Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

cored red elm set

Posts

cored red elm set

#1

cored red elm set

Steven Kubien

>Hi folks,

This is one of my few successful attempts at coring with the McNaughton centre saver. Well, actually there was a larger bowl for these two to sit in so maybe it wasn't that successful. I really hated that tool (and returned it). I'll pick up a Oneway kit soon.

Red elm, harvested by the local electric company back in October. With Steve Mushinski's help (and his chainsaw since I didn't have one at the time), some of it avoided the burn pile. Walnut oil to darken it up and salad bowl finish on top.

Critiques and comments welcome.

Cheers,

Steve Kubien


img

Re: cored red elm set

#2

Re: cored red elm set

Sean Troy

>Really nice shape/grain mix. Coring sure is a handy system to use.

Re: cored red elm set

#3

Re: cored red elm set

Mike Brazeau

>Very pretty pair of bowls Steve. Elm grain is beautiful but it is tough as it gets.

Mike

Re: cored red elm set

#4

Steven Antonucci

So much easier than wasting wood...

steve antonucci

>I keep telling myself that I'll get a coring set someday.

Nice work. Next thing you'll try is three cores, then 4...

Steve

Re: cored red elm set

#5

I've tried more cores...

Steven Kubien

>...and thus far have had mixed results. Lack of a chainsaw early on meant using smaller timber and (more importantly in my case) screwing up the largest blank has been troublesome. I've made a bunch of big funnels along with some small blanks (4-6" diameter) which were too small to be bothered with. I do have a finished 2 piece set in silver maple which I will post in a couple of days and a 3 piece set in birch which ought to be lovely when finish turned.

In all of this, I got terribly frustrated with the McNaughton system. The big concerns for me were wasting so many bigger blanks and not getting consistently shaped cores. I returned the tool within the 90-grace period offered by Lee Valley and will get a Oneway set soon.

Cheers,

Steve

Re: cored red elm set

#6

Re: cored red elm set

Texian

>Steve,

Thought I was the only one that did not care for the McNaughton tool. Returned mine also after some very unproductive trials. Granted that there is a learning curve, but I don't expect to live that long.

You got a couple very pretty bowls. Much better than I did.

Re: cored red elm set

#7

Re: cored red elm set

Lan Brady

>Texian and Steve,

I sure hate you guys have run into such a problem. 2 Weeks ago, I cored my first bowl with my McNaughton tool. The first bowl was intense all the way. I could not imagine why anyone would us this thing.

BUT, by the third blank, I was coring with 2 fingers on the tool. I wish you could have made it work for you, because I am extremely impressed with mine. I cannot beleive the versatility. It allows me to core deep or shallow.

I did watch the Mahoney and the Grumbine video before trying to use it. I give a lot of credit to these guys for improving my learning curve.

Lan

Re: cored red elm set

#8

Re: cored red elm set

Steven Kubien

>Lan it was the versatility of it that attracted me in the first place ok, it was also less expensive than the Oneway). For me, it was pure hatred. I hated using it and isn't this all supposed to be fun? To each his/her own. I know there are lots of folks who love this rig and use it successfully for hundreds and thousands of cores. Guess I am not one of them.

Cheers,

Steve Kubien

Re: cored red elm set

#9

Re: cored red elm set

davidwalser

>As long as you're looking, have you considered the Woodcut Bowl Saver? It does not appear to be as flexible as the other systems, but it's use of the tail stock appears to give the cut more support and make the tool easier to use. Here's a link to CSUSA's page: Bowl Saver

Note: I don't have experience with any of the coring systems; I'm just looking myself. Any comments on the relative advantages of the three systems would be appreciated.