Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Elbo, Monster, et al.

Posts

Elbo, Monster, et al.

#1

Elbo, Monster, et al.

Russ Fairfield

>I have been enjoying the controversy of "who was first?" I hate to tell you guys this, but none of you were. Maybe you aleady know this??

I have to give credit to a couple guys in Tallahassee, FL, who were the real inventors of the articulated arm hollowing system sometime around 1994. They didn't patent it because they just wanted a stable hollowing tool that was ridgid, easy to use, and didn't weigh a Ton. There made 5 or 6 of them that I know of. I saw one of the guys at the Symposium last year, and learned the other one is no longer with us. We had a good laugh about the whole thing, and that they predated everyone by at least 10 years.

They came up with the idea during a bull session at a club meeting after one of then had purchased a hollowing system like the one that Frank Sudol had demonstrated. Frank's captured bar predated the one by Lyle Jamieson bu about 3 years, and these guys were looking for the same rigidity without it weighing 400 pounds. Frank's was fabricated from 1-5/8" solid bar stock, and was as difficult to move as it was heavy. One of them fabricated the prototype, trashed it, and built No. 2 for himself. I can't remember how many they made, but there were at least 6 that I remember. The last two and had ball bearings in the joints, where the previous versions had used brass bushings.

They made these things because they worked and were a good solid boring bar system, and they never had a thought of making any money off of them. It is unfortunate that a good idea has become the center of a controversy. This only proves a couple truths about these petty arguements. First, there is nothing new under the sun. If it isn't new science, there is a good chance that somewhere someone has done it before. The second truth is that, unless there is real money involved, and lots of it, everybody loses, except the attorneys.

It seems that the people involved have already lost.

Re: Elbo, Monster, et al.

#2

Re: Elbo, Monster, et al.

Bill Stehman

>"The second truth is that, unless there is real money involved, and lots of it, everybody loses, except the attorneys.

