Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Sharpening question I forgot to ask at Five Barns

Posts

Sharpening question I forgot to ask at Five Barns

#1

Sharpening question I forgot to ask at Five Barns

wilbur

>Stupid me. There I was with all that expert turning advice at my disposal, and I forgot to ask the two questions I wanted to ask. I blame my boys for distracting me. :@)

Here's my sharpening question. After sharpening a gouge, either with a grinder or a Tormek-type system, do you touch up the inside of the gouge, either with a leather profiling wheel or a slipstone? it seems to me that sharpening just the outside would raise a little of a burr, which on a chisel or plane blade I would then sharpen off. I figure what's good for a chisel must be good for a turning tool.

Re: Sharpening question I forgot to ask at Five Barns

#2

Nada after sharpening

Dominic Greco in Richboro PA

>Wilbur,

You wrote:

"After sharpening a gouge, either with a grinder or a Tormek-type system, do you touch up the inside of the gouge, either with a leather profiling wheel or a slipstone?"

I know that some people out there hone after grinding, but IMHO I never have. The burr disappears shortly after you touch the wood. So it's not much help on a bowl gouge.

HOWEVER, it is common practice to raise a burr after sharpening a scraper. This produces a tool that takes a finer cut. Sometimes you need that, other times you don't.

Also, some people touch up a skew with a slip stone rather than drag it over to a grinder to sharpen. I've done this on occasion.

I hope that answer your question.

See ya around,

Dominic

Re: Sharpening question I forgot to ask at Five Barns

#3

Re: Nada after sharpening

john lucas

>Most of the time no but fairly often for the last cuts I will use a Diamond Fish hook sharpener to hone the inside of the flute. I light touch with an ultra fine diamond hone on the outside this fish hook hone on the inside and you will be surprised how well the tool cuts.

Re: Sharpening question I forgot to ask at Five Barns

#4

Re: Sharpening question I forgot to ask at Five Ba

davidwalser

>Well, I wasn't in attendance at Five Barns, so I hope you won't mind my answering anyway. Many, if not most, of the turners I've spoken with do not hone after sharpening. Some very well respected turners do hone. Watch one of Alan Lacer's videos and you'll come away believing that honing is mandatory! He claims (in his Projects Along the Woodturning Trail video) that he can turn two or three bowls without resharpening as long as he hones in between trips to the grinder. (This is a very well done video. If you've been turning a while, you might not agree with everything Alan says or does, but you'll still learn a lot and have a lot of fun in the process.)

My advice: Try honing for a while and see if it makes a difference for you. I've been using a Tormek for awhile now. I like the edge after honing on the leather wheel much more than I do straight off the stone. Using the jig, it takes almost no time to hone the edge once or twice in between sharpenings. YMMV.

Re: Sharpening question I forgot to ask at Five Barns

#5

Re: Sharpening question I forgot to ask at Five Ba

Greg Haugen

>Wilbur,

There is a purpose for everything. Honing is most often done to the inside of the gouge's flute. It's easier and less likely to "roll over" the edge that was just sharpened compared to trying to hone the "bevel" that's only 1/8 to 1/4" wide. For the most part, bowl turners like the edge right off of the grinder. Think of it like a bread knife and bread. Some also like a honed edge. Spindle turners will hone their skews and sometimes the inside of the gouges. Alan Lacer has a diamond hone with radiused profiles on the sides for this purpose. Skews have to be "scary sharp". A grinder's wheel doesn't produce a keen-enough edge. So they should be honed with a diamond hone, etc. For stubborn woods I'll take it one step further and polish mine on a mdf wheel charged with White Rouge to an near "mirrored finish". Nick Cook uses a tormek for a lot of his sharpening. His skews will still come off the tormek (a very fine grit wheel) and will be honed either with the leather strop of the tormek or a diamond hone.

Honing has a strong foundation in production turning. Instead of stopping, going to a grinder to touch a tool a turner could simply take a diamond hone from their apron's pocket and touch up a tool in a few swipes and be back turning in a couple of seconds. Time is money.

I'd recommend for you to try it both ways. Start a bowl and put a fresh from the grinder edge and make a few cuts. Then do the same thing with a honed edge. I have also seen turners make their own "slip sticks" with a turned dowel and some of the black wet/dry sanding paper. Diamond hones that are used by turners are usually 600 grit.

An interesting side note. A bowl gouge is one of the only woodworking tools that is sometimes used without a keen sharp edge. You'd never use a chisel, planer, or jointer with that kind of edge on it.

