pain in the tuckus

twisted whiskers

>I really enjoy turning black locust. It's beautiful. But nothing large in diameter. The large diameter black locust blanks I've cut always seem to crack while drying or turning, and as others have noted, it will beat you up. But it isn't so bad when you're turning smaller diameter pieces. It's free and plentiful here in Appalachia, so I use it. It has a very high bending strenth and I get a lot of spindle blanks from the logs I cut. I like it for tool handles, dibbles (a gardening tool), chain pulls, finials, and just last week I turned a pair of 12 inch #10 (6mm) knitting needles from black locust.

Re: Turning locust is a big fat pain in the tuckus

#18

Follow up

wilbur

>Last night I took one of the red oak log segments that I got from the same neighbor that I got the locust from, and roughed out a bowl. It was MUCH easier than the locust, although I did have to stop and resharpen more often than I have had to with other woods.

Maybe I should keep some of that locust around. Turning with that stuff is kind of like swinging a bat with a batting doughnut on. It will make my real attempts at turning seem like a piece of cake, even if I am using oak. :@)