>After having been away from woodworking for a few years I'm starting back up and of course protecting my lungs is an issue. I have a good half-face respirator with new filters but am curious about the powered respirators. As far as actual protection, if fitted properly is there a difference? I would assume if they fit properly and have the same class of filter the protection would be the same but there would of course be the differences in comfort, convenience, etc. I used to use the Dustfoe (like miners wear) but now use a double cannister version from 3M. My wife ( a scroll saw nut )uses the Dust-be-gone and I am trying to convince her to use a respirator also. We are running a Jet air cleaner and a single stage dust collector but will be upgrading to a cyclone by the end of summer (that will be another thread) Any thoughts, opinions etc are very welcome. Thanks folks...
>Has anyone used the AirShield Pro? and how does it compare to the Original?
They are on sale over here for $290 and $220 respectively.
With the $10 off $250 offer on the right hand column of the page, it is down to $280 for AirShield Pro, that is more than $80 cheaper than other places. I am tempted, but would like to hear some first hand report.
I have not purchased from this company for several years; I am still on their email list. No affiliation.
>..>> I own both of them and I'm the happiest with the regular Trend. The pro is safer but has more plastic to go around your face. There are two drawbacks for me; 1. I have a beard so while the pro is safer, it's not comfortible. 2. It only goinfg yto be used by me in the winter because I'm in Israel and it's way too hot for about 6-8 months out of the year.
If it's comfotible, it's safer because you'll actually wear it instead of leaving it on the shelf.
>I use the Resp-o-rater. It has hepla filters and filters our 99+% of the sawdust down to 1 or 2 microns. It also doesn't use batteries so you don't have batteries running down in the middle of a "work" session. I found that the rechargable batteries usually ran down on me in the middle of a turning session. It is also reasonable priced at about $50. You can check out their website at Duxteriy.com. I don't have any affiliation with them, just a satisfied user.
With that said I will try to provide an objective review.
I have had the unit since it first became available back in March. I bought the unit, spare overlays, a spare set of filters, the earmuffs.
I fully charged the battery as the unit arrived at my home in the evening and I first tried the unit out the next evening.
My initial impression was that the unit was well made. When I went to put the unit on it was hard for me to get the thing to fit without HURTING my head, The front part of the "seal" dug into my forehead. After several tries at getting the unit to fit without digging into my forehead I had the unit on and running.
The air is blown down across your face. But the seal also goes over your head. The seal keeps the heat in and the air blowing across your face keep your face comfortable but the heat coming off my balding head makes a lot of heat. In less than 1/2 hour I had streams of sweat running down my face and neck.
The fan, battery and filters are all located on top of your head. This is all top heavy and makes the unit feel like it is going to fall off. The unit doesn't fall off. Instead it feels like it is going to fall and it pulls on the underside of your chin to stay on your head.
The fan is noisy. I have worn the unit for at least 20 hours. I expected the noise to become less objectionable the longer I used it. This has not been the case. The noise is just as objectionable now as it was when I first put the unit on.
The earmuffs have worked much more poorly than I expected. I have several sets of earmuffs all of which work a LOT better than the Trend attached earmuffs. I usually need to wiggle the regular earmuffs to achieve a good noise seal. I can't wiggle the Trend earmuffs to achieve that good noise seal. I can press against the earmuffs and get a good noise seal. Once I remove the pressure from my hands the noise seal is lost.
The Trend Airshield Pro doesn't work for me.
Uncomfortable
Hot
Unbalanced
Top heavy
Noisy
Poor earmuff noise seal
I previously had the Racal power visor. I found that unit much more comfortable, cooler, balance achieved and fairly quite.
Please note that these are my impressions. Maybe I am overly sensitive or maybe I have a fat head.
I hope you have better luck with your choice than I had.
>There is a lot of stuff in the turning world where one can buy something that is not as good as something else and get along with it for a long time. I don't consider safety equipment to be in that category. People will argue about the best lathe, the best chuck, the best gouge, etc, and it is all pretty much a function of how much you can afford and how much you are really into this stuff.