Scrapers. I use scrapers in box making. My sharpening technique I've learned from Chris Stott. I'll hone the top of a scraper before I grind it. I want to remove any "remains" of the previous burr. I want a fresh burr. If a scraper is too aggressive or dealing with a wood that is a known "grabber" I'll hone the fresh burr back off after sharpening. This takes alot of the aggressiveness out of a scraper. Also, even though I haven't tried it, there are some that are honing the grinder burr off and raising a new "uniform" burr afterwards with a burnisher. Recently I was talking with Don Derry about this. It's supposed to be a better finish to the cut/scrape and have more control compared to a grinder burr. Think of that bread knife again and then roll it over. Not a great edge and not uniform. Now take a keen chef's knife and roll the edge, a nice uniform keen edge. It's also a "cabinetmakers" technique for cabinet scrapers. I have not tried this, but wish to do so soon. I've used "grinder" burr or No burr scrapers.

Hope this helps. The main point is to try different things (grinder edge vs. keen edge) and see what works for you.

Greg H.

Re: Sharpening question I forgot to ask at Five Barns

#6

Re: Sharpening question I forgot to ask at Five Ba

davidwalser

>"Scrapers. I use scrapers in box making. My sharpening technique I've learned from Chris Stott. I'll hone the top of a scraper before I grind it. I want to remove any "remains" of the previous burr. I want a fresh burr. If a scraper is too aggressive or dealing with a wood that is a known "grabber" I'll hone the fresh burr back off after sharpening. This takes alot of the aggressiveness out of a scraper. Also, even though I haven't tried it, there are some that are honing the grinder burr off and raising a new "uniform" burr afterwards with a burnisher. Recently I was talking with Don Derry about this. It's supposed to be a better finish to the cut/scrape and have more control compared to a grinder burr. Think of that bread knife again and then roll it over. Not a great edge and not uniform. Now take a keen chef's knife and roll the edge, a nice uniform keen edge. It's also a "cabinetmakers" technique for cabinet scrapers."

I was told by Jeff Farris (of Toermek) that it's best to hone off the burr when using a scraper on end grain. For kinds of scraper work, it's best to keep the burr. My own "tests" are too limited in nature for me to have reached my on conclusion.

Re: Sharpening question I forgot to ask at Five Barns

#7

Steven Antonucci

As a Tormek owner

steve antonucci

>here is my general method of work:

For roughing out, the edge off of the grinder is plenty good for producing a roughing cut.

As the tool dulls, I have a small fine diamond stone that I used to maintain (aka, resharpen) the edge. I gently stroke the edge until I can see a small mark on the heel and the cutting edge. This gets me through the rough out.

When finish cuts approach, I return to the Tormek for a fresh edge. At this point, I will hone the edge on the leather wheel, but just the edge, not the whole bevel. Makes no sense to polish the bevel, since it doesn't cut. Sometimes, I will just hand strop a skew for the same effect. It doesn't take much time with white diamond, and maybe two-three passes per side.

Steve

Re: Sharpening question I forgot to ask at Five Barns

#8

Re: As a Tormek owner

davidwalser

>My approach used to be very similar to Steve's (and might still be if I could find my diamond hone :)). However, since I acquired the new Turning Tool Setter (TTS-100), I might not use my diamond hone even if I could lay my hands on it. As long as I've not used the Tormek for some other tool, re-honing an edge takes less than 30 seconds. All I do is load the bowl gouge in the jig (SVD-185), use the TTS-100 to set the protrusion, and hone on the leather wheel (the universal support is already the correct distance from the wheel because I've not moved it since I last honed my bowl gouge). It's quick enough I don't know there's a reason to NOT use the Tormek and, I believe, the edge off Tormek's leather wheel is better than I could obtain using my missing diamond hone.

Re: Sharpening question I forgot to ask at Five Barns

#9

Steven Antonucci

No arguments here...

steve antonucci

>I also have the same setup, and it's only a matter of seconds to resharpen, but I use the diamond stone for convenience. On days that I can't find it, I take the time to use my Tormek.

Only machine in my shop that can't be upgraded...

Steven

Re: Sharpening question I forgot to ask at Five Barns

#10

Re: As a Tormek owner

wilbur

>Just to be clear, I was asking about honing/sharpening the inside of the flute on the gouge after you've finished working on the bevel, and whether that was useful.

I have a Tormek as well, and I agree that the time needed to sharpen or hone a gouge is really not as long as people might think.

Re: Sharpening question I forgot to ask at Five Barns

#11

Steven Antonucci

I don't "hone" the flute

steve antonucci

>Conceptually, I think you'd only have to "surface" it one time, and certainly not the whole length. I think it might be a point of dimishing returns though, unless the tool is severely pitted or rusted inside. Then, you just buy a new one that isn't...

I have the small honing wheel for flutes, and occassionally, I will run the flute over it for a few seconds (but only an inch or so) to strop off any steel that may have been ground above the bevel. I do it by hand, and it's about 5 secs of work, no more...

Steve

Re: Sharpening question I forgot to ask at Five Barns

#12

Re: As a Tormek owner

davidwalser

>Gee, Wilbur, what's wrong with answering a question you didn't ask? ;)

I do hone the inside of the flute (using the Tormek's profiled leather wheel). I can't say it makes any difference, but I do it.