Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Twice Turned Boxes and Hollow Forms

Posts

Twice Turned Boxes and Hollow Forms

#1

Twice Turned Boxes and Hollow Forms

Cyril Griesbach

>I'm throwing this out to all the box and HF turners who twice turn their work.

Assuming that you wait for your wet turning to dry regardless of which drying method you use...What drying problems, if any, do you have with leaving a tenon on that is heavier than your rough turned thickness?

I've had my best luck with the alcohol drying process and less with sealing and bagging or microwave and I'd like to stay with the DNA.

Any and all help will be appreciated.

Cyril

Re: Twice Turned Boxes and Hollow Forms

#2

Steven Antonucci

I don't like twice turning hollowforms

steve antonucci

>The few I have tried have resulted in catastrophic failure. One Maple vessel that I turned hollow to about 1" thick split open by 1" on the one side. Not saying that it can't be done, but I think it's a better strategy to turn to finish relatively thin. If you cut to less than a 1/4" they are dry in a day.

Steven

Re: Twice Turned Boxes and Hollow Forms

#3

Re: Twice Turned Boxes and Hollow Forms

john lucas

>I have had some problems with the thicker tenon,so what do is to coat the entire bottom 3" of the vessel with endgrain sealer inside and out. That seems to have helped although I don't do enough of them to have a real consensus.

Re: Twice Turned Boxes and Hollow Forms

#4

Re: Twice Turned Boxes and Hollow Forms

mfoster

>I usually twice turn hollow forms, especially if I am going to do some carving or enhancements. I will turn to completion a number of hollow forms if I don't care about distortion or think it will enhance the final piece.

I have tried several methods to deal with the tenon issue. I, like you, tend to prefer the DNA drying method. It seems to lessen issues with splitting etc. I will sometimes combine the DNA method with sealing the bottom end grain as John does. My thought here is that the end grain will lose EtOH or water much quicker than the side grain in the rest of the piece, so I want to slow it down. I don't coat the inside of the end grain. I will also keep a full length tenon, but scoop out the bottom of it to decrease the bulk. I usually either oversize the tenon so that once trued up after drying it will still fit the chuck, or plan on using smaller jaws for the second turning.

I have had a few checks using this method (mostly repairable) and don't recall ever having a catastrophic failure of a hollow form. I have had numerous bowl failures, but none with hollow forms. I attribute this to much less wood movement in hollow forms as opposed to side grain bowls.

Mike

Re: Twice Turned Boxes and Hollow Forms

#5

Re: Twice Turned Boxes and Hollow Forms

Cyril Griesbach

>Thanks for your help and advice, gentlemen.