Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Past the point of caring how long it takes?

Posts

Past the point of caring how long it takes?

#1

Steven Antonucci

Past the point of caring how long it takes?

steve antonucci

>John (and John K's) posted below on how long it takes to make a gavel got me thinking...

How many of you care how long something takes to make? I know that I used to consider that as a measure for "how good" I was getting when I started. I figured that if something took me 1 hour to make, and I could cut it down to 30 minutes, I must have doubled my skills to have been able to see that kind of "productivity" gain. (LOL NOT!)

Nowadays, I tend to take much more time on the things I make, and I tend to want to make things that take a lot more time. Gone are the days where I could cut 10 bowls in a day and finish them the next. If I am lucky, I can cut one in one day, finish embellishing it the second, and finish during the week.

I've done this with eyes wide open.

So, do you find yourself making cupcakes or do they take too much work?

Steven

Re: Past the point of caring how long it takes?

#2

Luckly, I'm not a production turner

Ron in Drums PA

>I can turn a bowl or a box pretty quick now, mainly because I gained in skills, but so what, I'm in no race.

I turn for the enjoyment.

Re: Past the point of caring how long it takes?

#3

Good point Steve

john lucas

>I only worry about it on production jobs. Even then I still try to do the best I can but I look at the whole process and see if there are things I'm doing that can be changed to speed up the process.

In my sales venues price is a major consideration. I want to have a top notch product but can't get top notch prices so I figure out ways to make the product faster.

Of course making the same thing over and over reduces the amount of time spent simply because you don't waste time thinking about what to do next and you take off larger chunks of wood getting down to the final product because you know what it should look like.

My mirrors are a good example. The first one took half a day. After I started making them regularly they took about 1 1/2 hours. I now make them in 45 minutes. Faster if I make one without any turned details.

My friend that I mentioned below made thousands of these things, sometimes in one week. When you watch him turn there aren't any wasted motions. He never sands past 220 and will skip grits because he knows how to do it properly. They used inexpensive woods and sold these things for $20 which Is too low but they also had to look at turnaround time and volume was one of the keys to making the business successful. His dad ran that business in Pidgeon Forge, Tn for 50 years so he must have done something right.

Re: Past the point of caring how long it takes?

#4

Re: Past the point of caring how long it takes?

Michael Stafford

>I can turn a box fairly quickly these days but that does not mean it will be finished to a standard of quality I am happy with. I am not a productin turner and it is unlikely that I ever will be. If turning is not fun I will probably quit turning. I am not trying to make a living at this hobby.

As Ron said, "It is not a race."

Re: Past the point of caring how long it takes?

#5

No, I'm not past the point of caring

davidwalser

>In truth, I'm not sure if I ever cared too much about how long a turning took to complete. This is my hobby. I've never sold my work and never intend to sell anything. (I suppose that'll change once I've finished filling the homes of my friends and relatives with turned items.) As long as I enjoy my time at the lathe, my hobby "purpose" is being fulfilled.

Having said that, I'm not indifferent to the time it takes for me to turn something any more than I'm indifferent to the quality of the finished product. Part of my enjoyment comes from the shear joy I feel in learning and honing a new skill. I simply love the feel of turning a square into something useful and, to the extent I'm able to do that with sure, confident, moves, my enjoyment increases. It's just more fun to do something right confidently and quickly, than it is to do the same thing hesitantly and slowly. Turning a bead with sure, deft, motions, produces a feeling that is very similar to the feeling I get from making a good golf shot -- with the difference being that good golf shots are much more rare.

So, yes, I'm not past the point of caring how long something takes. I try to honestly estimate how long something "should" take me to turn. If I'm able to turn that item -- and turn it well -- in less time, it's a very pleasant and welcome surprise.

Re: Past the point of caring how long it takes?

#6

ebd

Re: Past the point of caring how long it takes?

ebd

>Never have cared how much time it took. My only consideration has always been the quality of the final product. Over time my technique has improved enough that I don't feel that I'm wasting too much time and proper technique can't be hurried without stress and risking damage. On a new piece, a new idea that I haven't tried, I work slower (sometimes much slower) than on a piece I've done before. A piece that I've done before but with a wood I've never used falls somewhere in between. I don't mind taking my time and (the few) customers I have don't mind waiting. I only do custom work and that only through word of mouth. I have no desire to make this into a job.

Re: Past the point of caring how long it takes?

#7

Keith Tompkins

Re: Past the point of caring how long it takes?

Keith Tompkins

>HI Steve, Excellent topic. I often hear people say that they got into turning because it was quick; a project could often be completed in an evening. Even if one is trying to make a living from turning, in the long run, the time it takes to complete a piece is not the most important consideration. The results are what matters. The piece that took less than an hour will sit on your (or someone's) shelf for decades for the world to see. I teach frequently, and confront this dilemma almost every time. Too many turners cannot be bothered to achieve uniform wall thicknesses, clean cuts, or excellent sanding and finish work. Speed seems to be of the essence, yet many turners want to "save" a piece that has been destroyed. I have been known to cut a student's piece in half on the bandsaw, and then ask them to start over when this happens. I try to do the best I'm capable of each time I produce a piece, and improve on my past work, and that's something I encourage in my classes. Make every piece your best. I think that's the same situation you are experiencing....small things like details in the form, the way the tool cuts, the finish the tool leaves. As one progresses in a craft, speed becomes less and less important (after all, speed comes with practice and experience, all by itself) and a desire to create beautiful, sophisticated objects becomes the focal point. I can see that in your work. :)

Re: Past the point of caring how long it takes?

#8

Funny you should ask...

Mike Jones, Redding, CA

>...I just spent all morning seriously re-sanding and re-finishing just two bowls. And, I said to myself in resignation, "I don't care if it takes the rest of my life!!!...I'm gonna learn to get the finish really, really right"

Laquer finishes, and shellac too (if sprayed) are easy enough to get right the first time through. Building coats of oil/varnish, and getting that last one perfect, eludes me...

...and I'm going to learn no matter how long it takes!

Re: Past the point of caring how long it takes?

#9

Re: Past the point of caring how long it takes?

robo hippy

>Well, I am a production turner. Turning fast is necessary for me, and just as important as the final product. I do take my time because I figure my tecnique will continue to get better. I don't want to waste time. Each bowl is fun, and I can't wait to get to the next one. If I do a sloppy job of turning, I will have to spend more time sanding which is my least favorite task. Every cut is a practice cut (I don't remember who said this), and with all the practice I have had, I am getting more efficient. My ultimate goal is to turn a bowl that doesn't need sanding.

I could teach some one to be as fast or faster than I am, in less time than it took me, because after 10 years of turning, I have learned a lot of tricks. A lot of them were from experience, and a lot from watching and seeing other people turn.

robo hippy

Re: Past the point of caring how long it takes?

#10

Re: Past the point of caring how long it takes?

John K Jordan

>I've never been concerned about the time. I hear people say they turn a finger top in a couple of minutes - it usually takes me closer to 15 minutes and often longer. And I don't think I've gotten any faster with experience - I seem to spend even more time now getting the form, thickness, finish just right. I've looked closely at the work of a couple of production turners that were very fast and apparently proud of it. But up close I saw things like sanding scratches.

But as others have said, if doing this for a hobby the the process is part of the fun. I even enjoy the sanding - it's kind of a zen thing. If I ever get to the point where all this seems more than work than recreation, I'll quit and take up something else.

JKJ