But whether you turn on a $125.00 Harbor Freight or a $7000.00 Robust, the dust you breathe is all the same. How much are your lungs worth to you? This is the one place where I advise people to buy the best they can, and the best is the 3M Airstream. It ain't cheap, but neither is reconstructive surgery or emphysema. The unit is well balanced, well built, comfortable, and uses HEPA filters. I can wear it on very hot days and have cool air blowing over my entire head and face. I have taken some very hard shots to the face with no damage, even to the face shield of the respirator. I've owned mine for almost 11 years now, and I would not be without it. The initial price is a tough thing to overcome, but when you amortize it over the life of the unit, it is very affordable indeed, and is probably less than you pay for your insurance deductible. And, it is capable of saving you a lot of pain and suffering, both from short term traumatic injury and from long term breathing problems that amount to a slow and painful death. How's that for a cheery thought?
>I have the Powervisor, which is much the same as the Trend. But, it is now safely in the box being replaced by am Airstream. There is no real comparison between the two. The Airstream has submicron filtration which is what you need. The Powervisor and Trend are adverstised for "nusiance" dust, which is what is stopped by your body anyway. The submicron is what does the damage to your lungs. The airpickup for the Airstream is also at the back of the helmet, while the Powervisor and Trend are in the front - where it is being made. And since neither the Powervisor or Trend has submicons filters, you are pumping captive submicron dust across your face.
The battery pack on mine will last for over 12 straight hours. The longest I have used mine was for 14-15 hours, but that was with a couple of breaks. Part of the rating for powered respirators is the CFM, which is around 6. To get the ratings that the Airstream has, they have to deliver that CFM for the duration of use. That means that they have to deliver 6CFM at the end of the 12 hour duty cycle. My Powervisor would start off at close to 6CFM but would fall within a short time period (i.e. minutes).
I like the full helmet, it is well balanced with the motor in the back. The battery in on a 2 belt I wear over my smock. It is in the back out of the way, and I don't even notice the weight. The helmet is also like wearing body armor for when those errant pieces of wood depart from the chuck or explode in your face. These days, I don't turn anything witout wearing my Airstream. I am allergic to some woods (Cedar, Oak, and Elm) and have severe sinus problems. I recently turned some aromatic cedar and could not tell it was cedar except for the color (and I knew what it was). There was none of the smell which would normally start my allergies going.
I spent a little more on mine, getting the smart charger with it. This is the only way to go. It will charge only what the battery needs and then go into trickle mode. You can leave the battery on charfe until you need it, use it for 30 minutes of six hours and put it back on charge - it will charge only what was used and not overcharge as it would be with a fixed 16 hour charge time. It was $135 and worth every penny. I raced model airplanes for 30 years and and have several of those for my models. We found out years ago that those were the best types of chargers, we had a lot less battery problems when we started using them.
I have one of those Jet bag units. It does an excellent job of moving dust from one part of the room to another. It has been replaced with a good cyclone unit that is a real dust collector. It filters down at the submicron level. I have a dust hood that actually works and I can get about 90% of the dust. The Airstream is good for the other 10%, which is right in your face. With the Oneida running, I can see a stream of dust comming off the gouge going into the dust hood. The only time it is not running when I am running my lathe is when I am turning green wood. But, for all else when the lathe is running the dust collector is running. I did some reasearch and found that the cost of the AIrstream and Oneida was still cheaper than a lung transplant, so I don't consider the cost that great from that perspective.......
Re: You have to breathe with your mouth and not yo
Tommy Holmes
>I adjusted to breathing through my mouth quite readily. So much so that I don't use the nose clip. I can easily change to breathing through my nose when I step outside the shop and at times forget that I'm wearing it and find myself going into the house with it on.
I've worn it cutting the grass and have gotten some swivel necking by people driving by looking at it. It is odd looking but works great.
>I'm no expert in health matters so I'm only suggesting people to look into this topic further and not saying the resp-o-rators should be avoided. I read somewhere mouth breathing is problematic because air is not filtered and warmed as much as when inhaled through the nose, as it bypasses the nasal canal and sinuses, and dries out the mouth.
Of course, things are relative. Mouth breathing (divers do it) shouldn't be a big concern for a normal person if it's not a prolonged method of breathing or it doesn't become the habit of breathing when one is not doing woodworking.