Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

long skinny spindle turner

Posts

long skinny spindle turner

#1

long skinny spindle turner

Eric in Los Gatos

>I'm a not quite a total newb but I am trying my first long skinny spindle. About 14" lg and 3/4" square to start. I have managed to get it to a rough shape but am having vibration problems and think my holding method wrong. The way I see it there are three possibilities:

1. Hold the base in a chuck. Line up as close as possible and locate the live center in the center of the part and lock the chuck down. This is what I have done now and think that bending part is what's causing the problem. When I released the live center the part moved so that it was offset a bit.

2. Hold the base in a chuck. Line up as close as possible and let the live center land wherever it lands.

3. Use a spur drive on the base and live center in the center of the opposite end. My concern with this method is applying too much pressure on the part and bending it.

So that's the way I see it. Is one the three methods I described above right or is there a fourth method that I missed.

Any advice would be greatly appreciated.

Thanks,

Eric in Los Gatos

Re: long skinny spindle turner

#2

Re: long skinny spindle turner *LINK*

john lucas

>Eric Check out this thread to answer most of your problem. I do find that chucking one end in the chuck will reduce chatter. You can also reduce the pressure on the tailstock a little more when you have one end in the chuck. However the rest of the problem can be solved by reading this post and a bunch of practice. A 14"x3/4" spindle is going to fight you. I use my fingers to support the wood opposite the bevel of the tool. This takes practice to get it right.


http://www.woodcentral.com/cgi-bin/turning3.pl?read=187952

Re: long skinny spindle turner

#3

what I do

John K Jordan

>Eric,

I haven't read the thread J.Lucas linked so perhaps it covers this. I turn a lot of long skinny spindles (12-14" long and often down to about an 1/8" in places). I do this:

- Definitely hold the base in a chuck. This holds one end of the wood rigidly and keeps at least the first part of the spindle from flexing. I find a thin piece is much less likely to break when one end is held in a chuck. If held between two nodes (centers), each end of a long piece of wood can pivot on it's supporting point and the whole shaft can flex and ring a bit like a guitar string. Instead of a 4-jaw chuck, I generally use the morse taper in the headstock as a jam chuck which works as well. This has several advantages over a normal chuck - one, it gives more clearance around the end for your tools, two, it gives more working length which may be important on a small lathe, three, it doesn't have any hard pieces whirling to catch the tool or hand, four, it automatically makes the tailstock end line up EXACTLY with the supporting point in the live center, and five, it cannot crush the wood fibers and distort the end (a common problem with softer wood).

To make a morse taper to jam, I first mount the blank between two centers (drive with a steb center) and turn a short taper on one end (1/2" is enough, no more than about 3/4"). I made a little brass gauge to make this quicker, but a caliper works as well. They are real quick to make after the first few. (I also cut a relief in the middle of the taper to insure a more secure fit.)

- Before mounting the blank between centers, I always make a small hole in the center on each end. This is especially important on thin, brittle woods which may otherwise split when the tailstock is tightened. To make this hole, I use a gimlet, the original cordless drill. I keep a small gimlet handy on a magnet on the front of the lathe.

- When turned thin, vibration will happen. When it starts, I use my left hand to support the piece directly opposite the cutting edge of the tool, left fingers cupped around the work. This is easy if I grip the tool in my right hand very near the toolrest, the thumb on the left side of the shaft, the forefinger extended and bent under the tool shaft, the three lesser fingers wrapped around to grip the shaft, and the handle of the tool wedged against my forearm. This makes the entire tool feel like an extension of the arm. The forefinger slides along in contact with the near edge of the toolrest to steady and add control to the tool. The toolrest may need to be raised a bit to use the tool comfortably and securely. The left hand moves with the cut acting like a moving steady rest. If friction from the wood makes it too hot, back off on the pressure by making a lighter cut.

If vibration persists as sometimes it will, I try things: change the speed, increase or reduce the tailstock compression force, take lighter cuts. In cases where nothing else works, perhaps due to hard and soft areas in the wood itself or where vibration has left a series of bumpy spirals, I use the very heel of the skew to make a smoothing pass. When used conventionally, the bevel of the skew rides on previous irregularities in the surface which compounds the problem. Using the very heel (just the first 1/64" or so of the cutting edge) minimizes the bevel contact.

- Occasionally, everything will be going fine and the nearly finished thin spindle will suddenly go off-center in the center, almost as if the wood has bent or warped. Some woods are more flexible and worse about this than others, seemingly almost plastic such that they stay where you put them. (Wood still a bit green is the worst.) The first thing I do is try reducing the tailstock force in case it is too high. Then I stop the lathe and bend the shaft back straight again while turning by hand to check (sometimes it will "pop" back into place), then hold it centered while turning the lathe back on. This usually fixes it. Sometimes I simply whack the spinning shaft with the handle of the tool to pop it back into true. This usually takes a half dozen gentle bumps before I manage to hit it in exactly the right place!

JKJ

Re: long skinny spindle turner

#4

Re: long skinny spindle turner *LINK*

charlie belden

>Before I got a chuck I turned a lot of "hair sticks" - between centers - using primarily a skew. Roughed the blank to round and started working end to end towards the diameter I wanted - actually a taper. At some diameter, and that varied with the wood being turned, either the tail stock end would develop a little movement. If I tightened up the tail stock I'd flex the piece and get whipping.

Then I got a chuck and skipped the tail stock all together. After a while I figured out that if I started on the non-chucked end and turned small areas to completion, including sanding and finishing, working my way back towards the chuck a) most of what had already been turned and never touched again stayed stabile and b) I was cutting into relatively beefy - and very stabile wood.

Scroll down to "S" for Spinarettes and "S" for small and then scroll to the bottom and go to the second page of "When Your Muse Abandons You". There's a 5" long toothpick with a bit over 4" of that at around 0.05 to 0.06"

The key - at least for me - is to finish as you go and DO NOT go back to touch up anything later.

By the inch it's a since. By the yard - well it's damned near impossible.


Scroll to the "S"s