Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Why a negative rake scraper works better

Posts

Why a negative rake scraper works better

#1

Why a negative rake scraper works better

eliot d

>I guess we all know by now that negative rake scrapers seem to avoid or reduce catches when scraping. A friend at my turning club has convinced me that part of the reason why they work has to do with the removal of certain vector forces at the tool rest that otherwise would cause the tool to push into the wood. And this makes sense. But I seem to recall that there is a rather complete theoretical explanation somewhere out there for why negative rake scrapers work. Can anyone point me to it?

Re: Why a negative rake scraper works better

#2

Re: Why a negative rake scraper works better

john lucas

>I don't know about complex. I'm a simply guy. If you hold a scraper so the handle is higher than the cutting edge then you don't get catches. For description sake I'll say 20 degrees higher than horizontal.

If you grind a negative rake on the scraper of 20 degrees then you can hold the scraper horizontal and get the same cut. I suppose in theory this makes it safer because you could lower the handle slightly and still have the cutting edge angle below horizontal.

I liked Stewart Batty's negative rake scraper because the edge was ground to a very sharp angle. This makes it cut very clean but doesn't hold an edge log at all. You could do the same thing by grinding the lower bevel of a standard scraper to a steeper angle. This is similar to what John Jordan did with his shear scraper. The top is flay without a negative rake but the grind is 45 degrees. This makes it cut very clean especially when used in the shear cutting angle. I don't know if a negative rake would be an advantage on a shear scraper.

Re: Why a negative rake scraper works better

#3

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Why a negative rake scraper works better

Lyle Jamieson

>Q&A in Woodturning Magazine August, 2008 has a good explanation. The benefit is for deep lidded boxes if you want to go with hand held blind turning. I prefer the carbide cutter and laser assistance on a supported hollowing system.

Re: Why a negative rake scraper works better

#4

Stuart Batty is adamant...

GaryG in MD

>...that a negative-rake scraper works better (is less grabby) than a regular scraper held handle high. There have been many discussions about the merits, or lack thereof, of negative-rake scrapers. Stuart says he coined the term. I'm not going to argue with Stuart -- my only interest would be to understand the physical reason for his experience. I have not read the mag article, but, as a physicist, my analysis indicates that the reason is that in the latter case, the contact between the tilted scraper and the tool rest has a force component toward the wood, pushing the tool in. The negative-rake scraper, with it's horizontal bottom, does not have this component. That's my story, and I'm sticking to it. Stuart says the handle/overhang ratio needed for a regular scraper is 7:1, and for a negative-rake scraper it's only 3:1. I'll trust his experience in the matter. ...Gary

Re: Why a negative rake scraper works better

#5

Stuart Batty is ...

Ed Moore in SW Virginia

>right, but not for a reason that a physicist can analyze using vectors. In order for a regular scraper to be presented to the wood exactly like a negative-rake scraper would be, you must have your handle and rest raised up a fair amount. In fact, with the handle and rest up you have far less control because your arm and hand are necessarily raised to an awkward position. You have better tool control in general when the handle is horizontal or close to it. Raising things up ten or fifteen degrees means that your hand is five or six inches higher than usual (depending on the handle length), and it is in unfamiliar territory.

Ed

Re: Why a negative rake scraper works better

#6

Re: Stuart Batty is adamant...

john lucas

>Gary I'm not going to argue with Stewart Batty. I love the guy. I think my problem with negative rake scrapers is how I use a scraper. On a box for example, I might use the scraper flat to clean up tool marks but then I make a final pass or two with the scraper tilted up in a shear scraping mode. I had trouble using the negative rake scraper in shear scraper mode. I do believe it is better when used flat, especially for deep boxes because it's more difficult to get the handle higher.

I also tend to use a scraper to remove very little material with very light pressure. This reduces the catches to 0 if done properly. If I had 2 scrapers I might opt for the negative rake on one of them but then I would have to switch tools to do one job and that would slow me down. The same is true with bowls. I usually get the finish I want off the cutting tool but If I resort to a scraper I always follow up with shear scraping. On a bowl I have more access to move the tool so the negative rake in a shear scrape might be a possibility.

I'll give it a try again in the next few weeks and let you know what I think. My first experiments might have been flawed. My first experiments didn't prove any advantages and you had to grind the tool twice (once on each surface) instead of once. Granted once you've established the negative grind it's a one grind operation to sharpen but you wear away the negative rake and have to regrind it. If you don't like the negative rake it also takes forever to grind this area away.

Re: Why a negative rake scraper works better

#7

Gary, a more accurate answer ...

Ed Moore in SW Virginia

>on my part would be that the vector analysis at the point of the tool would not be different for the two cases. However, a vector analysis at the end of the handle would be quite different when considering handle horizontal and handle end up five or six inches.

Ed

Re: Why a negative rake scraper works better

#8

Re: My opinion, for what it's worth.

Russ Fairfield

>This is the same as the arguement about whether the burr should be put on the scraper with a grinder or burnished, or whether there should be a burr on it at all. Everyone has their own opinion and there are good arguments to support all of them.

The bottom line is that all of this comes down to our personal preference. Everyone has to try the various options and determine which one works the best for them, and that has nothing to do with science, mechanics, or force vectors.

