Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Unique piece of wood.............

Posts

Unique piece of wood.............

#1

Unique piece of wood.............

jake Niedling

>Here is a picture of the start of 14" maple bowl. When I chainsawed the tree section into 2 halves, it appears that it grew around another tree or limb. You can see in the photo of the roughed out bowl where this limb was located in the dead center. Now the questions is whether to turn it away into a shallower bowl or keep in in the finish bowl? Any thoughts.


img

Re: Unique piece of wood.............

#2

Re: 2nd picture

jake Niedling

>Another view.


img

Re: Unique piece of wood.............

#3

Peter Charles Fagg (UK)

Re: Unique piece of wood.............

Peter Charles Fagg (UK)

>If it were my piece I think I would try to incorporate it so giving the piece a unique identity.

If a bowl is turned so that as much as possible of the indentation is kept through the wall it would add that extra wow factor and a history.

Peter.

Re: Unique piece of wood.............

#4

Re: Unique piece of wood.............

john lucas

>I agree with Charles. It would sort of look like some of Bill Luce's bowls. My first thought was this a golden opportunity for carving but I think I like the idea of the natural void which gives it a story.

Re: Unique piece of wood.............

#5

Re: Unique piece of wood.............

John Leonard

>I agree with Peter and John. If you turn it out it"s just another bowl. John L.

Re: Unique piece of wood.............

#6

Re: Another vote for keeping it

Steve in NC

>It will make for a unique bowl with a built in story.

Re: Unique piece of wood.............

#7

Re: 2nd picture

charlie belden

>When faced with a gift horse, it's best not to try and turn it into a miniature pony.

I can see the piece - filled with wool - some of it spilling out the opening left by a long departed branch of a noble tree - the wool just asking to be spun into yarn - for a baby's knitted booties, or a little girls wool cap, or a warm scarf for an old man to wear on a cold winter day.

Turn the most beautiful bowl you are capable of turning - and leave the void left by the lost branch for others to do with as they will. They will fill in the opening - perhaps with the memory of the one who turned this bowl.

Or not.

charlie belden

Re: Unique piece of wood.............

#8

Re: Unique piece of wood.............

Dale Cook

>Hi Jake,I would leave the void, I've done this several times where I had one or more voids and I put a rim of contrasting wood on the top spanning over the void or voids and has work quite well. Either way I would leave it. Good luck!

Re: Unique piece of wood.............

#9

Here it is with inside roughed out....

jake Niedling

>I decided to rough out the bowl and leave the void through both side walls. End grain coated with sealer. So it will be a few months before you see the finished product. Hope it stays together.


img

Re: Unique piece of wood.............

#10

Re: Unique piece of wood.............

Ron McKinley

>That's really unique. By all means keep it! .......Ron

Re: Unique piece of wood.............

#11

Bummer-I wanted to see it on the 30th

john lucas

>

Re: Unique piece of wood.............

#12

Re: Here it is with inside roughed out....

charlie belden

>Leave the walls thick to emphasize the missing branch - undercut if you must.

An opportunity with so many possibilities.

Re: Unique piece of wood.............

#13

Peter Charles Fagg (UK)

Re: Here it is with inside roughed out....

Peter Charles Fagg (UK)

>I agree with Charlie, keep the top surface thick and possibly undercut, the internal shadow produced will give added depth to the whole piece.

Peter.