Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

I had a terrible time!

Posts

I had a terrible time!

#1

I had a terrible time!

eliot d

>I tried to turn an odd shaped rectangular hunk of wood off center at various places in a pathetic attempt to get some kind of Stoney L. --type sculptural effect. I got essentially nowhere. My big mustard monster started jumping all over the place! I did see a balancing system in Richmond that probably would have come in handy, but I didn't pay enough attention at the time. Any thoughts from some of the sculpturally -oriented turners out there?

Re: I had a terrible time!

#2

Re: I had a terrible time!

John Veerkamp, Western Mo.

>several things to try. play with the speed, sometimes slowing down or speeding up can make a big difference in the shaking. also you might try tapeing some weights(lead fishing sinkers, washere,etc) on the light side. Sharp tools and light cuts are the rule of the day.

Good luck. Keep at it you'll find the right combination.

John

Re: I had a terrible time!

#3

Re: I had a terrible time!

john lucas

>Eliot Stoney used to use large plywood faceplates and added lead weights to the off balance side to make everything spin freely. That's also how people like Graeme Priddle and Terry Scott do their off center turnings. It's much cheaper than the Vicmarc balancing system.

Re: I had a terrible time!

#4

Re: I had a terrible time!

Raymond Overman in SC

>I have two MDF plates with dried hardwood tenons that I use for off center turnings. I've screwed counter weight blocks directly to the MDF as well as used duct tape to attach the wood to the plate while leaving the area to be turned exposed.

I'm nowhere near the league of Stoney or other off center turners but this method seems to work pretty well on a 1642. I can't see why a 3520 couldn't manage it.

Re: I had a terrible time!

#5

Re: I had a terrible time!

Chip in Plano

>I've seen using MDF backers in 2 different Woodturning Design issues since 2006. One was for a wine rack and one for a kleenex box. I believe I saw another one in a Wood magazine (I think) where the project started with a piece of white oak shaped like a 2x4 into which 2 identical sized bowls were hollowed out. The carrier was a piece of plywood and a 2x4 block screwed onto one end or the other as the counter-balance for which ever bowl was being cut. The 2x4 could easily be drilled out for additional lead weighting to really fine tune the balancing.

Have I tried this yet? Nope, but it's on my list of to do's. I have several 8/4 pieces of white oak that need a spin.

Re: I had a terrible time!

#6

Lyle Jamieson

Re: I had a terrible time!

Lyle Jamieson

>Be very careful!!! Even with Stoneys experience he was seriously hurt once. I have turned multi axis of up to 250 pounds. You didnt say what scale you are working with. The ideas posted already are good for relatively small scale pieces. I would not trust tape to hold weights on any piece. With larger pieces the flywheel and balancing chucks methods fail. The counter balancing weights are not directly opposing the off balanced wood. You can get a static balance but once you turn the lathe on the weight is flinging mass in different directions. I prefer to securely SCREW weights on the waste wood. Another plan for smaller pieces is to CA glue a block of wood on, if you have a good flat surface to glue onto. All these take considerable planning to figure out how you will clean up the waste area after turning is complete. Never under any circumstances do I stand or walk through the danger zone in front of the wood with the lathe on. I think its worth the fuss, go for the spectacular.

Re: I had a terrible time!

#7

Re: I had a terrible time!

Fog Tanner

>Most of my turning these days is offcenter. I have three different offcenter chucks that I use for various projects. I started doing a lot of eccentric bowls where the piece is offcenter and at an angle. Even with mt lathe weighing a 1000lbs I was still able to get it moving at higher rpms. I start at around 400 or more and work up to 1500 as mass is removed. For the larger pieces I stop at around 900 now.

With the eccentric chucks I have, there is a builtin imbalance with a large amount of steel being offcenter. I can get vibration with no wood mounted at all. I counter act this I bought the Vicmarc balancing system. This may have been the one you saw. I just finished a large 11" Pecan bowl using the system. The counter balance seems to work with no problems. I worked with the weights before ever turning the lathe on. I found where you had to start from and that it was better to move both a little than one a lot. Once I got the static balance set, I turned the lathe on, checked for vibration, and adjusted the weights as necessary. I wound up with no more vibration than you would with any bowl blank. Its a similar process to balancing a crankshaft - except I don't have the highdollar machine for that.

As the bowl is roughed out all the vibration goes away pretty quick. What used to take me 4 hours to turn was cut down to 1 1/2 hours. And that was one a much smaller piece of wood. I am also using it for the "normal" bowls that I do, just to avoid the inital vibration and lower rpms.

I also do all the "roughing" and part of the finish work with the tailstock engaged. When I rough out the pieces, I cut them as usual with intent of removing as much waste as quickly as possible. This shortens the duration of the most imbalance. I will also use the tailstock on the inside at times while working on the rim. Once that is thinned down I move the tailstock out of the way.

And if you want to do offcenter work of a lager scale then you need some body protection beyond what you normally use. A faceshield alone isn't good enough, you need a helmet with a visor that can withstand a blow. I wear a helmet all the time, and hand protection (left hand) part of the time. And when I can get over to Col. Bubbies I am buying a surplus flak jacket for a turning smock. If you wear glasses and have bifocals, it is worth getting a set of single vision glasses that are good for about the same distance you are from your computer monitor. That keeps your head away from the activity. It is much too easy to "get down and look closer" on some of those finer cuts. At times I also put a piece of masking take on the tool rest at the "Nogo zone". It also helps to put a piece of dark or contrasting colored background under the piece to help you "see" the shadow cuts.

It is fun to do, you just have to remmber that is is much more dangerous than normal woodturning and not something you do unless you are really alert - which what we need is more lerts...Have fun and be safe and careful.

Fog

Re: I had a terrible time!

#8

example...

GaryG in MD

>Eliot,

You have gotten some excellent and well-thought-out answers to your post. They have pointed out that what you are trying to do is dangerous. Please be careful.

Terry Scott has a new series of off-center work. If you're a WoW member, there's a great photo of his setup from July 13 at

www.thewows.com/isapi.dll?c=Content&htx=View&siteid=G6kOAI&contentid=ZZZZZ5S5&contentclass=PICT&categoryid=0

Even relatively small pieces require a very large workpiece. Think ahead.

...Gary

Re: I had a terrible time!

#9

Re: example...

bill crommett

>For my off center work I use an Arbortec four carbide tooth grinder head in a throwaway 4 1/2 imported grinder mounted in a special grinder jig. The reason for the cheap grinder is that the bump-bump of the wood on the Arbortec takes its toll on the shaft bearings,and it is cheaper to buy another cheap grinder than to replace the worn out bearings on my Makita. Once I get the excess lumps off I then do a balancing adjustment on what is left.

Re: I had a terrible time!

#10

Re: I had a terrible time!

John Jordan

>Something of interest in Stoney's pieces. The different axis are almost always along a physical center of balance-it may not look that way, but it's easy to figure out. Stoney maintains that can be sensed in the overall balance of a finished piece.

Stoney and I taught a class at Arrowmont once, and the class had a pretty tough time with a simple bowl, so I was not looking forward to them trying multi-axis the next day. Fifteen propeller like objects spinning around-it LOOKED scary, but they did great-no problems, go figure.

Be careful.

John

John

Re: I had a terrible time!

#11

Re: I had a terrible time!

eliot d

>John,

Thanks for the response. Can you give me some sources for the "easy-to-figure-out" method you mention?