Re: Why a negative rake scraper works better

#9

Re: Stuart Batty is adamant...

GaryG in MD

>John,

I understand what you're saying. We all have our own ways of doing things, and there are clearly several effective approaches, but after watching Stuart twice recently, I have changed some of my methods. You can't argue with his results. He used three different tools as a negative rake scraper -- a skew, a parting/beading tool, and his big sword.

You're certainly right about the sharpening part, and although I've read that the original version used on bone didn't necessarily use a burr, Stuart insists on a prominent burr for wood, and he puts a new one on about every 30 seconds of use. I'll have a demo article out in a day or two and post a reference here.

...Gary

Re: Why a negative rake scraper works better

#10

Re: Gary, a more accurate answer ...

GaryG in MD

>Ed,

Stuart says a regular scraper gets "sucked in", while the negative-rake scraper does not. The reason is neither at the cutting tip nor at the end of the handle -- the key is the contact point at the tool rest. A negative-rake scraper held flat on the tool rest has no force component toward the wood. A normal scraper with the handle tipped up does not rest flat on the rest, and the force vector from the rest to the tool has a component in the direction of the wood. That's the difference. I believe that's why it "self feeds". That's the catch. ;-)

Gary

Re: Why a negative rake scraper works better

#11

Re: Why a negative rake scraper works better *LINK*

Bradford Chaucer

>I think you guys are missing a major point in the different geometry of the tool. A so called positive rake scraper has an included angle between the top and front of less than 90 deg, with the result that contact with the wood is at the edge only. In a so called negative rake scraper, the top is ground with forward rake, and very little clearance on the front resulting in an included angle of 90 deg or more. The resulting contact is less prone to dig in and may almost be riding the front "bevel in use. See e.g.

http://www.hiltonhandcraft.com/Articles/The%20Negative%20Rake%20Scraper.pdf


http://www.hiltonhandcraft.com/Articles/The%20Negative%20Rake%20Scraper.pdf

Re: Why a negative rake scraper works better

#12

Re: Huh?

Ron McKinley

>I still don't get it. I use scrapers on bowls and boxes and still don't understand why grinding the scraper a little differently makes a difference. Guess I'm just dense......Ron

Re: Why a negative rake scraper works better

#13

Re: Why a negative rake scraper works better

john lucas

>That is quite informative. Thanks for posting. It does not answer the question about the negative rake round nose scraper that Stewart Batty uses. His scraper is ground along the edge and looks more like a skew grind along the edge. There isn't a bevel to rub on that tool. I think his scraper is harder to get a catch however.

Re: Why a negative rake scraper works better

#14

Not all negative rake scrapers ...

Ed Moore in SW Virginia

>are ground the same. Some, such as Stuart Batty's, have a much less than 90 degree included angle. Mine are more like Stuart's, but not quite like a skew on its side. It certainly has a smaller included angle than those in the Hilton article. I don't get catches and it leaves a smoother surface than a traditional scraper.

Ed

Re: Why a negative rake scraper works better

#15

Re: Not all negative rake scrapers ...

robo hippy

>I recently saw Eli Alvisera (spell?) and all of his skews, beading and parting tools had a negative rake to them. I found it interesting and modified one skew and found it to be much more friendly to use. I got away with making cuts that would have normally resulted in that decorative spiral on spindles that we all have experienced. That is because you can't really come off the bevel while making the cut. On the scrapers, I don't know what the difference is because you aren't riding the bevel for most of the cuts. I do know that a negative rake scraper doesn't work at all for massive stock removal like a normal scraper does. A scraper is my prefered tool for bowl roughing. At a shear angle, it doesn't seem to work any better than my regular scrapers. Since I keep the cutting edge of the negative rake scraper in the center of the blade, I can change it at will from a right hand to a left hand scraper at will depending on which side of it I touch up on the grinder last. Maybe it is just me, or it could be my grinding wheels (CBN-cubic boric nitride) and the burr they leave.

I have to play around with it a lot more.

robo hippy

Re: Why a negative rake scraper works better

#16

Re: Why a negative rake scraper works better

eliot d------WebKitFormBoundaryTKv+qeilZ7RAWtT9

>I find that the only answer supported by an engineering answer is that by my friend Gary, with whom I've discussed this issue personally. He is absolutely right about their being some force resolved down the tool into the wood because of what's going on at the tool rest. It really is a simple matter of vector forces. But my take on that is that for a light scraping cut, that force component is too little to worry about. I still think there is something more going on. I have to look up that Q&A that LJ mentioned.

Re: Why a negative rake scraper works better

#17

How do you put a negative rake on a SKEW!?

adrien------WebKitFormBoundaryCYgCTS8iAM5FYG+w

>

Re: Why a negative rake scraper works better

#18

Re: How do you put a negative rake on a SKEW!?

john lucas

>Adrien If I understood Eli accurately his skew is ground with a convex curve on the bevel, vs concave or flat for most skews. If a skew is used as a scraper it is technically a negative rake whether it's convex or concave grind. I ground a skew convex and tried it out for a few weeks. I didn't like it. You could get a catch just like on the concave ground skews. I found it harder to control when turning beads.

Re: Why a negative rake scraper works better

#19

Thanks John, that demystifies it.

adrien Coblentz

>