Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Two maple boxes

Posts

Two maple boxes

#1

Two maple boxes

Ed Moore in SW Virginia

>The ambrosia maple box on the left is 4 1/8" high and 2 7/8" diameter. The spalted and lightly ambrosia maple box on the right is 3 5/8" high and 2 3/4" in diameter. Both boxes have a Shellawax finish and a smooth "pop" fit.

If you see slightly convex curves on the side profile of the box on the right, both on the top and on the bottom, then your eye is correct. Both lids have a very slight ogee shape.

I would really like a critique of the these boxes. Tell me what you like and what you dislike. PLEASE! Take no prisoners. [grin]

Ed


img

Re: Two maple boxes

#2

Ambrosia maple box

Ed Moore in SW Virginia

>This wood is marked beautifully. There are some real bug holes on the lid on the right. It was fun getting the Shellawax out of them.

Ed


img

Re: Two maple boxes

#3

Spalted maple box

Ed Moore in SW Virginia

>Getting a smooth cut wasn't always easy. I used the small Munro tool on the bottom to get rid of tearout and then took light cuts with the usual angled scraper. While the sides angle in towards the joint, there is also a slight bow in each element.

Ed


img

Re: Two maple boxes

#4

Re: Spalted maple box

David Walser

>Ed,

Both boxes are great. The grain match is excellent and the wood is beautiful. The beading hides/accents the joint in an attractive manner. I like the convex curves on the sides. My only question is, would the box on the right look lighter (and better) if there were a slight rounding off of the bottom corner edge? Don't know. It looks fine as is (better than fine), but I think I would have tried rounding off the corner -- and probably ended up regretting it.

Re: Two maple boxes

#5

Re: Spalted maple box

Ed Moore in SW Virginia

>Dave,

I kept the bottom edge crisp because the edge of the lid is crisp. Another option would have been to bring the bottom in like the box on the left.

Thanks for the idea,

Ed

Re: Two maple boxes

#6

Re: Spalted maple box

Barry Irby

>I like them both. Excellent. They both invite you to pick them up and open them. They look as if they would be easy to hold onto and the get a grip on the top and bottom to give them a tug to open them. (As opposed to some of mine with few details on the profile to hold onto.) My only criticism is that the beads on the one on the right do not appear to match exactly. The lower bead appears more round and the upper bead more flat, but that could be the photograph. Great boxes though.

It just occurred to me that you could make these out of a single piece of wood and never separate them and never hollow them. Grain match would be perfect. They are hollow....right?

Re: Two maple boxes

#7

Spalted maple box, open

Ed Moore in SW Virginia

>Okay, here it is open. I didn't have the lights right since SWMBO wasn't available as a lightholder. You are right, if someone wanted to show a good grain match, then make it in one piece and don't bother to hollow.

You are correct about the beads. One is slightly "higher" than the other.

I have become quite conscious of box shapes that don't lend themselves to easy openings. That is why I like the mosque boxes of Richard Raffan. They don't squirt out of your fingers when you try to open them.

Thanks,

Ed


img

Re: Two maple boxes

#8

Re: Spalted maple box, open

Barry Irby

>I like them both.

On the one you have open, try making another with the base slightly more concave. Sort of sweep the ogee through a little more. If the base of this one is is conceived, the photo is not showing it well.

Re: Two maple boxes

#9

Barry, if you ...

Ed Moore in SW Virginia

>put a straightedge tangent to the side of the base near the middle, then you have about a 1/16 or less clearance at each end, so there is a slight bow, but not a pronounced one. SWMBO really likes this box.

There are two possibilities if you have a convex edge on the top. You may put a concave base on it and get an ogee outline, or you may may put a convex base on it and have the base reflect the top. Either will work.

I have only done one hyperbolic box with the lid and base concave. Alan Lacer seems to be doing them now so I am looking for other possibilities. No one owns the hyperbolic shape, but sometimes discretion is the best approach.