Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

wet turned bowl question

Posts

wet turned bowl question

#1

wet turned bowl question

Phil in NJ

>Hi,

I had roughed, then cored a set of walnut bowls from wet wood where the largest is approximately 15" diameter x 7" tall. The wall thickness of the largest bowl was about 1.5".

Though I wrapped the largest bowl in 2 layers of paper bags to slow the drying, it started developing cracks on the outside. The pith is not in the blank, and there were no defects, inclusions, or splits left from the rough that would expand into these cracks. I turned the cracks away and re-wrapped it again... I checked again 2 weeks later and again more cracks. I think if I'd left it alone, it would have cracked through into the interior, wasting the bowl.

So, today I gave up and turned the 15" bowl to completion, down to 1/2" wall thickness. So far so good...

The question is: should I try to slow the drying process of the finish-turned bowl? Or just let it dry and hope?

Thanks!

Phil

Re: wet turned bowl question

#2

Re: wet turned bowl question

Greg Haugen

>Since you're "Coring" bowls I'm assuming you know you should have equal wall thicknesses. No real thick bottomed bowls for drying,etc. I'd "control" the drying. Since you say it's "finish turned" you don't want to add anchorseal or anything more to it. I'd put it in a brown bag or even a box (then shut the box's flaps) along with some of the shavings from the turning. The shavings will keep some moisture in the "micro environment" restricting the bowl to dry too quickly.

Wood dries by the movment of air over the surface. Some hollowform turners turn to finish thickness and place the form in a closed box. In a couple of days, they open one flap, in a few more days they open the other. Control. By restricting the air movement or keeping it a little "humid" (with the shavings) for a gradual drop there's less stress on the wet wood to dry.

Another consideration is where the wood came from. Often times you may not know when you see a log felled already. "Trunk" wood usually has an aprox. centered pith and equal growth rings. "Limb" wood the pith is often off centered and unequal growth rings. Limbs don't growth straight up like a trunk usually does. Gravity causes more water in the wood cells to "sag" or stay lower on the limb. The wide section of growth rings is the underside of the limb, the narrow side is the upper side. It's harder for the tree to "Carry" water to the upper half of the limb. Wood with irregular rings can be difficult to dry. Some may call it "reactionary" wood. The narrow and wide rings react differently and often crack at the differences of the stresses. When I come across this I'll take one bowl usually or two but I'll split it so the bowl has the same growth rings, not half and half. This can be done and I've done it but it can cause problems to have a bowl with narrow and wide rings.

Bill Luce is a turner that uses the grain and balances it amazingly. www.billluce.com. I'd also recommend watching John Jordan's DVD Aesthestics and Properties of Wood, which is excellent. www.johnjordanwoodturning.com Our club just had John demo but I missed it, I have seen the dvd though.

When I'm turning bowls to "twice turn" them dry for utility bowls. Sometimes I'll anchorseal the whole bowl and sometimes just the end grain. Depending on wood and how soon I want it back on the lathe. If I just end grain seal it, I'm usually doing a lage batch of bowls and they stay in the shop with the shavings for a day or two to slow that initial drying with the humidity or I'll bag them with some of the shavings for awhile. If I'm in a big hurry, I'll use DNA or finish turn it as a round bottomed utility bowl and let the wood do what it will do. These twisted and warped organic bowls are often the best sellers. Go Figure.

One final though. Large bowls, above 13-14 inches. Are a pain to dry. I've had the most success when I've gone slightly less than the 10% rule but I'm also being very mindful of the grain and trying to balance it. More wood is harder to dry but it's tought to finish turn a bowl and "run out of wood" also. It's a balancing act.

Sorry I wrote a novel. Hopefully something is of interest.

Greg H.

Re: wet turned bowl question

#3

Re: wet turned bowl question

GaryG in MD

>Phil,

I'd recommend that you read up on Dave Smith's alcohol soak method. Follow Dave's instructions to the letter (particularly the drying part after the soak). It should work for you.

Just look in the WC Archives. See, for example,

http://www.woodcentral.com/cgi-bin/archives_turning.pl?read=113285&v1=e2vrt43&v2=hand+plane&v4=bar+clamp&v5=tyr6gh

...Gary

Re: wet turned bowl question

#4

Steven Antonucci

Sapwood or heartwood?

steve antonucci

>I've had the same issue with walnut of any size. The cracks can sometime be turned out, but sometimes will progress all the way through.

I am a fan of DNA soaking, and walnut seems to benefit from it. Where in NJ are you?

Steve

Re: wet turned bowl question

#5

Re: Sapwood or heartwood?

phil in NJ

>I'm in Montclair NJ.

It's part sapwood part heartwood. The cracks seemed to be forming on the end grain on both sides of the bowl. I'll just wrap it up again and let it dry slowly.

Thanks all!

-Phil

Re: wet turned bowl question

#6

Steven Antonucci

Are you a NJ Woodturners member?

steve antonucci

>If not, we're having a meeting tonight in Roseland.

You are welcome to come by. Bring the bowl or roughout, and I'll bring one too. We can compare notes.

Steve

Re: wet turned bowl question

#7

ditto on achorsealing rough-turned bowls

adrien

>

Re: wet turned bowl question

#8

Re: wet turned bowl question

robo hippy

>I prefer to turn green to final thickness, then let them dry and warp before sanding and finishing. Note, if you want to sand them on the lathe, you need a lathe that will go down to 10 rpm or so to sand. Most of the variable speed lathes can do this, but you may have to call the factory so they can tell you how to adjust the inverter properly. They come factory set to turn off at about 50 rpm. As far as the drying, there are more ways to dry than there are gouge profiles. On testing the DNA and LDD (dishwashing soap) soaks, with thin turned bowls (1/2 to 1/4 or less) there is no measurable difference in drying time, movement, or cracking, and I say this after drying several hundred bowls in the DNA, a thousand or more air dried, and a couple thousand LDD soaked. I still use the LDD because bowls soaked in it sand out a LOT easier than the other ways. DNA actually seems to make the wood harder.

I have long thought that the success of the DNA was because of the wrapping of the outside of the bowl, and not the soaking. I am putting this to the test. Madrone is the most difficult wood to dry that I have run across. Leaving one 1/2 inch thick without boiling is considered suicide. I turned a number of them, and left them 1/2 inch thick. I then wrapped the outside. I was using that plastic film (6 inch wide that you use to wrap boxes on a pallet so they don't spill) on the rim, and a couple of wraps of newspaper on the rest of the outside. I also did a few that were wrapped only in the plastic (no condensation on the inside of the plastic, but they took longer to dry), and a couple that were wrapped only on the rim. I also tried apple, big leaf maple, and English walnut. The success rate was almost 100%. I even left some with knots in them which also will guarantee cracking. The idea is that with the wrap, the inside of the bowl dries first, and the outside second. What this is supposed to do is pull the outside in towards the inside drying the blank in a compression mode. This does make some sence to me. While I have only dried a hundred or so bowls this way, I think it works. Will it work on thick bowls? I would imagine so, but I haven't tried it as I don't do that style. I do think this is less mess than anchor sealing the blanks.

robo hippy