It seems that the people involved have already lost. "

``````````````

So true Russ. If a plaintiff ever won the defendants would of course file bankrupt. The plaintiff would have a moral win and never sell his product except to maybe a few newbies with no material gain.The power of the internet cannot be overlooked. One can lose before ever winning.

Re: Elbo, Monster, et al.

#3

Re: Elbo Tool

Ron McKinley

>The articulated arm concept goes back to the 1920s but was never patented or patentable so 1994 is a "second coming" of the concept. I think Stan Townsend, inventor of the Elbo Tool, who has a patent or applied for a patent several years ago, is probably the rightful owner of the current concept.

Stan has many patents to his credit and is really savvy when it comes to inventions and patents. Years ago, he invented and patented the high-speed mail sorting machines that are still in use today.

Somebody is barking up the wrong tree! .....Ron

Re: Elbo, Monster, et al.

#4

Hollowing Tools In The 1920's?

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>"The articulated arm concept goes back to the 1920s but was never patented or patentable..."

Ron, that is interesting. I had no idea that hollowing tools went back that far, especially an articulated are hollowing system! Who was it who made the articulated arm hollowing system in the 1920's?

Re: Elbo, Monster, et al.

#5

Re: Hollowing Tools In The 1920's?

Ron McKinley

>Stan Townsend ran across the 1920s articulated arm when he was researching his patent for the Elbo Tool. I'm not sure it was related to woodturning/hollowing. .....Ron

Re: Elbo, Monster, et al.

#6

Re: Hollowing Tools In The 1920's?

john lucas

>10 years ago when our club started we had a turner who had an articulated arm he built modified from plans he found somewhere else. It was huge and attached to the end of his lathe with massive swiveling joints. It worked perfectly. I remember him hollowing a cedar bucket in about 15 minutes. I looked for the plans he handed out that night but I've moved twice since then and couldn't lay my hands on them.

Re: Elbo, Monster, et al.

#7

Re: Hollowing Tools In The 1920's?

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>Oh, well articulated arms have been around as long as primates. The man-made ones are just an imitation of nature with maybe just a little improvement. I figured that since articulated arm hollowing systems were being discussed that is what was invented in the 20's.

Re: Elbo, Monster, et al.

#8

Steven Antonucci

Amen.

steve antonucci

>

Re: Elbo, Monster, et al.

#9

Dick Hines

Re: Hollowing Tools In The 1920's?

Dick Hines

>It just goes to show you nothing is truely new.

Re: Elbo, Monster, et al.

#10

Re: Hollowing Tools In The 1920's?

Russ Fairfield

>Which proves my point.

Re: Elbo, Monster, et al.

#11

Re: Unfortunately a patent can be.....

Jamie Donaldson

>...granted to anyone who successfully files the papers, and that is not necessarily the first to actually invent a device. Turning is such a limited market that the expense of filing a patent with legal help is probably more than the potential profit from such a specialized device.

Re: Elbo, Monster, et al.

#12

Keith Tompkins

Re: Unfortunately a patent can be.....

Keith Tompkins

>Jamie, You are correct. As far as I'm concerned, a patent isn't worth the paper it's written on. If you try to defend a patent, you will discover why I say that.

Re: Elbo, Monster, et al.

#13

Re: Unfortunately a patent can be.....

eliot d

>Of course it's a much bigger market ,but I believe the guy who invented the time-delay windshield washer sued one of the big auto manufactures who tried to rip it off -- and won a huge award.

Re: Elbo, Monster, et al.

#14

Re: Patents

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Keith, you're responding to an experienced copyright litigator (Jamie) with first-hand knowledge and a scalp or two on his belt.

|;-}}

Re: Elbo, Monster, et al.

#15

Re: Actually 3 scalps Mark!

Jamie Donaldson

>

Re: Elbo, Monster, et al.

#16

Re: Actually 3 scalps Mark!

Jerry in Indy

>I think this whole mess can be cleared up by Judge Judy

Re: Elbo, Monster, et al.

#17

Unless theirs an Earthquake :)

john lucas

>

Re: Elbo, Monster, et al.

#18

Re: Patents

Ron in Drums PA

>It usually breaks down to "He With The Most Money Wins"

Re: Elbo, Monster, et al.

#19

Steven Antonucci

Who holds the patent on a bowl gouge?

steve antonucci

>I should probably do a quick patent search, and if there isn't one, file it. Then I could sue everyone for violating my patent...

As far as I see it, that seems to be what's happening here. Some filed a patent on a great design, and is trying to extend it's reach to all similar designs, even though they had existed prior to the patent.

Is there a grandfather clause for patents? Can someone actually stop a prior invention from manufacture because they don't hold the patent?

For what it's worth, I hold a degree in engineering, and see the Elbo tool as a great idea, but terrible execution. I see the Monster tool as a huge improvement to a someone else's great idea. Finally, I see the Kobra as a great piece of engineering of someone else's great idea.

Now back to my patent search. I may even broaden the search to include all steel tools for cutting wood, and if I'm lucky, I'll be rich...

Steven

Re: Elbo, Monster, et al.

#20

Re: NO Steve

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>That's not how it works, and the dispute you are referring to has absolutely nothing to do with any patent on any tool, "pending" or otherwise. Please do not exacerbate a situation about which you have no actual knowledge, in which you are not involved.

Please just let those actually involved resolve their differences privately. It really has no place on this Board, and if this keeps going, Ellis is simply going to nuke all of it.

Mark

Re: Elbo, Monster, et al.

#21

Sometimes it helps

Ron in Drums PA

>Mark, I sent you an email but it bounced.

In the email that bounced I gave you a reason why airing this information on boards like this can help.

Re: Elbo, Monster, et al.

#22

Steven Antonucci

Actually, I knew about this months ago

steve antonucci

>And it stopped me from doing something too.

Not because I thought I'd be sued, but just because I don't need any more headaches in my life. All I am asking for is for the parties that are involved to work it out in a way that best benefits the woodturning community.

As a lawyer, I understand that you cannot comment without incurring some potential liability to your professional status. I am not a PE, so I don't need to worry about commenting on my opinion of the whole situation.

I believe that innovation will make the whole tool market stronger (for the hollowing "cheaters" out there that don't freehand :-) and I have the right to express that I disagree with someone attempting to limit competition through litigation. Apparently, a lot of fellow woodturners agree with this position, and we are letting our voices be heard.

You are correct that I don't know the particulars about the alleged patent infringement, and I believe that I've been pretty clear that I don't care. What I care about is choice. Three tools on the market, all of which have thought and engineering design behind them, to accomplish the same tasks that I do with hand held boring bars.

Hannes Michelsen had an interesting comment about his hats. He said that initially he was annoyed when people started copying them, but eventually he took it as a challenge to get better. I think that we're looking at the same thing here, and the market will decide what better means.

Steve

Re: Elbo, Monster, et al.

#23

If I understand the posts, ...

Ed Moore in SW Virginia

>there are two things that are/are not involved:

1. There is not currently any litigation about patent infringement.

2. There is litigation about a Non-Disclosure Agreement.

And it is my OPINION that this whole thing is a Public Relations Disaster -- no matter who is "right" and who is "wrong".

Make boxes, not war!

Ed

Re: Elbo, Monster, et al.

#24

Re: Sometimes it helps

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>email sent

Re: Elbo, Monster, et al.

#25

Keith Tompkins

Re: Patents

Keith Tompkins

>Hey Mark, I think I'd rather be involved in a copyright lawsuit than a patent lawsuit. At least the copyright office doesn't encourage people to improve upon other's copyrighted material. In a letter from the patent office, I was notified that the main purpose of the U.S. Patent office is to encourage innovation....not to protect the patent holder. In my case, my own patent was used as the basis for a newer patent....leaving me swinging in the breeze (with empty pockets)