>I turn (or try to) furniture parts - ie spindle turning. I have a Jet mini. The last several times I've turned anything, I have been getting a lot of chatter and when I turn the lathe off, I see a deep spiral pattern in the wood. This seems to be a new thing. I don't recall seeing it before. I believe my tools are sharp. Any ideas/Tips/suggestions? It could be something very fundamental. I' not much of a turner. Yesterday, I was turning some teak legs for a garden bench and it was really frustrating!
>While I'm far from an expert spindle turner (or any kind of turner), the first question would be, what tool are you using? Spindle gouge, skew? That may help some of the others to know a little more about what you are using.
Also watch to make sure you're not apply pressure or force with the heel of the grind. This will start the chatter.
I'd put a fresh grind on the tools. Final cuts do warrant a fresh grind or hone. If the spindle is thin, "whip" can start at 1" diameter depending on length. As a spindle gets thin it will start to whip like a jump rope causing the spiral/chatter. Excessive tailstock pressure can bend a spindle already into a "whip" formation. Excessive speed can also throw a spindle out of true. As a turner gets more comfortable they often times turn the speed up. This can help but also hinder. A steady can be used, they do fit mini's-or wrapping a finger around the spindle as you cut will "Counter act" the force of the tool-or turn it in steps. Do a 2", or whatever, section at a time. Keep the rest of the spindle thicker to provide support. Once you're done with a section, don't go back, just "blend" the steps together.
If your spindles aren't thin, I'd look at the grind's sharpness or if there's pressure on the heel of the grind. "floating bevels, not RUBBING bevels".
Also the skew is one of the only tools that doesn't require most of it's force "down" onto the spindle. Gouges require more down force than skews. By using a "sharp" skew the forces can be transferred back towards the tailstock or headstock more than down. Hence less pressure to minimize whip.
A good exercise is to rip a 2x4 in half. It's soft wood and cheap. Turn it round and keep doing planing cuts with any tool until it breaks. There's no danger of a thin spindle breaking. It will just drop. How thin can you get it? Then try another tool and do it again. You'll learn what tools work best for certain applications and wood tools can get you out of jam if you get into one.
>Tony First of all what size and what length are you turning. It it's a jet mini without the bed extension you should only get chatter with spindles under an inch thick.
If it's not your tool usage (and it could be) the first thing to check is the spindle. On this lathe the tension the handwheel puts on the spring on the outboard side affects how smooth the spindle runs. Loosen the set screws and tighten the handle (it's left hand threaded) until you feel the spindle bind a little. Then back it off a hair so the spindle move freely and tighten the set screws. If that doesn't work and your sure it's not your turning then I would suspect the bearings. I've turned on a lot of Jet mini's and some were quite old and not had a bearing replacement on any of them.
If your getting chatter from the tools and they are sharp then it's probably from applying too much pressure on the bevel. Lighten up the pressure there and maybe cup your fingers over or under the piece and apply light pressure on the opposite side of where the bevel is rubbing. This usually works fine for me. I turn flexible woods about 10" long and 5/8" diameter between centers and dampen it quite well this way.
I'll agree that the most likely reason would be too much pressure. The key is in your left hand. First, grip the tool shaft gently with your thumb on one side and your fingers on the other. Use this grip to cradle the tool and NOT to push into the wood. Take your left hand completely OFF of the tool rest so you do not use it as a fulcrum for applying pressure. Your left hand should gently guide the tool without pushing it into the wood. See the photo in the Stu Batty post. If you are using a gouge, round off the heel of the bevel so you cannot use that as a fulcrum. Gently guide the cutting edge of your tool, working from larger to smaller diameter. Using these techniques, you should first be able to remove the ridges, and then make clean cuts. Give it a try, Gary
I'm not much of a turner, but my most recent project involves turning 15 sixteen inch long spindles 3/8" diameter at one end and 1/2" diameter at the other.
I was getting quite a bit of spiraling early on. I started using some green-ish elm (seasoned one year in log form, then riven off into turning blanks and turned immediately). With this wood I got lots of spiraling even when turning pieces 1" in diameter.
I tried some pieces in kiln-dried oak and got loads less spiraling - I think the oak is stiffer compared to the flexible wet elm.
As my technique improved I got much less spiraling:
1) I used a super sharp skew with very light pressure, and used one hand as a steady rest.
2) I actually slowed my lathe speed down. I found that I got worse spiraling at higher rpm. My final passes used low rpm and a low skew travel rate.
3) If spriralling starts, you have to back your skew up to a point before the spiral exists and restart your cut. If you just try to clean up the spiralled area by recutting it, your bevel rides the spiral and you end up recutting a new spiral.
4) If you have very light spiralling on a flexible spindle (eg. 3/8" diameter), just give up and use sandpaper to get rid of it. It isn't my first preference, but I can remove spiraling in about 20 seconds with 220 grit sandpaper or I can mess around for 15 minutes with a skew then switch to sandpaper when I give up.
5) My technique is better moving from left to right than vice-versa, so my final pass moves in that direction.
6) I also found that some parts of the blanks responded better to a long-point-down cut compared to the long-point-up cut that I normally use. I think the long-point-down cut also acts as a bit of a steady rest because the cut is oriented more downwards into the tool rest compared to the more horizontal cut you get with the other skew orientation.
>Lots of good stuff to work with here. I guess I left off some important info. This is happening with pretty much all my tools! I use a 3/4" rougher, a 1/2" spindle, and a 1" skew. The stock is generally pretty thick (furniture legs - ~2" diam.). I wouldn't be surprised if I was applying too much force and rubbing the heel. I am not a confident turner and I tend to tense up. This is a relatively new phenomena for me. I've turned plenty in the past without this issue (had plenty of other issues though!). This particular project is a piece of teak that is 2" in diameter down to around 1 1/2" diam. I was pretty happy with my pommels until I brought the tool too close and caught the corners and lifted some grain - oops. I glued it back down and only lost a small chip on one corner. Thanks for the help. I'll have to get back out there tonight and see if I can make leg #2 look like #1. I'm still at that stage where if anything comes out well, it was by accident, so making duplicates is a real challenge. One thing I did notice the other day was I had the rest so low I was almost scraping with the rougher. Someday, I'm going to take some turning lessons and let somebody see what I'm doing wrong fundamentally.
>A couple of other tips. Sometimes a tool with a smaller cutting edge will stop the chatter. If your using a 1/2" spindle gouge and have access to a 3/8" or 1/4" try that. You also might try moving the tool rest as close as you can.